rjay

By the metrics on this thread he must be a failure...his team currently in 11th. Not likely to make the 8 after a premiership year. What's wrong with McRae and his FD?

Reckon he does have a say (one of a few) but who has the final say? It would be interesting to know.

This is interesting. Hannebery said last Sunday that the Swans were loading. He said just adding a little bit to the training is enough to flatten you on match day. Someone else, can't remember if it was Hodge or Sanderson said clubs don't do loading anymore as the season is now too long and physically hard. They get their loading match days. So, who knows. ...but I wouldn't think it's an excuse for a loss like last nights unless they are flogging to absolute s... out of them on the track. edit: and I don't think loading is very sexy for the experts as it takes away a lot of their analysis. Think of all the fun they will be having over the Swans this week. They've been worked out, there turnover game is in disarray, Is Longmire the right guy?

Mid season draft maybe...

If he can come back in a Trent Croad situation and win us another flag then yes, I definitely want him back.

Wouldn't by me. I reckon he let us down badly and maybe cost us another flag going home... I hope they never win one in his time there. He can come back if he want's another flag.

Sydney have been the best team this year. Having a down patch but just in time to ramp it up for the finals. ...but as is always the case, the team with the fittest list at the end will win.

He will be up there I would think...not sure if he could win it but he's been consistent.

I was at Waverley for that one...the 1988 GF is another. Many other disappointing games through the late 60's, 70's & 80's.

He's no front runner 'picket', unfortunately he's a great young player. Unfortunately because he plays for them not us...

Fair chance we could finish 13/14...although they say it's an even draft this year. The myths of the draft.. This is a super draft He is a generational talent This is an even/deep draft

I've believed for most of this season that we need to reset the list. The talk of making finals this year, it's not happening. Any chance went out the window with Trac's injury & probably earlier with Gus' s retirement. Reset with a decent draft hand, good trade period & go again in 2025.

Not sure about Carlton but the Swans have been loading and most probably in a loading phase now. Hannebery talked about it earlier today on SEN. For those that have doubted the efficacy of loading and the effect it has in season then maybe worth listen. For those with a closed mind, then don't bother.

...Ryan is more believable than most.

I do think it's funny the excuses (reasonable) being made for Carlton...injury and 5 day break. If it was us a lot on here would be saying it was Goodwin & dismissing the injury and 5 day break excuse as weak.

Come on 'DD'...you've watched the Casey games. There is no way that he is competitive enough in the ruck to play the position at AFL level. If you are going to attack anything it should be the list management decisions not selection.

The question is, who do we bring in that will do better? I don't think we have a better option than Petty & JVR until Max gets back.

Neither is Fullarton..

You never know why decisions are made unless you're in the room...we are all guessing and as I've said before I would have selected Grundy like most of us but who knows the extenuating circumstances.

If you've seen Fullarton at Casey then you would know that wasn't going to happen. Better to at least have Petty marking ability around the ground...

OK, so who was this specialist ruckman we should have selected 'SWYL'???

I think this is one of the issues with Will... ...and against good VFL ruckmen he has struggled to provide a consistent contest. You can blame selection as much as you like, but when the cupboards bare...

It's the truth...we don't have anyone apart from Max who can compete in ruck contests at that level. People want him to talk straight then he does and others complain. I know it's a no win situation.

If we look at our best 5 players coming into this season we could probably say Max, Trac, Clary, Gus and May. 3 of those are out, 1 at half power and the other going ok. We get the results we should pretty much expect. We don't have the star power on the ground to win against top teams. No coach is going to fix that, genius or not.

It's really not 'norm'...these are list management decisions. Goody has some input but the decision is not his alone.