damienjr

Hopefully the club will offer him another 12 month contract that will make it worthwhile.

Lazy response. How could you have stopped the Smith revelation, which came out of the blue and was taken out of our hands immediately? What would you have done differently in Clarrie's case?

Please tell me how the club has mishandled the Smith and Clarrie issues?

I think I must have been living under a rock. Am I supposed to know who these people are?

Is there any reason why the latest update regarding Tracc's exit interview has been removed?

The latest from 7News. Apparently, Petracca did not commit in his exit interview. Now Casey venue is a problem. https://7news.com.au/sport/afl/christian-petracca-no-certainty-to-remain-at-melbourne-as-trade-speculation-ramps-up-c-15835017

If you had a choice between young Darcy from Bulldogs and LJ I’ll would go Darcy any day

Gee that's a trip down memory lane.

??

I think they would if it meant getting Kossie

Hi Wheelo, is there a reason why some stats are not shown in other games in Round 23, namely PA v Adel, WC v Car, StK v Gee and WB v NM?

Is there anything arranged to acknowledge our retirees on Friday night, like a lap around the ground at halftime? I am mainly referring to Gus and BBB if he does not play. @WalkingCivilWar, have you heard anything?

Is it your gut feeling from your interactions that Judd is happy where he is, considering he has yet to sign on after 2025?

He's gone.

After all he was talking to Kale Chandler

Yes, I tend to agree. If he builds his tank and body over preseason, I can see him in a role not dissimilar to Fritsch, Melky or Gunston. Keep him away from being a go-to key forward.

Yes I agree but I admit that I like Dwayne's commentary, particularly his zingers. He came out with one of his best during the last quarter when talking about Melbourne's tumultuous week: "You can look too deep into a burnt toast and see the image of Jesus".

Is there a reason why Judd McVee has not signed beyond 2025?

Boy, Roffey is an angel compared to some of these guys. Imagine if she appointed our CEO and then sacked him 24 hours later. This place would be apoplectic.

I tend to agree. Now ANB. These 2 set standards and culture. We now need a couple of younger ones to step up, like Rivers, McVee, Chandler, Sparrow, and JVR.

The last time I watched a game, it was played over 4 quarters. Losing by a point after conceding the first 6 goals and with us having all the momentum for the next 3 quarters, it never crossed your mind that we had a realistic chance to win this? In the GWS game, when we were 6 goals up, were you saying to yourself, we are not going to win this? If true, it won't matter how we play; you will always think we will lose. That is sad.

Yes. I think this is the reason.

My comment was not an opinion, but a fact. There wasn't any thinking about it. I was stating what is true.

Our "horrible brand of football" almost beat the 2nd and 3rd placed teams over the past 3 weeks. And this is with a banged-up team made up of youngsters.

So you base that broad statement on a sample of one and a bit games? Gee, you're good Nostradamus.