Biffen

One cigarette could burn our ship down .Best to let him rack up a Brownlow elsewhere . Now where's my red nose and funny wig.

Who can argue with that rationale?The Y along with the cigarette means a no from me now. Forget about all that ability and skill. And he's a witch.

Characters never drink or smoke.Only machines

You have me stumped .

YAMMAS!

Yep-there is no mention anywhere of drugs and the photo is four months old probably posted by a "mate".This is the kid that stood out in the games I watched on Fox . He slotted goals in finals for Cales new club , Claremont . Some people can never see beyond the obvious . To the hand- wringing goody-goodies I say "Let he who has never had a beer and a smoke be the first to cast nasturtiums upon the young gun". The photo worked-watch him star for the Bummers now . Remember this is a footy club ,not a church group. If a player has a beer ,we can handle it ,we will live through it .

It's truly a sterile world now when someone who is 18 cannot have one beer and one cigarette without being pilloried by hand -wringers . Sure it's dumb to put it on FB while the draft is happening but FFS-all of you who have written him off for life over this photo should get a grip on reality . he may be naughty but if its the same Garlett that played rep for WA then he can tear teams up . Thats all that I care about . Oh he smokes! Oh how terrible! Harden up!

When was the last time we had a Greek Boy ? I really cant remember any at MFC. I like "Jimmy Stomp-Ass"as a name . "Pethi Mou-Stomp-colos"

He could be the next Martin Pike! Lets not judge people on one beer and one ciggy.

If you think Irra can bring something to the table ,without getting annoyed . And he doesn't become tating ,remains sponsible. Then its probably not an ational decision . We may need him .

He'll never make it .

Garlett ,purely because he can suck back cans and smokes with Neeldy after training whilst we build our culture thingo.

Cool-its about time we recruited some party animals. Four pillars is like four corners man.... Square.

Bring on the haters!The other clubs are just stepping stones! Frickin rabble make me sick.

Andy Lovell will be shattered.

The train analogy is great . Sadly , it is often used in the match day thread describing the score. "Its a train wreck".

The AFL has not considered that in this media foray they will be more liable for their lies than ever before. They are making a big mistake .Even I am incapable of reporting on myself accurately-and I am as near to a perfect human being as is possible. I can see the headlines in a few year or less: GWS SUES AFL for withdrawing revenue.... see page 309 for details.

Be prepared for stonishment.

Another reason the go home factor is not so important in this case is that "home" is Adelaide . Viney ,Jamar ,Sellars ,Tapscott ,Trengove dont seem to be in any rush to return . Tippett was so desperate to leave he made them write in a special exit clause for him .

Hard to disagree that Swooper was the best since NS. The unluckiest Coach must be Mick Malthouse-sacked by a megalomaniac president when at the peak of his powers.

Charlie Young from 1897-1904

Charlie Newman

All he needs to do is hold the marks and kick the ball through the middle.These are two things he has struggled with .

Saints

Theres a recruiter from GWS who writes fantastic notes on all the kids but they are often smeared with tomato sauce, gravy , jam , pies,cakes etc so we have to go by Emma Quayle.