Jaded No More

Oh man why you gotta go depressing me like that?

I agree. Flags are rare. This might never come around again. If we can win one I would be over the moon, even if I’m not there to watch it in person. I will however acknowledge that if we don’t make the grand final or we lose the grand final and it isn’t being played at the G with crowds, then I think it would somewhat soften the blow.

Pre Covid I haven’t missed a home or Marvel game live in years. The only time I missed one was if I was traveling. I sat through years of us losing week in week out by sometimes 15 goals, all in the hope that one day I will get to experience the joy of seeing us win a flag. To have that taken away from me and any other long suffering fan would just be another piece of joy being ripped away from us in Victoria.

I can’t think of anything worse than Melbourne winning a flag and it being played elsewhere and we can’t attend. It would just top off what has been probably the worst year of my life.

Yes but not in the seniors unless absolute disaster strikes with injuries.

Super disappointing and his pace will be really hard to replace. I hope he can make it back for prelims if we make it that far. I would say Hibbo is the natural replacement there and Bowey can play a more attacking role with Hibbo defending. You lose pace with Bowey but you gain better ball use. Let’s hope Salem’s groins hold up n

Crap. Not good news. Finals start in 3 weeks.

Still no word from West Coast? Do we know if the [censored] who posted this stuff online is even a West Coast fan? Either way, [censored] poor from them not to even acknowledge it. Sore losers.

I think they will give Gawn more minutes up forward to give him a rest. And BB will do more rucking in the forwardline.

Another week of lockdown and Baccus Marsh school shut again. Absolutely can’t see it happening.

Last week was enjoyable but honestly I felt a bit sorry for GC. I don’t have anything against them. But beating those flogs in Boo Stadium was just marvelous. I despise that club about 50% as much as I despise Geelong, and anyone who knows me knows I would bomb GMHBA if I could.

Humans are trash and social media has just made the rubbish dump bigger. How in 2021 are we still not “woke” enough to be over this crap?

Sadly we have no currency both in terms of picks and cap space. Best chance is to bring a free agent in who is chasing success and willing to take a smaller pay for it.

Mine too. I was not around for Flower or Jimmy as I only moved to Australia in 1998. Clarry is the best player I’ve seen in a Melbourne jumper purely because he has rarely had a bad game since the day he debuted.

Yep and people said he was no good because he didn’t immediately hold down Full Back 🙄

Sure, if you love a throw 😂 Mitchell and Libba are slow. Clarry has a brilliant burst of speed and his ability to pick up the ball one handed while charging forward is unmatched. He won us the game last night by doing just that in the final centre bounce and then had the vision to hit the ball lace out to Spargo. He is a talent like no other. I will fight to the death anyone who thinks he isn’t the best inside mid in the competition! He was winning AA blazers at 20 in a game over flowing with midfielders who can see ball and get ball. He is special.

Richmond. Ugh. Please no!

The absolute love fest for the Bont is just annoying. Look he is a star, incredible vision, amazing ball user, beautiful to watch. But was he a 7 votes good on the weekend? Hell no. I watched the entire game and he was just OK. Did some nice things but did not go hard when the game was there to be won. He did get a nice helping hand from the umpires tho. You can already tell he’s won the Brownlow the way these umpires fawn over him like a love stuck teenager. Oliver isn’t flashy but nobody does what he does. Nobody is even close to him in the league when it comes to getting clean ball out of contested situations with his hands. He is a miracle footballer and until the day I die I will maintain that he’s a better player than Trac (who is an A grader!)

I get the vibe they will take no risks with Tmac next week at all. Too important from round 23 on.

Great. Much harder for the Dogs. I like it. Thanks Tassie. Now please also let me come and holiday there in the pre finals bye. Thanks.

He was the best forward on the ground. Darling did SFA and Kennedy was hampered by injury (I think Kennedy is a monster FF and an absolute star but he’s in his twilight now).

Absolutely bizarre votes. Is Simpson OK? Also Trac not a stand out for best on ground for mine at all. But I’m not complaining when a Melbourne player gets a perfect 10.

The only thing they should be saying is "too bad we aren't fit enough or interested enough to play 120 minutes of footy and thank god lightening gave us a 30 minute breather so we could get going for 15 minutes and kick some goals to make the game look less one sided". And also "I sent Nicholls the cheque yesterday guys".

Sam Blease. Talk about PTSD. I tried so hard to forget how bad we were at recruiting, developing, playing and life in general back then... thanks for bringing all that up again.

Absolute locks unless injured are below FB. May Petty Hunt HB. Rivers Lever Salem C. Langdon Oliver Brayshaw HF. Spargo T-Mac ANB F. Fritsch B. Brown Pickett R. Gawn Petracca Harmes I/C Jackson If Hunt is badly injured I would say his replacement will be Hibbo purely for experience and the fact that he can do a shut down role on a dangerous resting mid. I would not want Bowey taking on that pressure in finals. Then the interchange for me will be a horses for courses from: JJ (Believe he should be in anyway), Viney, Melksham, Bowey, Sparrow and Jones if we want experience. I think we will alternate the medi sub depending on who is carrying what injury, the weather and also if VFL can continue, to get good miles into legs in preparation for more finals. I think Melksham has a role to play, as does Viney come finals (and have no doubt he will walk straight into the side), but I think JJ is really versatile and for that reason I want him in the starting 22 as he can play wing, inside mid, half back or half forward should the need arise. In hotly contested finals footy, the ball use of Melksham could be a real asset, but his poor defensive work rate could be an absolute disaster too. It's a tough call. I wouldn't be against him playing a negating role on Caleb Daniels should we meet them in the finals. But unless he has a specific role, carrying him and Fritta is going put a lot of pressure on ANB and Spargo to defend up forward. Sparrow, Jones, Vanders and Weideman will be on standby for injuries or suspensions, but I don't think any of them will make the cut except for as medi subs. I would be happy to have Jones as a medi sub should we make the grand final if he is in good form and fully fit, but we can have that conversation when and if we even get there.