Maldonboy38

Bringing in Chocco and Yze seems to have made a huge difference to Goodwin. At the very least his manner and expression during press conferences has shifted, but that might be due to the fact we are winning. The biggest difference seems to be game-day coaching. He trusts the players to steady when the opposition are on a run. But if we have a poor quarter (and we usually have 1 bad per game) those problems are resolved in the next game break. I will admit I had him on thin ice, waiting for the first 8 rounds to see how we are playing, but I reckon that is fair enough considering our 2109 and 2020 seasons. But that ice is rock solid now.

I just hope he is ok. One AFL player (I can't remember who) is continuing to have concussion symptoms 6 weeks later. We can't replace him like-for-like. He plays the wing in a way that few others do, more like a wingman from the 70's. No way do we move ANB out of his role. Apart from his pressure and running, he can kick goals. I actually thought Baker was OK during his 1 game, while not being great. But his defensive running was a negative. Are any of Sparrow, Lockhart or Bedford genuine runners? Or anyone else showing wing-like capabilities at Casey? I like the option of Jones, but that would probably mean moving ANB to the wing which is a mistake. So I basically have no idea how to replace Langdon!

Just ben watching some footage and highlights, and want to give a BIG shout out to Petty. Apart from his very capable beating of his opponent each week, that mark he took shows an increase in confidence. He gets to contests, and is steady with ball in hand. I haven't noticed him too much over the past few weeks but I made a point of watching him and I really like what he brings. And although Melksham has been on shaky ground for most of this year, I thought his workrate, effort and footskills were very good. That howler of walking the ball over the boundary line was a brain fade, but he was effective in his role last night.

Absolutely agree. The above 5 + Hunt would get a game in any other team and are rarely beaten. Spargo's ball use is starting to look like Caleb Daniel's: steady under pressure, accurate, line breaking.

No change unless Viney is ok, but I have no idea who to drop to let him in.

6. Oliver 5. Rivers 4. Brayshaw 3. Harmes 2. Petracca 1. Gawn

I've held back. No longer. I believe now.

We controlled the game with no real standout single player. Every player contributed. Our team defence was a thing of beauty. We are the hunted now. Bring it on!

Two free flowing goals to us to take the wind out of their sails would be vey nice.

Reading most of this you'd think we are losing due to mistakes. We're up by 19 points and outplaying them all over the park. We're WINNING - come on, how about some love and admiration for a great first half!

Their only strength remains the freeballing, unpressured kick straight into the forward line, accompanied by semi-hidden throws. We have been stronger all over the ground. They take full advantage of every freed up moment they get. If Jackson or Weid could actually mark the ball, we win by 8 goals.

Whether we win or lose from here - we are very good at pressure, and the Dogs crumble under it.

Wow.

We lost by one point when nearly our entire 22 played an average or poor game. Dogs beaten by Blues and Tiges. On both occasions, the Dogs crumbled under fierce pressure. If our boys can play the Goodwin 'start-from-the-contest' footy and do most of the hard work when we they don't have the ball, we win and we win well. If our tackles don't stick, or we let Daniels, Bont and Johannisen play loose and free 5 metres off the contest, we get smashed. Oliver, Gawn, Trac, Brayshaw, Fritsch, May, Lever, Salem are our usual match winners, but this game relies much more heavily on Spargo, Pickett, ANB, Harmes, and Hunt. Dees by about 16 points I reckon (hope?).

It's the best midfield we have had in along time, but please, there are a vast number of midfields in front of our current lot who actually achieved success.

A car load of us were coming down for the game, and I was all set to purchase tickets today. Due to some logistics, we had to make a decision today so we pulled the pin. Really peeved. I was really hungry to see these 2 go head to head live.

I am fairly peeved at the breakdown in basic skills, and many players looked flat, but we are 9-1. Yep, we had a bad one, but I hope Goodwin shows faith where it is due.

No expectations of perfection here. Expectations to reproduce the simple things the team practices each week. And no, it was not the highest pressured game all year. Don't get me wrong, the Crows played very well. But a lot of our handling errors were unpressured.

Lots of frustrating cameos tonight. If only Jackson could mark. He gets to so many contests, and his hands are first to the ball. But he just can't clunk them...yet. Jordon's kicking is becoming a real worry. For a bloke who is playing so well he consistently produces howlers. Fritsch and his kicking... Max in many dumb moments. And our basic skills - marking, handballing, kicking, and general ball handling was torturous to watch. But our main problem is our midfield. The number of times they waltzed through the corridor in numbers, especially with one running ahead of the play, was infuriating.

Kick randomly out of congestion, and without thought, opposition marks it: check Handball to teammate under pressure: check. Fumble the ball on the ground: check Miss simple marks: check Unpressured turnovers: check Don't do/give first option and get tackled: check. I just hope that is as bad as we get.

What is going on with holding the ball and push in the back? Not the slightest correction from the horror of the last 2 weeks with umpires simply not paying blatant free kicks. I LOATHE Carlton but the umpiring looks biased against them. And Hawthorn are rubbish.

Three best teams to date are Dees, Doggies and Lions. Beneath them are Port, Cats and Eagles. But we can't write off the Tiges yet. If you want to understand how much a good midfield counts for, look at our centre clearance numbers decrease since Viney has been out. Cotchin, Prestia and Bolton seriously changes their midfield power. And their leaders and elders often step up to drag them across the line. They are failing, but don't write them off yet. Having said that, Dusty has lost a metre or so of his pace, Hibbo showed how to play him, and now Fagan and co have worked out how to tackle him. Harmes did the same thing. Riewoldt can really turn it on in key moments but rarely plays a full decent game. And most teams who have the right personnel play the Tiges defenders one-on-one and they get showed up. Their team defence is great, but they are not great one-one-one. Notice how Vlastuin and Grimes got exposed by forwards who can really mark the footy.

I'm not sure where we can meet for a Demonland gathering (annoying question inserted here: what would be the collective noun for a group of Demonlanders? You know - a murder of crows, a mob of kangaroos, an asylum of Pies fans etc...) but I have a few good places to avoid: The pub with no beer The Salvos in Bourke St The Windsor High Tea rooms Some petty part of me would love to meet on Gosch's Paddock, walk down the road in huge numbers to the Pies headquarters and throw frozen pies over the fence onto their training track. Or cross the road and throw burnt cards and microwaves onto the Punt Rd oval. Yes, it does feel rather pleasant to be a Dees man at the moment.

Sorry, Jaded, but that is both horribly tragic and savagely funny! I feel for you, but it really made me laugh.

I sat back and had a think of the great Dees midfielders I have seen since the early 70's, and I reckon this bloke is the best I have seen. A big call, but I honestly can't see a more natural on-baller during any era. His movement and game-reading around a contest are breath taking, his hands are as quick as Sam Mitchell, Simon Black, Greg Williams and co. But for me it is his pace. He plays the game at full tilt. And he is still sprinting while others are out on their feet. He is so good, I would absolutely loathe him if he played for another team.