Pates

Can I just say how awesome it was to see Kozzie starting in the middle against at the Saints. Having that speed and excitement in the middle of the ground helped create that first goal to Viney.

Maybe they'll create some just for Dangerfield to play in ?.

I think we could find Jackson playing a little more on the ball as Brown and Weiderman get fit (and hopefully firing). If we're looking at playing them all (big if), it could look something like this: TMac Weid Spargo Pickett Brown Fritta Jackson starts on the bench and plays a more on the ball role, Melksham, Fritta, and Tmac take turns playing the opposite wing to Langdon. The tricky part then becomes who loses their place in the line up, Jordon and Sparrow have been playing well, while we may also look at trying to squeeze Hibberd into the line up. It's rare to have a close to full compliment of players available anyway so other injuries will likely start to open some doors.

We could look at the flexibility of the players as well, look at positions that they can rotate into. While I like Fritta in the forward line I could also see him be used in a wing role as he's a good mark and pretty well paced, as well as a good field kick. Likewise I think TMac could be used as a high forward half/wing role (it's kind of how he's been playing already). I pretty much only see Brown and Wied as the two players that are less flexible. Weid can pinch hit in the ruck, but Brown we recruited to be our lead up FF so that's where he stays. As @DeeSpencer said it's unlikely we can find a way to have all of them in, makes competition for spots even stronger.

Given Melky’s poor 2020 I have no hesitation about keeping him at Casey until he puts in multiple performances that indicate that he is back to his best and willing to do the team requirements.

I wanna say it was around 2001 with Sandy. I vaguely remember there were players that really wanted to play in the finals series for Sandringham but were prevented from doing so by the club. At the very least it should have been the players choice, and really finals experience in finals experience no matter if it's the big leagues or VFL. I don't think many clubs have done that since, and now I think we have a very good working relationship with Casey (mainly because they've become apart of our organisation). But precisely because the VFL didn't start before round 2, and because they would have byes that don't match with the AFL team, it just seems like such a poor substitute for a reserves competition.

It's getting better, would really love to see Brown getting closer to footy action. Clearly the round 3-4 estimates were very optimistic for both him and Weid.

Gary cops a lot of crap from people but you can't deny his passion for the Dees. He is Melbourne through and through.

Really sounds like this new second tier competition is already proving to be a mistake, or at least in the early days a total mess. How can you have a second tier competition start so much later than the main league. It's a joke. COVID has caused a lot of issues with money but this really underscores that the AFL needs to create a reserves competition with each team represented by their own club (or a likewise affiliate). 18 teams that play each other from within the competition. I know it would take a lot to organise but it has to be the way forward to create a proper reserves comp. (FWIW I would have our 2nds operate as the "Casey Demons")

How good is it to see Dees in the finals, and this year I think on our day we can beat all comers. Shame for Daisy, get to the Granny for her!!!

I think that sums it up for me, if we were judging him purely as a forward then you would have him out. I'm judging him as a 2nd ruck/forward/utility and for me he is just doing enough, every game into him assists his development so for that reason I think the bar is also set lower. That said as you've pointed out bing once we have a full compliment of Weid/Brown/TMac the headache will come on how we use them all the to the best of their ability. Jackson will certainly move out of being a forward and probably go to being more of a utility/onballer/2nd ruck. We also shouldn't be afraid to drop him, send him to Casey for stints as their number one ruckman so that he can get a taste of what it's like to ruck all day for multiple weeks.

It’s a hard thing to say but I really think until one of the players puts in a performance that says “they need a week at Casey” I really just want to see a settled side. Maybe, MAYBE Melk comes in for Jones with Nate being medical sub but really I say no change. The current team is gelling so well, everyone contributed.

**** really? Why are they starting so late? Ok I’m flipping completely for a couple of reasons, first off it’s a really bad look for a player with a 3 game suspension still able to be out on a footy field, secondly it’s plainly unfair to the rest of the competition that players suspended now are given that opportunity to maintain match fitness while players suspended later have to sit on the sidelines. Rule needs to change, does not pass the sniff test.

And as I said, we have rarely had any selections go this way so it’s a fun one to hear.

I actually think our field kicking has improved which I feel would’ve been his number one job, of course all kicking needs to be looked at but I’d say he’d be happy with the progress so far. Kicking for goal is so much between the ears, I think for Fritta in particular that’s his issue. As another hypothesis on our kicking for goal issues, is Casey making it harder for us to improve at it? Sounds silly because you’d think it would make it easier but if the players are constantly practicing at a ground that’s blowing a wind that forces you to always compensate does that play on the players when they line up in still conditions? Petracca had a shocker for his shots for goal, usual he is so pure with his shots from 50 but none of them were even close.

Yep beware the wounded animal. This is not only a chance for us to go 3-0 (good lord!) but to effectively put a pin in GWS's season early, it will be a big one for both clubs. GWS should be feeling it a bit in their legs as well, they started with a slog in the wet, travelled to Perth, come back to Sydney, and then fly to Canberra (short trip but still gotta go through the airport motions).

You would've thought at least someone (central ump, boundary ump, goal ump) would say let's just check if the ball was out first. To be fair if it's called a goal I'm not even sure you can definitively say it's out, remember it only needs to be the smallest part of the ball. I actually think Kozzie's is the best this week, not only the skill but the importance of the goal. Turned the game.

I believe this week was still in the pre-season for VFL so it doesn't get registered as an official game. Shouldn't be able to play after this week. I don't think this is favouritism, just a little stroke of luck for Danger. EDIT Just to add, I don't agree with it. If you're suspended it should be suspended from playing any competitive footy.

That’ll do. I think we keep persisting with LJ but seeing Majak put in another solid performance does throw the idea up of giving him a crack as our 2nd forward/2nd ruck. I’d expect the FD to continue to give LJ the ability to develop in the seniors, particularly as we are currently winning. Another quiet LJ game, and another solid Majak Casey game should really put his name in contention.

That one never gets old, we have rarely had a pick selection go out way like this so it’s fun to dine out on it!

That’s what the best teams have, bottom six players doing team-lifting, important acts. I’m not saying we’re there yet but this is what we did well in 2018 as well. Well done to both who I would say quite a few on D-Land would’ve been comfortable about them being out the door at the end of last year.

Max is a great example of someone who stays in almost every game by purely having a high work rate. Even if he’s having an off day from taps (or taps to advantage) he’s still making contests and taking contested marks. His role as the sweeper when May and Lever are covered is absolutely essential to the team. He looks like someone who will play into his mid-30s, even if it’s not as the no 1 ruck. Jackson couldn’t have a better mentor.

He’s only going at half pace, should be getting 50+ per week! ?

Flashed in and out, did some good thing but not involved in the game for large periods. I thought his ruck work is improving though, he wasn’t tapping it down the throat like Max but competed strongly and staying in the contest when the ball dropped. He’s giving Max plenty of important chop outs and rest that make me think it worth persisting, if we drop him who goes into the middle when Max rests? TMac? Tommo? The only thing I’ll say is that if he doesn’t improve by the time Weid is ready and Sam puts in a strong return performance, or Majak starts killing it at Casey, then his place could be in jeopardy. But for now it’s worth putting time into his development.

You clearly went through something personal @Half forward flank and if that last post was indeed your last on the site all the best to you. But the takeaway from Spuds game was multi-layered because the world is ever evolving. I’m not sure how old you are but you strike me as someone from the baby-boomer gen, nothing wrong with that at all but I think that generation and older looks a bit down on guys having feelings. One side of things that Spuds game is meant to achieve is for blokes to feel ok about reaching out to someone who THEY think might be struggling, and you have to be prepared to really listen and take in what’s being said. It sounds like a snowflake thing to say but toxic masculinity is a big issue with guys not being willing to either open up or listen to a mate open up, we tend to side step it by having a laugh or by telling them to harden up. As someone said before, women don’t have as high a rate of suicide because they really talk to each other. The other side like the other point is allowing blokes to feel safe about opening up to issues with each other. Rather than just answering the question of “how ya doing” with “not bad yaself” guys needs to feel ok to say, “you know what mate I’m struggling and I need to talk about it”. What you said is also true, there is only so much friends can take on, and quite often they need to be the middleman to say, “I’m here for you and happy to chat, but I think you should speak to a professional as well”. As well as talking to mates, guys need to let their guard down to theirs wives/GF’s/partners. My fiancée noticed when I’m stressed and I feel lighter when I’m open about it, I really feel for the Frawley family, he seemed like a lovely guy with what very little interaction I had with him.