old dee

The tigers are a good two seasons in front of us IMO. They have started a slow climb But unfortunately the Dees have not found the ladder yet let alone worked out which way is up.

+1

We must have read the same lines dd. Damning him with faint praise comes to mind. For the high jump IMO

Not sure about that Chook I think they beat us twice last year and had a way better year than the Dees. I seem to remember the Tigers beat both Grand finalists during the year. The closest the Dees got was about 8 goals to one and 15 to the other. They have a better song as well.

Well Thaipantsman Similar things were said about any number of our recruits in the last eight years and most have been average at best. Some never even had 1 AFL game. e.g. Cook. He looks good but I will believe it when he has played 50 AFL games. Until then he is a good junior who has not played one game yet. He has joined the big boys now lets see what happens

You don't remember 2007,8,9 and 11 ID? They were very good bottoming years too

Do you really want me to answer bbo?

Think I have much the same opinion Redleg but a pick 15 to 20 might change my mind. I actually think there is no chance that will happen so he stays I guess.

This sounds like good news to me. Wonder if either are silly enough to stump up with a first round pick or early second round. I would be tempted to take it. But all smoke and suspect no fire.

Cannot agree ID The Tigers song is easily the best in the AFL IMO beats all others hands down. I actually think the bulldogs song is ordinary.

Careful JT the way the MFc changes logo's / colours it could be incorrect 5 minutes have you do it.

My fingers are crossed. The last thing we need is another blow out from the BP era. The plie is way too high as it is.

There is one big positive Maldonboy.

Very good Deeoldfart. I was just thinking that this thread has turned out to be the Demonland confessional. So come on ladies and gentemen now is the time to cleanse your souls.

The fat lady has not sung on a couple of above Jonesbag. Although she is limbering up.

So far an average player that has had a lot of injuries. Would not be surprised to see him moved on.

Great minds !

That may well be the truest thing you have said this month dc. 18 is too many clubs IMO

Very Good DWA Like your work

Unforgetable Robbie

We agree on this one chook, a bit player in 2013 is the best I can see

That is the $64 question bb. 21 this December and already has had 2 serious knee reconstruction does not give me much confidence. In the doubtful class for me unfortunately find it hard to see a long AFL career for Max unfortunately.

First you have to get the ball. Does not seem to do that all that often. Will need a big 2013 or I think he could be in serious trouble of not getting a contract extension

I struggle with what his claim to fame is supposed to be. With the exception of the fact he plays hard. What aspect of the game is his strength?

It must be way more anoying for the Bombers I think he was a pick 4, he has obvious talent but cannot get on the park. The bombers keep hoping he will turn the corner injury wise. Where as Cook has never looked good enough, we knew he was of doubtful quality early on.