John Crow Batty

Showed a few good things in last few games despite a truncated season due to injury. Worth another go around.

The crows are a shambles. Still they can’t do mediocrity like we do.

Garry Ablett in his first season averaged 8 disposals in 12 games and 10 goals. Spargo first season, 18 games, average of 12 disposals and 14 goals. Ablett did not have second year blues though and managed to improve in his second season. Played some great games but also a few poor ones. Spargo is worth persevering with. Not as talented but just as smart.

His game needs more refinement. The club has to find away to maximise his talents and ball sharing ability. He did a lot for little impact. Not so much his fault as poor midfield chemistry.

Had a good season after coming of age in 2018 though appeared at times to be furiously paddling against the tide with little success. Weighed down by the general ineptness of some of his midfield partners and poor co-ordination.

[censored] players that are successful all have one thing in common. That is strong linear progression and consistency despite their faults. They just re bloody good despite themselves and clubs put up with them because their advantages outweighs the negatives. Look at Dustin Martin, Cousins, Toby Greene and others. They have never spent half their careers in the seconds, rehab or jail and generally get along with their peers. Bennell is just a walking disaster and Murrey is a dicquehead that cant break out of the reserves so likely will always be a dicquehead loser.

And a proud member of......

MFC basket case

Our record over the past decade firmly puts us in the basket case category. Thank you GC for lining the bottom though. There has to be some damn incredible improvement In 2020 to debunk that 2018 was not a flash in the pan. Anything less than a solid top 8 finish will be a fail. However that won’t stop the apologists hailing our improvement if we finish 16th.

Bruce will go elsewhere because his whole worth is dependant on kicking a bag of goals against us.

I’d like to see him get more of the ball. If he can get to 20+ possessions a game he will be awesome.

Bad move by him. Eschewed the opportunity to play bruise free football and extend his career.

Chance for him to show Chance for him to show something different now that his old mans and Jones shadow are not hanging over him. Will be a better play IMO. Want to see him do smarter things and involve teammates more rather than doing it all himself. Tends to hunt and get his own ball rather than like Jones demanding everyone gives it to him these days. Lingering injuries have also scuppered him this season. Hope he gets a solid full pre season in.

Many posters preferred to ignore the elephant leaving the room.

We have the key forwards. Fritsch and Tmac for starters. We just need a better forward system and a clued up mid field and a couple of pacy small forwards. Oh.....and players that can lock the ball in and maintain pressure.

whilst we have recruited Shows they aren’t yet convinced he can go the distance and be a long term prospect. But with their list they can afford to keep him on the periphery. No need to take a chance. Whilst we have had a good record of recruiting indigenous players the best have all been solid workmanlike types. We couldn’t keep Farmer because we didn’t put an appropriate monetary value on his talents. He was kicking five and plus on a regular basis. Bagging a star has eluded us. Charles, Wonna and Jurrah had that potential and Picket is in the same category. He’s only played one game. The test will be how he progresses next season and after.

The clock is brought forward for daylight saving in the off season so we miss out on that. When it goes back to regular time in early April it sets our premiership clock back and adds another couple of seasons. Best to ignore daylight saving.

Since our last premiership 55 years 20,103 days 40,206 clock cycles 482,472 hours 28,948,320 minutes Assuming we are currently at 5pm we are due for our next flag in 16 years. If we are at 5am we are due for our next flag in 39 years.

Highly talented but flaky. Can kick a nice goal. Could never cement a permanent position. Though for different reasons is like replacing a Garlett with a Garlett.

When it comes to draws we are equal last.

Don’t get your hopes high. https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/snap-shot-premiership-tiger-comes-to-the-four-20191001-p52wga.html

Sad to see him go but with four other key defenders vying for a spot not surprised he may be going. What irks me is that he was one of few improvers this season. I just hope all the others just had an off season.

Though a solid player, he lack the influence and gut busting burst to be a match winner at the death. It’s a joke to compare him with Dusty. Petracca has had a long time to get to those heights and likely never will now.

Long overdue but since he has another season he has to improve his personal game if he wants to get to 300. He is not ageing like fine wine. I don’t believe he should be gifted games to get there. There is no defined position for him to play anymore. Superseded in the midfield, is not a genuine forward or defender and lacks pace for an outside role. Last season he faded very badly in most last quarters. Barely noticed in many unless he made a horrible clanger. Prefer to see him doing his bit at Casey next season.

frosty ready to rumble.