Everything posted by bing181
-
Gary Pert Quits as MFC CEO
If someone's incompetent or stinking the place up you don't keep them on for 2 months in the same role, nor employ them beyond that period as a consultant. Pretty clear that Pert hasn't been sacked. Equally true that a change at the top and some fresh blood isn't unwelcome. Provided we get the right person.
-
Gary Pert Quits as MFC CEO
Confirmation bias.
-
Gary Pert Quits as MFC CEO
"Green said the review did not recommend Pert go." (The Age article)
-
2024 Phantom Drafts
A lot of what we do at 5 will depend on what the Saint do with their later picks. Hope we have good intel!
-
Time to go Goody?
Sydney weren't missing Heeney until they were: in the grand final. Heeney had a stress fracture and look how that turned out for the team.
-
Marty Hore Re-Signs for 2025
Wasn't helped this year by injury, wherever he plays he needs consistency to even be in the mix. Hope he has a more settled season next year.
-
Dan Houston
Nek minnit ...
-
Wade Derksen
AFL: "Melbourne has a suite of selections that includes picks No.5, 28, 40, 49, 54 and 65, but it's unlikely the club will have any luck in attempting to change the minds of GWS officials by Wednesday's deadline."
-
Welcome to Demonland: Pick 9
Well done Tim Lamb. (if it comes off)
-
Welcome to Demonland: Pick 9
By the time we trade to get Derksen - who's a tall in any case - plus Sharp, not sure we'll have many lower picks left.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Harry Sharp
If he could knock a few seconds off that he'd get close to the women's world record. Or the Australian men's record. Both around 5:20. If that 5:28 is correct it's remarkable.
-
9 Reasons to be Positive Heading into 2025
10. Much easier draw.
-
The Draft Pick Upgrade Thread
I think you'll find the club disagrees with you. JVR, Petty, Turner, then add Fritsch, Kozzie and a couple of smalls plus Jefferson coming through ... workable, and they're all still young, or young enough. Mids would be the priority I would imagine, if not KP defenders for the longer term (May, McDonald, Thomlinson will need replacing over the next year or two).
-
Financial Review: Melbourne Demons the 6th most valuable brand in the AFL
Given that the buck stops with the CEO ...
- Tim Lamb
-
The Draft Pick Upgrade Thread
Not sure if this has been mentioned. MFC are interested in Lion's first rounder, pick 20. They need the points for Ashcroft. Apart from 28, for lower picks we have 40, 48, 53, 64. Then maybe add a 3rd round pick for Tomlinson if anything goes through under FA. Not sure how much we'd have to give up for pick 20, but we obviously aren't going to take all those lower picks to the draft. "The Lions will have multiple takers for the pick, with the Giants, Melbourne and Western Bulldogs among the clubs expected to hold extra middle-range and later draft picks by deeper in the Continental Tyres AFL Trade Period to have a swing at pushing up the draft board."
- The Draft Pick Upgrade Thread
-
Dan Houston
Not for mine. Pick 5 plus trade to get another first rounder and take that to the draft. Much better for the club long-term than another player in his late 20's (or getting there). We're going to be losing a LOT of our key players over the next 4-5 years, starting with Melksham and McDonald next year, May the following year, Gawn and Viney the year after that.
-
Oliver Trade Rumours
I think it's probably a question of semantics. For Lamb, back-room offers and calls to check on availability or hint that player X could be available for the right place are probably everyday occurrences. For the rest, we don't know who did what in all this. Between MFC, Geelong, Oliver's manager and any number of others who might have been across what was gong on, we'll probably never know the details.
-
Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
Personally, I can never see trades in raw terms like this, there are too many variables and it ignores context. We needed a player like McAdam to cover for the absence of Melksham and loss of Bedford. I'm not sure who else was available, but if this is what it cost to fill that hole, so be it. The issue with McAdam isn't so much his ability but the fact that he seems to be injury-prone. Fingers crossed for a better second year with us.
-
NON-MFC: Trade Talk
Also ignore them getting rid of players like Treloar and Grundy while still paying large amounts of their salary.
-
Wade Derksen
Also true of Jackson. He was OK enough to be worthy of a game in his first season, but he's now into his 5th season and is still improving. Against that, 5 years in and he's not exactly taking the comp apart, and the difference between 2nd year and 5th year Jackson is not all that flagrant. 9th in Fremantle's Best and Fairest, still not the finished article. Not knocking him, would love to still have him, but I'm not sure even Jackson is a good counter-example for rucks take time.
-
Trade Targets
Who should we be trading in that won't be coming - or to put it another way, who should we be trading in that isn't going to cost an arm and a leg in terms of picks and salary?
- The Draft Pick Upgrade Thread
-
Time to go Gary Pert
The only actual info out there is that it's Taylor (on his Linked in Profile) and presumably Lamb as he's the List manager. In other clubs it includes the coach, so probably Goodwin. And you would imagine head of the FD, Richardson. But other than that ... who knows. I took it that when Gawn mentioned 10 people there was a touch of hyperbole - no committee of this sort would have 10 people and it's hard to imagine even who they could all be.