jnrmac

Had wrist surgery and went swimming up in the Murray and got it infected. This began a cycle of infection issues and career threatening wrist problem

They were gifted a spot in the finals that year because of Essendrug's suspension

Melbourne would want to be locked into the final 8 by around Rd 17. We can't make the 8 when we have average teams to beat let alone this lot above. Goodwin's form when our season is on the line is frankly pathetic

He is more of a lockdown defender that was being groomed to take over Nev's role wasn't he? Not sure he was expected to "rack up disposals". In any case its not like we have a lot of small defenders other than Salem who rack up disposals....

Make no mistake. There were sizeable forces out against him and he is saving face by announcing he is leaving in 12m. My spies tell me The natives were very restless after the debacle on contracted players.

Following on from above, 1. we had a dearth of smalls a few years ago and now we have gone all in on speed, and smalls. Why so many? Do you ever draft because you think some might fail? 2. How much of this is based around Richmonds strategy? 3. Which if the previous draftees that we haven't seen much of look the most promising to become A graders? Petty, Jordan, Neitschke, Lockhart, Baker, Sparrow?

It's a long way from town on a Razor scooter......

Binman in mourning...

Not at Melbourne....

Thanks Simon Go to bed now...

That's your view. I think mine is a realistic take. I'd like to see a list of the people that we have 'attracted' to support Goodwin that have been jettisoned in the past 4 years. By your reckoning this should have resulted in success I presume? It's a long list particularly when many of those have been shuffled around in multiple roles to try and find the right combo. We have changed virtually every role except the senior coach. You can keep changing the surrounding personnel but at what point do you reach the conclusion I have come to that the bloke acting as senior coach is not the answer?

Very happy with this appointment but still very concerned about how much baby sitting we have to provide for Goodwin who has essentially failed in his role.

Quality post

That's the issue. Its a good thing BUT we're not getting the best value out of that. He and Melksham have the ability to kick those flat 50m darts through the corridor that can break open the play and oppo defences. If he's going to play defence we need to get more out of his kicking ability than dinky 15m chip passes.

The problem is that a lot of these guys can't keep the bulk on when they start doing aggressive cardio... STill the strength often remains...

Pretty sure we played finals in 2018 but I get the sentiment,,,

Another embarrassing piece of rubbish from this club. Just Shut TFU and perform on the field FFS

Hipwood is the one for mine that people rave about but rarely puts it together. Kicked 5 freakish goals against us one year if I recall. Probably the one I like out of those is Himmelberg

Everything about his game looks OK except for the fact he rarely takes a one grabber. Fumbles way too much Frankly if he doesn't fire this year he's a bust for mine

Good you can have a laugh at yourself

*cough* *cough*

There's some gold in these posts about Oliver....

I thought his kicking looked weak. Accurate but no depth Its a small sample I know ...

Agree with this. A great guy apparently and I wish him well but the fact he stayed for so long at this club when it was clear to most that he had substantial limitations as a footballer is beyond belief. Not one outstanding attribute that you could hang your hat on. He was picked because he was virtually our only tall defensive option. It's not Oscar's fault but the fact the club persisted with him for so long is embarrassing. Those that defended him to the death can start wiping the egg off their faces now.

Exactly what a rumour thread is for!