Fat Tony

Make Petty stay and reload for a flag next year. We have him on a good value contract and we will still get a draft pick if he leaves at the end of 2025.

I can’t see us tagging under Goodwin. He will back our defensive system.

Surprised Gawn received votes. I thought he was quite poor with his disposal.

How far away are Hunter, Turner and McAdam?

Salem played the whole game in defence. Petty was moved back when Lever went off.

How certain are you that Salem won’t be moved from the midfield? 😉

I would be worried about both Petty and Brown playing both Adelaide games. I would probably play them in one game only. Similarly Windsor.

The list needs a big cut. A significant number of our young depth are not quick enough or skilled enough.

AMW shows a bit but his disposal is not good enough. Disappointing half by Woewodin, with too many mistakes. He needs to get stronger and cleaner. Brown is a clever player. But is too small for AFL at the moment. Jefferson shows no AFL qualities. Tholstrup does some good things but not enough. Laurie is a good ordinary VFL player. Schache played a decent half but doesn’t have the competitive spirit to play as a forward in the AFL.

Too many mistakes by Woewodin this quarter. He needs to be much cleaner to get into the AFL.

Jefferson is no where near it.

Hopefully we knock the schizen out of them so hard they finish the game with a pure wee jumper!

Great news that the strength and conditioning team think Petty is good to go.

So the best draftees wait a year to play AFL. No way the AFLPA should agree to that.

It will be a big hit for the bottom teams and almost identical to the situation when GWS came into the competition. The wooden spooner will get pick 5 instead of pick 1.

If they are going to extend the season, I think it would make more sense to go through to October than start in early March.

The Dogs are as talented as any team in the AFL, so it was a great win. Ben Brown was very good in perfect conditions. I doubt Brown can be a premiership spearhead in 2024, but he did well and helped our forward line function well. It was great to see Oliver play with so much endurance and power. TMac played a solid game and is faster than Tomlinson and better at competing for the high ball. Hore kicked a couple of lucky mongrels. I am still a bit of a sceptic. Chandler was great and is clearly ahead of Spargo and Laurie in my eyes because his faster and able to compete better in the air. May is playing great footy. Max was excellent in perfect conditions. Billings was excellent and is really well suited to play the high half forward role in our system. Windsor's dexterity and decision making is exceptional for a two game player. He will be a gun inside the square if he can get stronger. Salem was good and is playing well, but it is having a knock on effect to Sparrow, who has been forced out of the midfield. I still think I would push Salem back (in place of Hore) and bring in another forward. The defence could be tested by speedy small forwards in less ideal marking conditions. I thought is was a bad tactical error to start the game with Viney, Kossie and Salem in the centre square and Viney got outsized by Bont.

Salem has to go back to take Bowey's role. We need someone with elite kicking in the back 7. Oliver and Viney both take 80% of game time in the midfield, which leaves 140% of game time to be split across the other midfielders. Petracca, Sparrow, Pickett and Billings can easily take those minutes and Salem won't give us more than those four. I am not sure who takes Schache's spot. TMac, Ben Brown and Fullerton are all upgrades but none are great options. Laurie is a VFL standard player IMO. Small, average kick, slow, poor tackler and small hands. Spargo also looks underdone. My changes would be: INS: TMac, Pickett, Billings (starting), Woewodin (sub) OUTS: Spargo, Schache, Laurie

Surely Salem goes back given Bowey is out. They are the most like for like. We need him to be our composed/skilled high half back. Kossie will come into the midfield at times, to go with Petracca, Oliver, Viney and Sparrow. Billings might also get a full game and can go through the midfield.

It’s only a bog ordinary assessment if he ends up an AFL quality forward.

I think Jefferson’s best chance to make it is as a defender like Mitch McGovern. He has zero ground game, lacks second efforts/intensity and will never be big enough.

It was definitely slippery due to the humidity being 89%.

We have not played well in humid, slippery conditions since Roos/Goodwin took over. (We have struggled in Darwin, Cairns, Brisbane and Gold Coast.) My theory is that the slippery ball takes away the aerial strength of Max and our intercept defenders. Plus our midfield is not skilful and overuses the ball to exit stoppages. The team selection was poor last night, with too many midgets. We need to place a greater value on small forwards who can compete in the air. The game has gone past players like Spargo and Laurie, who are hopeless in the marking contests, and not quick. We need Woewodin and Tholstrop to come on. Oliver looks too heavy and lacked pace. Schache just isn't urgent enough or strong enough. Howes looks good and will be a player. Windsor did some great things and will get better but is still really a 2025+ prospect. I am often critical of Tomlinson, but he played a good game. We can still win the flag this year, but we will need everything to go right.