Sir Why You Little

I am not disputing his form in ‘21, he was consistently excellent as a defender, which is why he had such high currency value. But i just don’t think he is fully committed anymore, 1% is all it takes We missed a huge opportunity to bolster our list. I also understand why the Club wanted to keep him, but i would have Traded HARD with Adelaide It was one of those Poker moments….

He should have been sent home last year, whilst Adelaide were ripe for serious trading. We could have upped the stakes more, and they would have paid. Now he is worth bugger all Shocking decision all round He was in Adelaide playing Golf with his mates during Trade Week, that’s where he wanted to be.

Recruitment of young players is fine Trading since ‘21 has been atrocious

Exactly. He came in from the opposite side. He only had eyes for Gus

Yep. It will always be my opinion The kick had been taken. there was only the man to attack

Maynard was never going to smother that ball, he lined up a Player and executed with the Full shoulder to the head. And got zero penalty for it That’s what occurred

The kick had been taken. Brayshaw was taken out i have watched it many times…

I don’t think it was rubbish at all. Angus Brayshaw was lined up and taken out, the ball had left the area. The only thing Maynard had eyes for, was the Player, the move was executed to perfection as far the Filth were concerned….

Yes i know. Other Clubs can make those big trades come off. We just cannot crack it

and replace them with….?? (Harmes was a different situation) but the other 2 I think the Club handled badly.

It’s definitely part of the reason, and i am sure there are many more Today was a complete shutdown

We had to find a way to keep those players, and we didn’t thus we are here now….

Grundy and Jordon, we let go far too easily I said it a few weeks ago, Angus wasn’t going to play again, his past history told us that Harmes was a different situation, but including Brayshaw that is 4 Senior Spots gone, that we have not been able to fill

This meeting could take all day if necessary. It doesn’t matter, bring in the Pizzas and a few Beers Get people talking, lay it all on the table There are problems that many within the Club, may not have any idea about, they must be addressed If we are to be that Good Club, we have to have complete honesty after a day like today

We shouldn’t have let players go, so easily, thinking that Gus was going to play again.

I would summon the entire Football Department Staff for a meeting tomorrow morning. Everyone who works with the Players and Coaches to attend. there is disconnection between Players, and disconnection between Coaches and we have find the answers quickly. The entire team shut down today after 5 minutes, Why? Everybody needs to talk it through, be honest There is a reason for our poor performances this year and it has to be laid bare. losing Brayshaw on the eve of the Season, is one reason I think has really effected the Core of the Club, but there will be other reasons as well. Today was unacceptable and we have to get to the bottom of it. The Big Talk is needed. It doesn’t have to be nasty, but it has to happen Everyone must attend and be honest….

Yes we are all anonymous on here. There are ways to convey information, without divulging too much…

It’s not looking good, is it? We have no Key Forward scoring Power, at all We have all been waiting for it to come good, but today showed that it’s just not going to work, on many levels. So frustrating because last year we could have really screwed Adelaide for Picks and Players, Adelaide have some good attacking forwards and they were desperate to get Petty home, he was there playing Golf with his mates, now he will go quietly for nothing….

I realized that after losing to Brisbane on the ‘G Because they are done, we should have smashed them to pieces, if we were serious. We were owned…

That is entirely possible, because the players we have replaced over the last 2 years are totally inferior and it has now come to the surface

Results do not lie Brisbane West Coast Fremantle All 3 comprehensively lost

At least he owned it. But we need serious action. recruiting McAdam was a Complete bust for a decent pick. Petty should have been sold last year when he held serious value (whilst injured) the midfield has been stagnant for 2 years This Loss of such magnitude may have one positive…. Everyone is under the Hammer. Coaches and Players…

Doesn’t read well does it. Complete Failure sadly….

He’s not worth anything now. Should have been done last year when he was in demand

We had a better list. We don’t have it anymore. The Recruitment since ‘21 has been a Failure