Roost It

We'll win the Premiership Easier draw, great run with injuries, an ounce of luck and a lucky bounce of the ball in the dying seconds sees Petracca kick the winner after we were 45 points down in the second quarter

Quite possibly the most over hyped and over rated player to have ever played the game

Keep

I totally get the love for him.

You trade him because you realise that he’s not going to part of our next Premiership

I’d trade Viney for a highly skilled, classy, fast forward any day of the week Gawn for a top 10 pick and a solid running player Very few untouchables in the quest to be the Premiers

I’d be looking to trade Viney as well. I rate Bradshaw the better prospect by a fair way. Target what we need and get them. We need pace, class, skill on every line. Our smalls are a bust and our forward line needs a reboot.

Trade now is what a ruthless club would do We’ll make him co captain and his form will drop away markedly Tom McDonald should also go We’ve got to get more top end talent in to get the best out of the quality we already have

Jenkins.....please NO we need pace and class and pace and class and pace and class

We need pace, class and players in the 22-26 bracket. Patton will go to the Hawks, a massive no to Jenkins and perhaps a new coach but that’s yet to be fully proven.

Has said coach got a gambling issue?

Petty has a long long way to go before anything can be said, for mine Weideman can’t be judged on this season. It was a train wreck. Has to go around next year, hopefully starts preseason training now.

I don’t rate him as yet. However he has another 2 years to find himself a position in the best 22. I hope he makes it.

As a father of 2 kids I’m more than happy for offensive, loud and rude fools to be tossed out. The AFL are doing this because the feed back they are getting is that people are sick of the behaviour of a minority of fools ruining their day at the footy.

I’d play Stretch, Spargo, Sparrow, Keilty, OMac, and Weideman every game for the rest of the season. We need to get games into our young players I’d get Ratten in to coach the midfield and look for some changes to our assistant coaches. Petracca cannot be traded Patton must be chased as should one or two outside mids playing Jones, Lewis and Frost seems a luxury we can no longer afford be brave MFC and 2020 might just be a rippa

We were cooked at quarter time

Yes you do as it gives you clean possession and the chance to move it 70 metres toward goal with one kick

Surely McDonald plays on Lynch? thank god number 9 is out thank god the Wagners are out great pity Nev is out to avoid an epic flogging we’re going to need everything to go right tigers by 86

Apologies to those who read my “We’ve got Gaff” posts. That was my mail. I’ll hold off next time I hear something and let others confirm. He would of looked great in red and blue on $750,000

I’ve stayed away from this thread until just now. I’m not coming back after reading the above post. He was in AA form and now.........oh ckuf it, what’s the point

The modern game hasn't happened yet. Who would have thought a bunch of fast 5 footers would win Richmond a Premiership, maybe 2 at the end of 2016? All of Hogan, Weideman and McDonald are very mobile. Exciting times ahead. I suspect quite a rivalry between us, Richmond, Collingwood and GWS will develop over the next decade. Oh yes and and I was an early doubter of Weideman but boy was that first quarter fantastic

90% going on accuracy of previous mail. I’m assured we’re not paying $1.2 or giving up any talent.

We’re not paying $1.2 million for Gaff nor are we moving any promising players on

It’s much more complicated than that. All those things are highly addictive. It’s not weak to be addicted. It’s an illness like any other. Labelling those suffering as weak just increases there unhappiness and drives them further down the hole. The country should just charge $1350 for a pack of ciggies as that’s roughly the true cost when you look at the health implications. Alcohol needs to be 7 -9 times more expensive if you factor in health costs. Gambling just needs to have its advertising banned and poker machines banned. The vast majority of users are the very people who can least afford it if only our governments had the balls to do that

Always, although this info it’s well known in AFL circles