Redleg

I got on to the live stream during the financial report and missed the earlier bit. Are you saying that all he said was that no announcement was available? Surely he elaborated a bit.

I am not buying into the flags argument, but I think you will agree that injuries early in a game, are different to injured unavailable players for the game. You can at least plan for it and select another fit player. Losing a very good player and on field leader early in the 2023 Q F affected us badly, especially when the result was a 7 point loss. Gus went off very early in the first quarter, after having one kick and one handball and was replaced by Laurie who had one kick for the remaining 3.5 quarters. He was basically ineffective from when he came on. I think Gus was on around 25-30 possessions a game at that time. We lost him and fresh legs at the end of the game, where it might have made a difference. The team was shell shocked and the Pies then jumped us ,until we settled down later in the game. Yes we kicked badly and that didn’t help, but I strongly believe we would have won that game if Gus wasn’t knocked out. I always thought the winner of that game would win the flag and that was how it turned out. No guarantee we win the flag, but our chance to was severely affected by the Gus knockout.

Different roles, but yes maybe he will be helping in the selection process.

In answer to the opening post I guess we are still "pondering."

To me it was a simple decision. Clarry was the biggest player problem in the club, by a mile. His huge salary was for 2021 Clarry, not current Clarry, that was another problem. Where did we finish the last two years with him? We brought in a bunch of new players in the last couple of years, who would be judging us and what we stand for, the culture had to be improved. The locker room is now happier and if you talk to the track watchers, they have seen a happier squad training. Good luck to Clarry, but much better luck to the Dees.

Who not one club or fan would not grab for their AFL team in a micro second.

I would be thrilled if he won the next 5 Brownlows, if we win the next 5 flags.

JT will eventually leave, but probably not to Tassie Devils, as they have Todd Patterson, Derek Hine, Scott Clayton and now Mick Cashion from the Hawks.

On paper we are a fair way off, but of course we don’t play on paper and of course it is just someone’s opinion or guess. I think we now have more unexpected options for midfield rotation.

Hold the presses Kane Cornes is coming. Great news we have secured another building block in our future.

RIP Cheryl. A lovely and talented woman I had the pleasure of meeting several times. Condolences to family and friends.

Obviously not related to Judd the Docker

Tom has been unlucky not to get more games in his AFL career, as he really is a decent ruckman. In one of the finals for Casey this year he was simply unbelievable, just carrying the team to a win.

I just got a migraine.

They are sometimes the hardest prediction. Everyone had Josh Schache in the first few of his draft for example and he went pick 2. There are plenty of examples of key forwards taken early in the draft who didn't go on.

.

I am with you, I see us improving.

Gee, a lot of thought must have gone into some of those nicknames, for example Vines, Steely and Sharpie.

I have only ever booed one former Demon and I don't even say his name. I won't be booing any of our recent departures. One suggestion to players wanting to leave, maybe say nothing, it's better than misleading loyal fans, who actually care about you.

If that's true I withdraw my defence of him.

That's how they operate. Funny, as one article said he would be great for the Giants' culture. I spent 5 minutes cleaning up the food I inadvertently spat out when I read that. There was another article on midfielders in the AFL, which he did not gain an appearance in and another naming A and B category players of each club and again he did not even make it being named as a category B player. Click bait works in strange ways.

Have done exactly the same several times. I also go up and down a small hill at the local park for my exercise walk and use player names to count the number of times I do it, silly habit I know.

Well at least he went to do his business in the toilet.

Agree with that and not rocket science either.

Well I understand your view, but it’s plainly wrong to blame an innocent party. Champion Data do that job and the football clubs can’t override that as they have no ability to do so.