picket fence

Midfield getting Smashed and so what a HUGE mistake this was not playing him! Shocking shizen decision and NOW it comes back to bite hard! Typical Melbourne! Stuff up!

WHAT A WONDERFUL MOVE IT WAS DROPPING OLIVER!!

Clearly you have no insights into list management and the fact that every place on an AFL list is like winning Tatts! Ok, the club has seen fit to give him another contract! In my mind it is a very questionable decision! Tell you what let's revisit this time next year and evaluate the sucess or not of this! Tell you what, if this is a success I'll not post here again EVER!

Prove me wrong like the Mc Donald's have ?? Oh really? Oscar plays a good game or two and you are satisfied?? Same with his Brother and his "Iffy" disposal! But that's another story! Luck is [censored]! You make your own luck! Iv'e learnt that the hard way!

sponded to the need to have a solid 30-35 core players. I think Pickett expects 22 delistings from one year to the next. Oh Ok so now he was signed for Depth eh?? Ok I understand perfectly now! Jack Trengove is in the 30-35 Core of Depth?? Still does not cut it for me! Might be a good bloke and all but good blokes aren't going to get uis to a premiership! Just to remind me again, how many games did he play this year?? And he is expected to improve and keep pace with a quickening game?? He was ready to go to Punt Rd was it?? Cheezus no wonder we haven't won any Premierships in 50 years!

Hnmm Interesting How so?? Are you thinking another Spanking at the Cattery??

Of course Nasher, as always!! Stick to topic! Cheers PF

No Comment re coaching,!! However, I enjoyed the 'Robust' debate on this topic! It makes Demonland such a wonderful forum for all! Cheers all, PF

Ah Moonman, some brevity and lucid possibilities you suggest! You make some valid pionts here! I can see the logic in your appriasal!

I never take advice!

No sorry Chook cannot agree with this! At the time Trengove and Grimes were co captains we had No leadership ! Zilch! It ws a very bad choice with not too much elese on offer! We now have many leaders ready to take the mantle! Cutting Trengove now would be absorbed and we would move on effortlessly! But we again played the cheese instead of the trap!

Ho Ho Ho being correct doesn't make me right!?? Yeah Right!

Which goes to show that I do know! I know what his true value was !! That's why I was totally dismayed at his treatment. I repeat Junior Mac was three time the player and leader that Trengove was!

Ho hum, so not one poster can tell me Whose spot he would take!! So I take it no ones! Therefore he plays at Casey for the year. Wonderful!

Really ?? Please explain??

And so by the same logic Jack Trengove should now be gone!! But isn't?? ! Brilliant! I REST MY CASE!

Disagree, Junior Mac was a sensational player, still quick,when shafted and a victim of some shizen powerplays between senior club figures! A much better player than Jack Trengove, and deserved better!

Cmon Chook, Mc Donald was three times the footballer Trengove ever was!

Why?? Why a Troll??? Because I have a very valid opinion?? People like you are the reason that this club still is without a premiership 50 years down the track! A PART TIME SPRINT COACH?? YOU ARE IN NODDY LAND! You can't develop pace< especially when you were never quick to start with! Sentiment? Bah I repeat whose spot will he take?? Time to take a hard nosed approach to this footy club! Clayton Oliver gets dropped just so he can play at Casey?? Cmon He should be in the team WE NEED HIS UNCOMPRIMISING ATTACK ON THE FOOTY! Cmon lighweight! Whose place will Jack Tengove replace in 2017??

Still doesn't answer the question.... Whose spot does he take?? HMMMMM?

HE IS SLOWWWW, the modern game has past him by! What position will he play and whose spot will he take?? Eh?

So common sense and pragmatics don't come into it then?? A wasted extension IMO Jesus Christ, no wonder we never improve with lets be gentle philosophies that really serve no purpose! who Adore players who are waaay past it! Get with the times!

So we have re signed a SLOW player who will struggle again next season? So what position does everyone see him playing Eh? Brilliant!

What a wondrful change that will be !! Who goes out?

You are joking/ We are talking CASEY not a stand alone Melbourne F.C