picket fence

BANG!

Good! he can take Melksham's spot on a HFF

Ok, because you have put money into a limited footballer with the potential of little to no improvement. His game has not evolved from day 1 1 Tries to take on player after player after player and more often than not gets caught or is panicked into a poor disposal. 2 Will not honour the first option, or second 3 Kicking is adequate but not elite 4 No Right side 5 Too one dimensional. 6 What if ... His foot injuries return? Ok thats my take on WHY this decision will bite us. IMV Take it or leave it! Ok over to you, can you give me 5 Compelling reasons for a 5 year deal???

Unless the vote givers have blinkers on! As I put up his stats for the year previously compared to Oliver in fact I would say his year was nowhere near a 3 rd in B&F ! Go on check his stats for yourself. I and other rated Oliver as easily 3rd in B & F. 2 years would have been enough with clear trigger for a third. 5 years for Viney? Unbelievable!

Ok Got it

Good onya Wayne, so I'm not entitled to a reasoned opinion??

And what is that reason???

No, bookmark my comment coz I reckon this decision will come back and bite BIG TIME!

1 possibly 2 year deal with triggers. Bookmark this for same time next year and see if I'm mistaken!

LOL

Tally ho Pip Pip all good on the good ship Lollypop! Demon for life yeah great!

Viney Limited just check his seasons stats Jones Finished Nev almost the same Max excellent player. Mate heart and soul IS NOT going to deliver a flag, Classy players will Viney signing reeks of yet another "Panic" by our Footy admin that saw us do the same thing to sign Goody for an eternity! No wonder we are so bloody average Viney 5 years FMD

Yep coz he is a Rugby player nothing more or less, Crazy decision for a limited player!

A 5 year deal?? Crazy!!!!

A good mate of mine who played 200 odd games of VFL/AFL made an "Astute" observation to me on the phone the other night. He said he detected a noticeable increase in Clayton Olivers decision making at around the half way part of the season. In essence he believes he made much better decisive decisions to Accelerate out of the packs rather than the obligatory dishoff handball. He believes Clayton Olivers peripheral vision to be as good as ANY in the game and a key factor in his split second footy nous. Now yes I know some of his handballs have been erroneous but the other aspect that my mate suggested is that too many teammates are standing flat footed instead of being as aware as they should be. Interesting stuff! He also said put Oliver in a top 4 side and he stressed top 4 and he said he would become Extremely elite and win a Brownlow!

Yes I do as well, however IMV Oliver's season was much better than Viney's! Here we go Head to Head Clayton Oliver CLEARLY HAD a much better season than Viney !!! CLAYTON OLIVER Season 2020 Totals/Averages GM K HB D M G GA B T HO FF FA CL CG I50 R50 AF * SC * Total 17 195 230 425 57 3 9 1 92 0 22 22 110 69 64 27 1,559 2,078 Average 17 11.5 13.5 25.0 3.4 0.2 0.5 0.1 5.4 0 1.3 1.3 6.5 4.1 3.8 1.6 91.7 122.2 * AFL Fantasy (AF) and Supercoach (SC) stats only include regular season. 2020 Statistical Rankings ● Ranked 15th in Total Inside 50s ● Ranked 5th in Total Handballs ● Ranked 6th in Total Disposals ● Ranked 5th in Total Tackles ● Ranked 5th in Total Supercoach Score ● Ranked 7th in Total AFL Fantasy Score ● Ranked 1st in Total Contested Possessions ● Ranked 7th in Total Effective Disposals ● Ranked 2nd in Total Clangers ● Ranked 1st in Total Clearances ● Ranked 6th in Total Centre Clearances ● Ranked 1st in Total Stoppage Clearances ● Ranked 13th in Total Turnovers ● Ranked 6th in Handballs Per Game ● Ranked 9th in Disposals Per Game ● Ranked 8th in Tackles Per Game ● Ranked 3rd in Supercoach Score Per Game ● Ranked 6th in AFL Fantasy Score Per Game ● Ranked 2nd in Contested Possessions Per Game ● Ranked 9th in Effective Disposals Per Game ● Ranked 6th in Clangers Per Game ● Ranked 1st in Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 6th in Centre Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 2nd in Stoppage Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 18th in Turnovers Per Game Season Highlights ● 31 disps (17 kicks 14 hballs), 3 marks, 5 tackles and a goal in Rd 11 57-pt win over North Melbourne at Adelaide Oval (9 Aug 2020) ● 34 disps (17 kicks 17 hballs), 5 marks, 6 tackles and a goal in Rd 10 51-pt win over Adelaide at Adelaide Oval (5 Aug 2020) ● 28 disps (12 kicks 16 hballs), 5 marks and 10 tackles in Rd 8 4-pt loss to Brisbane at Metricon Stadium (26 Jul 2020) ● 29 disps (16 kicks 13 hballs), 6 marks and 6 tackles in Rd 7 43-pt win over Hawthorn at GIANTS Stadium (19 Jul 2020) ● 28 disps (12 kicks 16 hballs), 5 marks and 5 tackles in Rd 2 1-pt win over Carlton at Marvel Stadium (13 Jun 2020) JACK VINEY Season 2020 Totals/Averages GM K HB D M G GA B T HO FF FA CL CG I50 R50 AF * SC * Total 16 166 152 318 40 5 10 4 67 0 28 15 82 55 68 13 1,207 1,593 Average 16 10.4 9.5 19.9 2.5 0.3 0.6 0.2 4.2 0 1.8 0.9 5.1 3.4 4.2 0.8 75.4 99.6 * AFL Fantasy (AF) and Supercoach (SC) stats only include regular season. 2020 Statistical Rankings ● Ranked 13th in Total Inside 50s ● Ranked 16th in Total Contested Possessions ● Ranked 13th in Total Clangers ● Ranked 15th in Total Clearances ● Ranked 9th in Total Centre Clearances ● Ranked 20th in Total Stoppage Clearances ● Ranked 8th in Total Turnovers ● Ranked 8th in Inside 50s Per Game ● Ranked 11th in Contested Possessions Per Game ● Ranked 12th in Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 13th in Centre Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 20th in Stoppage Clearances Per Game ● Ranked 2nd in Turnovers Per Game Season Highlights ● 27 disps (14 kicks 13 hballs) and 5 tackles in Rd 16 14-pt loss to Fremantle at Cazaly's Stadium (7 Sep 2020) ● 34 disps (14 kicks 20 hballs), 5 marks, 6 tackles and a goal in Rd 1 27-pt loss to West Coast at Optus Stadium (22 Mar 2020)

Well there you have it, clearly our coaches are clueless! How clueless might be played out in this review which might see several on the outer!!

Has PACE, Classy ball user, and Skill. We lack all three. GET THIS DEAL DONE!!

Clayton Oliver had a far far better year than Jack Viney. How Viney finished in front of Oliver is fantasyland stuff.

Thats overs!! just leave out pick 62 and would do this in a heartbeat!

Dan Andrews would be my guess!!

I prefer Jeff Kennett myself!!

Exactly my thoughts on the same game! Get him in !!

GOOD! Does that mean Goodwin is under review??

Yes thanks for the correction 3 out of 4 seasons?? Shheeeeit his price just went up!