Bring-Back-Powell

And for it to be at the G, or at the very least not during lockdown.

And the good news is we’ve got Adelaide away in the next couple of weeks.

Helped us in 2023 by providing a useful wing option. Actually averaged 3 more touches a game than Langdon. His game against Carlton in the semi was underrated IMO. But yeah, clearly went on one year too many, and never got started after that calf issue. Probably won't go down as a Demon great.

If our window is closed for next year with or without the hypothetical inclusion of Houston, then I'd also be keeping pick 5 rather than Houston. The more I saw of us this year, the less confident I am of a sharp rebound to the top 4. But to answer the question in a vacuum of trading pick 5 for Houston or giving 5 years to Peatling, it would be Houston by so far it isn't funny.

From memory WA opened their borders to NT, SA and TAS. So Dees members from those states were lucky enough to attend. You basically had to be the prime minister if you had any hope of travelling from a COVID state to WA. What I don't remember was could you travel from VIC to NT, SA or TAS, quarantine for 2 weeks and then head over to WA?

Houston by the combined length of the Flemington, Mooney Valley, Sandown and Caulfield straights. Houston is chronically underrated by DL posters and would be our clear 3rd best player behind Gawn and a fit and healthy Trac.

A yes please from me. Kicked 4 snags in one of Port’s finals last year and was/is expected to be a key part of Port’s future forward line.

Yeah he was a fixture in the side when Geelong started 7-0 and was getting his 19 touches a game. He was then omitted for our game which raised eyebrows among the Cats supporters. Came back a couple of weeks later for 3 games when Geelong started losing a number of games, and then wasn't really seen again. Could be a sneaky good/rebound kind of recruit for a club next year.

Beefy stats in this last VFL game: 25 touches, 12 marks and 2 goals.

Against Freo we lost the clearances 47-16 without a recognised ruck against Darcy and LJ (the rare game where the combo actually played in the later rounds - yay for us!) We simply couldn't compete in the middle that day and it was a list management melt down as far as I'm concerned. If Campbell played that game, could anyone take a guess what the clearance differential would have been? If he does come across, he'll actually be an important acquisition as we can't rely on Gawn to play 23 games. We also can't throw JVR to the wolves for more than 5 minutes a quarter. His output waned in the latter part of the season aside from the GC game.

His game was fine that night. I was just flabbergasted that he got 3 votes in a game given many posters denigrated him all year, and Kane Cornes suggested he was the worst key forward in recent years.

After all the accolades afforded to ANB for his tagging role on Nick Daicos on Kings Bday, Nick actually got Brownlow votes.

Petty somehow snagged a 3 voter against Geelong…

Trac 10 votes after 4 games!

Any other AFL and MCC members around here that have secured a seat for the big one? Will be a belter of a game to attend.

He's not a good AFL player but if it means we don't have a repeat of the Petty and JVR debacle facing the Darcy's and Jackson's of the league then the acquisition would make sense. The club really needs a ready made ruckman by trade on the list outside of Gawn. We paid dearly for it in the Freo game in which the game was over before it even started.

I really hope for Fullarton’s sake that he would have been behind Forte and Smith in the ruck depth if he were still at Brisbane this year. Otherwise, it would have been a yes to your good question. He’s probably pondering the question as well.

If you read my earlier post: 1) I praised our 2021 finals series achievement by stating we were the third most dominant team since 1990 in terms of cumulative margin. 2) I defended the COVID claim by stating the 2021 season (as opposed to 2020) was just like any other in terms of match and season length. If you think that’s undermining our achievement then good for you. As for the “rent a crowd” claim, I have no recollection of posting it, but if I did was I wrong? How many West Coast and Freo supporters logged on to scab membership codes all the while pretending to be MFC supporters?

For sure. As would Sydney supporters. Potentially 4 GF losses in 10 years without winning one.

Prepared to eat humble pie wit that post, but he’s still an elite coach. The Best neutral final I’ve attended (behind the 2012GF) as it didn’t involve Collingwood wining it.

I would give anything to have Chris Scott as Melbourne’s head coach next year. This mob was a 7-8 side at best at the start of the year. Absolutely gets the best out of his players at his disposal and clearly has a system that can stand up in September.

That’s a fair question re the MCG. Our form at the G was quite ordinary in the second half of the season. 1) Ordinary low scoring scrappy win over Essendon 2) Shock loss to GWS 3) Even more of a SHOCK draw to Hawthorn 4) Beaten by a fellow flag contender Dogs from start to finish in what was considered a litmus test at the time 5) A “meh” win over a mediocre Adelaide where we allowed a big run of opposition goals in the mid part of the game. We’ll never know if we would’ve handled the MCG for a September campaign, but our interstate form for most of 2021 was tremendous.

To all those complaining about the umpiring, did we benefit from any dodgy calls or was it only Freo that benefited?

Does he cop heat for letting Grundy and Jordon go to Sydney to play in a grand final, for minimal compensation? And yes I understand JJ was an unrestricted free agent on bugger all salary, but the facts remain that we did not value, appreciate and anticipate what an asset he was capable of being and that is the art of being a successful list manager.

Definitely some similarities between us and Port. Contest and defence, inefficient inside 50 entries, impotent forward line, inaccurate. No surprise that our last 3 games against Port have been sub 8 point margins either way.