Ferghus31

Fully AGREE a New Coach or our current one is forced to admit his style and game day setups have not worked

Does anyone know what is happening with Choco hopefully staying?

Are you sure most Supporters are like you No! my prognosis is very simple the result of the Review will tell all if he stays or goes.

WHAT WILL HAPPEN IF THE REVIEW FINDS Godwin is one of the Major reasons for our Decline as most are suspicious of

LETS ALL Move on he can play but is he an expert on how Football sporting clubs Work we will find another player that is dedicated and grateful to PLAY FOR US

No matter who we get Goodwin does not take any notice of their opinion just sack him and start again

I am not sure that at the completion of the Review we see mass sackings however if Goodwin Selwyn Griffith are found to be behind our decline they MUST go but our Communications with Members and continual leaks to the Press Need urgent Attention

WAIT UNTIL THE REVIEW IS COMPLETE THEN HEADS WILL ROLL STARTING WITH GOODWIN Then Pert and THE FITNESS STAFF

HIS NAME Simon GOODWIN just do the right thing and go

Why do we still have Goodwin when a person of Quality Integrity and Dam good Bloke we cant KEEP VERY SAD But great for him

Agreed Paul Connors is a man of his word and has integrity

We have a very Good Coach in Mc Qualter stop him from going to WA in his Final Interview at Training sessions he Encourages and the Players like Him NOT SO SURE THEY LIKE GOODWIN

Definitely think he needs 1-2 new voices around him, esp in terms of game-style and nuance things like running patterns, transition especially a very correct observation. HOWEVER my point is he does not take any Notice of his Assistants its his way . My suggestion is we get Simpson OR SOMEONE coach similar just to Put pressure on him lets face it our game plan no longer works

Totally Agree

The Hawks Cats give opportunities to YOUNG Players look at Goodwin took ages to play Monez Wakefield and then selected him kicking and screaming his reference to Fullarton was quite Rude these are only 2 of several incidents . My suggestion is we get Adam Simpson as an assistant coach he is a man of quality tell Goodwin to heed his advice or else. The current review will find that Goodwins people skills and listening to advice is sadly lacking he has a closed mind but if he is confronted and told you are on your last chance we might see some success

The Coach and Fitness areas are in need of a shake up just look at our AFLW Coach his assistants and Fitness staff they provide a great Enviorment for the Players and have respect I cannot say the same For Goodwin

WHY HAVE THEY NOT SIGNED Monez Wakefield HE CAN PLAY

GWS Known as Gillons Western Substitutes and Jesse wish we still had him

Totally Agree But the Board should Demand a FULL AND COMPREHENSIVE Audit and Examination of the Football Operations in all Areas and if the result is damming CHANGE NO PERSON SHOULD BE EXEMPT FROM THE Coach to the Boot studder

That is great news Matty Whelan has a very high opinion of him when i spoke to him he has a Rugby Background and tackles below the Waist you watch he will become a very good player

WHY HAVE THEY NOT SIGNED Nor Selected Andy Moniz-Wakefield THIS KID CAN REALLY PLAY IS THIS ANOTHER Blunder

Goodwin hopefully will follow him lets start 2025 with a Fresh Approach Thanks Greg

Thanks for mentioning Monez Wakefield he will be a Real player i see a similarity to Matty Whelan and talking to some of the Coaches they believe will become a great midfielder he also has a but of mungrel

Hopefully its Goodwins second last game as Coach

Forget contending, it's time for Melbourne to rebuild its list and culture Goodwin has set the tone and is ultimately responsible for our Football Brand Style and Culture i dont think he can fix this time to Refresh and restart