58er

Agree that Robbie is elite but have no doubt if Trac Clarry or Gawny andone or two others play in our next flag they will go to another level of favouritism. All 3 are starting to put together a cv which if mirrored over the next 5/6 years and a flag or two will trump IMO any player of the last 50 years in history and achievement.

Smith YES but not Josh isn't a Lockhart replacement not fast or skilful enough fir minding smalls. Jets possibly Harmes Salem Jordan or even Sparrow would be my choice. These scratch matches fir the Leftovers should be used fir experimenting nes spots similar to Tigers discovering Shai Bolton as an onballer. Experiments I would like to see are: Smith to forward line Hunt as an on baller as his kicking is long snd direct and even Bton just explodes for distance not linking a player! Corey Wagner as small defender Chandler has been given run in backline maybe Bedford also. Its a waste of time if you are going to delist without trying a player in a different position!

While Dan should shoulder ( and I believe will when the enquiry is finished) due to the quarantine outbreak ( guilty of not checking the success etc after a few days ) not of the choice. So is Gladys B ( as is Brad Hazzard) responsible for the Ruby Princess debacle. She has apologised without testing real blame I feel snd could have sacked ( or asked Brad to resign) Brad. AND SCOMO ie responsible fir the Aged Care tragedy. Where is the plan? Says there is one! If There is one lets see it? Oh and if it does exist IT HAS FAILED under any situation in NSW and VIC.He did a general apology but didn't take responsibility really.

The next Melb premiership team will be the best Demons for 50 plus years Yes we should laud and remember our champions but that next flag 22 will all be immortals along with the Coach.

If Melky was going to be dropped it would have been earlier in year Now that he hit his top form last week why would it even be considered. Besides he is one of Goody's faves!!!

Next week or this week ??

Melksham ?? He is in front of Hannan esp in selectors and Goody's eyes snd mine!!!

Sorry wasn't Hannan omitted then got ill any way?

Sorry Lockhart first Chandler got depth 2nd!

Absulutely snd the smaller Bullfog defence might just be his opportunity yo get on the board in a big way.

Good point Rod that was a great piece of play by both players. Maybe it's just his perfectly relaxed and smooth motion but sometimes I think the ball seems to be in slow motion When passed. Wonder if he will ever play in the middle or up forward again. Sometimes I hope he gets switched if we need a boost in either position. Love the family Northpoint Cafe at Brighton Beach North Rd location.

When have I suggested Deserve means gifted???? Jonesy deserves an equal opportunity to Make the milestone bit not favouritism. He did well enough on Sat especially in the wet conditions and his strong body helped in the clinches a number of times plus his tackling was ferocious. All is going well and maybe he can hit the scoreboard a bit this week.

We are officially The Travelling Demonberries !!!!!!

You seem to be the one to move on if you still hold or keep a grudge etc.agsinst Jonesy. Didnt have to mention it at all. Any human saying he doesn't deserve an equal chance to get his 300 is really salty and miserly. The only reason I asked was because of your incredulous statement !!!

Whatever have you been a longtime critic what for pray tell ?

My only criticism of Salo is I would like to see more urgency in his running and delivery by foot. Other than that he is a rock with great disposal and good skills. Good team man and reliable in performance over his 100 games. Congrats and thanks to Christian and good luck fir the future esp in 2020!

Tommy is getting better each game and the ruck assist role suits him. Handy around ground and was so close to clunking 2 or 3 on Sat near the square. Dogs smaller deference opens up our chances fir the taller marking fir Weid and Tommy

Maybe down to %!!!

What about Carlton ?

That's my point DrD Petty "will be a KP either forward or back " not Jacko as you are thinking from my post Jacko will be a ruckman plus mid on ballers plus forward who is versatile because if his range of skills and remarkable athleticism. Of course Petty if at CHF or FF full time will kick more goals than Jacko but how many Jacko gets AND score involvements May not differ a great deal in total.

Won't replace Jacko As both are very different types of player NO ONE plays like Luke he is a freak and a complete X factor on ball and up forward as a floater. Will be Key position back or forward

not sure of where Petty will end up but not on a wing !!! Either CHF or CHB or FB or FF depending upon our key position players and who performs and also maybe as a swing and versatile key. Lets just hope he can overcome his injury if not in 2020 but ASAP.

May be they could bring back Weids Dad To mind Trac!!

Thanks DW thought Clarry May have seen Trac now do it on ball and realised he could also as had gitness and training bade to do the same Yes Burgo that's a definite genius tip. And our whole midfield has turned on it's head as we have 2 inside And outside bulls (Clarry and Trac) now plus much more rated outsider in Gus who likes time and space To dispose. Jack still ferocious and he also is much more composed and kicking beautifully. Did 2 or 3 beauties in front of me at the Gabba yesterday. He is steading like Hibbo and disposal is VIP now. BTW I keep including young Jacko in our midfield as his ball gets after ruck work and 2nd and 3rd follow ups are elite.Rarely wastes a handball and Kicks on the run fine. Such a future has he Cant wait till he plays 50 games wow how good! Its all a half glass full let's hope it continues as We don't really know where this journey may take us! Just win the next game each week and concentrate like that and our position will take care of itself.

True DP Very very Happy to watch another near decade of this midfield if they play like they are now. Plus Jacko!!!