58er

Logan MAC is not to my knowledge a ruckman. You are comparing an Orange with a cumquat !!! What matters is that LJ contributes to the team rucking, up forward in team play, and around the ground as he did on Sat with 4 marks. He is learning on the job and had his season shortened by half last year so needs more games in an important ruck role. He will pay us off in spades in due course up forward as well but he must improve his kicking also.

Your post is confusing pairing them off against each other Some of which I don't agree with. But you only came up with 2 positions for talls not 3 !! Name the 6 or 7 forwards in the 22 please. BBB and T Mac can play in same side plus Jacko running around 2nd rucking and Bailey the fourth person plus smalls. Weid is in the mix but Tmac brings a much more rounded game and competitiveness To our side plus he can play at CHB !

LJ is getting judged harshly He was very competitive in the ruck and that coincided with our run of goals ( coincidence or both Maxy and LN around the ground) LJ took 3/4 marks around the ground and is not a ruck Pushover by any means. Fits in dies team things but yes does need to work on his kicking which no doubt he is by Choco.

Riv played his best game on Sat night and won't be dropped Hibbos kicking is no better than Riv was. Still like Hibbo but not at Rivs expense and I thought Hunr played well enough to stay in the team Hibbo could be the med sub!

And some demented fans say we wouldn't miss him, OR he doesn't impact ( enough) AND/OR he doesn't win us games!!!' Really he does all three and yes he can still improve his quality but boy last night was a big big statement On a big stage. He and Trac showed That they are A graders ( Steele matched them sort of ) and are well ahead of the Saints genuine mids not small forwards and are getting great support from our lesser lights eg Viney Jordan Sparrow ANB and Kossie.

So who is the middle tall in your team ?? BBB will play Ymac is still a different player and can get his win ball plus Jacko is versatile and can play anywhere on the forward line. Bailey is the fourth Player then the variety of smalls. Weid will have to show he us a better option than Tmac IMO. I still wouldn't rule out Petty if injuries petsist.

Best team performance since 2018 come on we have such short memories.

Weid will not Beat Jacko As one is more versatile so BBB Tmacand Jacko with Fritta Kossie Spargs and Prob ABN as forwards best mix.

Agree Tmac is very valuable in his form and is so accurate! BBB would get in Weid May struggle depending on form. Plenty of upside with team over a whole season. Langers is a gem and a great recruit to boot My Hope is Rosman can develop enough to be our other winger ( played his best in VFL practice yesterday with 3 goals).

You have to get a ticket to the theatre for a play or cinema for film also so why the kickback fir a safety procedure that is the same at a lot of other entry points. It gets down to do you really want to go ? If so get up off your proverbial and stop winging.

Unfortunately Lily has not been in great form for about 3 games Zge seems to get caught trying to dispose and falls over or is unceremoniously dumped! Dintvtjink it's confidence with her but lard hope she is back on her game in the Finals. Good luck Lily

Where Langdon haven't seen ONE post like that! And Rivers was back to best today. Hibbo may come in later when injury and form vary,

No no no no form for 2 years and needs to tackle chase and contest properly.

Really move on make it a donation you couldn't use it any way!!!

Get nothing for nothing !!!!! Hope you get it validated etc for your grand child's sake. PS Probably won't ever win the Largest Spending Granny Award for this year but maybe Kindest Granny.!!

Talk about a contradiction One minute you can't take your son along because of the ticketing Is there no Junior Members tickets available separately to join Senior Members? Then at the end you blame kids for losing interest this year because of last year's non attendance availability. Is it both or one or the other reasons??? For away games a GA ticket would cover your child anyway even at an Adult price which is not too dear!!

Great article and saw many Tassie games 1959-1969. Still think our backline can get better With Riv improving and if Petty is st CHB snd we don't need him on the forward line. Tommy MAC would also be a standout if moved back at any stage.

Think you could get away with that pretty easily but someone's name or code is going to be somewhere for tracing!

Absolutely it's Kangaroo Court decision and A disgrace. Who are the Tribunal members here. I f not the AFL are a joke re head injury tackling!

Disgraceful inconsistency by that Trubunal Only Daisy or may be Paxy would qualify for us under the Marinoff/Bowers rule. Perhsps a one game reduction for Marinoff and Bowers initial charge was light on for potential danger!

Travis I am not sure you can just ( ethically) Use another barcode ie someone else's. The while tracing system would be confused if the was permissible. Good luck however.

No pace in that trio no one would catch and tackle a Saint runner and they have about 12. Need to look at Chandler and Viney at least.

Why ???

It is the Danny Frawley Tribute Match so about between 30 and 33 could be possible now 40,000 are able to attend in the Covid mix.

No sorry apologise MD