Everything posted by adonski
-
He and his management have said those rumours were untrue, for whatever that's worth
I think Langford might be a champion regardless of the lack of pace. Gonna be really interesting to see how he's rated come draft night. I'm hoping Jagga drifts out to P5. Would require Norf going early on a tall with pick 2. As well as Adelaide ignoring him. Maybe wishful thinking unfortunately.
What I find stranger is the assumption the Crom will simply take Draper given he's from S.A
A few thoughts on our P5/P9 midfield options, from someone who isn't qualified (note: I am not a doctor) Harvey Langford: Looks a bust-proof, plug and play option for round 1. Looks like a ready made AFL player amongst boys in some of his highlights. Pace is a worry. Xavier Lindsay: Brayshaw replacement? Half back, wing or inside mid all options. Good pace, good skills, accumulates, willing tackler. Left footer which is fun. Could be accused of being a bit vanilla? Murphy Reid: Hands of God (HoG). Class, poise, accumulates well. Not much speed, on the smaller side for a mid. Can get a bit Hollywood with his disposal. Does he get stuck as a flanker at AFL level? Josh Smillie: Excellent movement and agility for a guy his size, kicking seems a bit hit or miss, a bit Petracca like. Rag dolls opponents his own age, will probably continue at AFL level given his size. Could be anything if it all comes together. Jagga Smith: Probably the style of midfielder that we lack. Nice speed, agility, movement, disposal. Buzzes round. Averages 58 touches a game, probably weighs 58kg too. Bit of N Daicos about him. FOS: Slick looking midfielder that kicks goals. Good mark, excellent agility and speed. I'm not as enamoured with him as most seem to be. Not that that means anything. Sam Lalor: Powerfull mid/fwd, built like a brick shizenhausen. Clean & powderful at the footy - internet reckons Richmond are keen at pick 1. Sid Draper: Great speed & explosiveness. Maybe a quicker Serong style mid? Sometimes looks a bit indecisive with ball in hand. Conclusion: Stuffed if I know
Says bugger all, but a short Melbourne summary: On November 8, the pick swap window will close again, until draft night, when it will be pried open once more. MELBOURNE Current draft hand: 5, 9 List boss Tim Lamb said the Dees would look at how many vacancies they leave before planning a draft strategy. With just two top-10 picks, they are well placed for top talent, but have nothing else in the cupboard. The Dees don’t have a future first, after giving that to the Bombers to get pick nine, but have three future thirds to get creative with.
Harrison Oliver is a Melbourne supporter....up to 1st on my rankings now
Might mean Jamie Cripps
Delisted free agent you reckon?
Yep we do, and we have an opportunity to pretty much rebuild the midfield over just two drafts with Kolt, Windsor, 5, 9 But that probably still leaves us a KPF short. I'm torn!
Realistically we need both. We don't have an obvious partner in crime for JVR yet (fingers crossed that's Jeffo but maybe more unlikely than likely at this stage) Petty is a defender long term post May I'd suspect, Disco more of a 3rd tall?
One of a few BigFooty draft watchers
We either get pick 9 or we keep the picks we traded for it
Jefferson was a needs based selection in a weak draft. He has the natural ability, worth a punt. Verrall was a rookie, Adams a later selection, they're gonna have their flaws.
Crows are such a loser club. If we didn't take McAdam last year we would have probably received a 5th rounder for ANB.
STRENGTHS: + Ball use + Consistency + Inside-outside balance + Kick penetration + Versatility + Work rate IMPROVEMENTS: - Endurance - Inside craft Lindsay is a player whose improvement areas are difficult to identify given he does so many things well, and has no glaring weaknesses. His best trait is arguably his ball use, credit to a raking left-foot kick when is often used to penetrate the attacking 50. He uses the ball well on the run, either wheeling away from stoppages or chaining possessions on the outside. Lindsay makes the right decisions and is largely effective in the short and long-range. If being pedantic, Lindsay's kicking is perhaps at its best when lowering his eyes. He is adept at gaining quick metres and compounding them by launching the ball long, but looks so slick when darting short passes inside, down the line, or to leading targets inside 50. Either way, he generates great momentum in attacking phases either as a connective outside runner or clearance winner. Having cut his teeth as a wingman and defender, Lindsay began to gain midfield exposure late last year and that was his primary position for Gippsland in 2024. He still reverted back to that original posting at times for Vic Country and the AFL Academy, but came into the year wanting to improve his inside craft and followed through to average 5.4 clearances from 23.4 disposals in the Coates Talent League. In that sense, Lindsay gets a big tick for versatility. He has maintained his quality on the wing and flanks while improving his contested work and enjoying stints up forward. Few others have the same kind of inside-outside balance as he is developing, and continuing to build his endurance base will only widen his scope. It will also lend to greater durability and see him become even more prolific from contest to contest. Lindsay's consistency is felt through his work rate and week-on-week output. He is capable of racking up bulk possessions as a designated kicker or go-to at the centre bounces, hardly wavering in his ability to have between 20-30 touches. Even if he doesn't his ball use makes him a high-impact type. While most midfielders' defensive running could improve, Lindsay has also shown an appetite for tackling and hunts the opposition. He's the type of leader who can drive standards and lead by example. He did so with a relatively young Gippsland group this year having garnered tips from a squad which produced six draftees in 2023, and one as an over-ager in 2024. Having had arguably his best outing on the biggest of stages - the National Championships final - Lindsay proved he can rise to the occasion and compete with the best of the best. SUMMARY: Clubs in the market for consistent, tough and damaging players who can fulfil a variety of roles should look no further than Lindsay. He firms as a genuine top 20 talent who could feature anywhere within night one of the draft – potentially just outside the first 10 picks. Likely to slot in as a half-back or wingman early in his AFL career, Lindsay offers good scope as a midfielder and his productive ball use suits the way many sides like to shift the ball quickly from end to end. Left footers just look a class above at times, and he fits that bill.
It's all about when you bottom out sometimes. Freo and Suns stacked with picks, Tigers have gotten overs on every deal. Then you've got the opposite end of the spectrum, with sides like the Dogs soon to be shafted on Baz Smith
Tim Lamb made the call...
Smilie's agility and movement is fantastic for a guy his size
Genuine insanity here. Unfortunate Trac wasn't open minded to living on the Gold Coast, we may have got their next 10 years worth of picks.
Pies given up a lot
