adonski

Saads very much an icing on the top type player. I would rate his worth as a late 1st round pick. I think a second rounder is unders, but certainly wouldn’t give a lot away to get him, either.

I could see a scenario where we’d trade a future first for Saad and their second rounder. Deodoro would lose sleep at night not getting a first rounder (even if it meant also giving something back).

Yep, diagnosed with a pea heart

Maybe - but why wasn't he traded at the end of 2019, then? Given he played out of position last year too.

More 'Frost is good' propaganda...just shows that Hawthorn are [censored]

Spill the beans

This cannot be serious

Jackson, Harmes, Hibberd all tests

We've traded Jack Watts for Jack Watts

Langdon left due to Blakely

Take it and run. Doubt Essendon does it though.

I found the crows support of Scholl a bit weird

Some truth in that, but even top 4 sides put out some absolute duds on any given weekend

I mean both Brayshaw and Harmes had career best years under Goodwin, probably Melksham too. Brayshaw & Harmes are victims of playing under Viney. Melksham is anyones guess, with T Mac & Jetta just physically cooked.

We got overs for Frost even when considering Hawthorn's pick will be pushed to roughly the 8th round in the draft

Forgetting Brayshaw, Harmes is faster, bigger, better defensively & a better decision maker in the contest than Jack. Gotta take the emotion out of the name!

I think we may find in time, that Rivers may have been worth the first rounder alone

Thoughts on Bailey Laurie

Big yes if the price is right

Williams should be able to chip in all going well

Could Bradbury the finals and a Brownlow medalist

Well he has something over Harmes then! Who we persisted with down there for 14 odd rounds

Jack leaving would be a massive win if it allowed us to bring a ready made winger (Williams or similar in). Fills a need and also lifts the output of Brayshaw & Harmes.

You're all stuck in the Goodwin school of stubbornness - embrace the vision!