Swooper1987

Not according to the MFC app. And he was drafted as a utility who has played both defence and attack. He was a key defender only last season for the WA national championships. Not disputing he looks an effective forward. Just raising the possibility he could be more than that. I do laugh though at the overreaction - lunacy. Might even be creativity. Something that's probably been a bit lacking this season. And a tall utility is a great asset to have. https://www.afl.com.au/news/672918/nab-afl-u19-champs-finn-gorringe-jacob-van-rooyen-strong-as-western-australia-demolishes-south-australia https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1033254/drafted-demons-land-jacob-van-rooyen-with-pick-no19

Possibly, however the match committee no doubt realised we had Tomlinson as tall cover in defence and our weakness in the seniors was our forward line. Watch this space, I reckon.

Van Rooyen was a very good defender in underage competitions. Perhaps he is the answer to releasing Petty forward. JVR, May, Lever as the back three and Petty forward. That gives us flexibility to switch those two around as required. JVR may well be that very rare breed of key position utility for those old enough to remember in the Terry Daniher/Ross Glendinning mould. At 193 cm he's a little shorter than Petty but he reads the play well and I'd imagine he'd play the intercept game pretty well.

Since 2011 when Geelong won the flag, the record of reigning premiers is as follows: 2012 - Geelong loses elimination final after finishing 6th in H&A 2013 - Sydney loses prelim after finishing 4th in H&A 2014 - Hawthorn wins flag 2015 - Hawthorn wins flag 2016 - Hawthorn loses semi final after finishing 3rd in H&A (straight sets) 2017 - Western Bulldogs finish 10th - 11 wins 2018 - Richmond loses prelim after finishing 1st in H&A. 2019 - West Coast loses semi final after finishing 5th in H&A 2020 - Richmond wins flag 2021 - Richmond finishes 12th - 9.5 wins 2022 - Melbourne loses semi after finishing 2nd H&A Nobody has come runner up the year after winning a flag in this period; two sides have made a prelim and lost; three have bowed out at the semi final stage; one in the first week and two didn't qualify to defend. Our performance was about the "average" for a defending premier over this period. A very hard draw, untimely injuries to important players and perhaps a lack of imagination (or too much faith) from the coaches box all contributed to the seasons result, and should provide some confidence that we will be in the frame again next year.

Whateley on AFL 360 said in his segment with Goodwin and Hardwick that the narrative around Jackson to the west has changed recently. Goodwin maintained the give him all the time he needs line. I reckon it's likely he stays.

N55 row C. Took about 15 minutes. Happy days!

Agree, especially McLean.

Thanks John, agree entirely. They cost us more than anything else on the night.

3 50 metre penalties resulting directly in 3 goals equals 18 points. We lost by 22. I'd say that cost us more than anything. Of course we all respect Sydney but to be honest I have no idea why you'd be disappointed or otherwise in what I think or don't think about Sydney.

Just get there everyone who can. We got 90k crowds to our first two finals in 2018 and I'm sure it made a difference. You never know when we'll play our next one.

However, despite that, we gave away three goals through lack of discipline and another couple with "unforced" errors if such a thing truly exists in finals. And there is the game. I agree that the Swans performance was the best of the first week though.

This narrative that pressure is our kryptonite is laughable. Pressure is every teams biggest weakness. The teams that apply the most defensive pressure always keep themselves in games and give themselves a chance to win. It's what got the Swans their flag in 2005 and it's Roos DNA. Our forward 50 pressure on Friday night was down compared to Sydney's - especially our forward 50 tackle count but we still applied significant pressure over the night. Our lack of composure with the ball when the pressure wasn't there was our biggest worry, as well as a lack of discipline that saw us cough up 3 50m penalties all resulting in goals. In a three and a half goal game, that's a substantial headstart we gave them before pressure even became a factor.

Not certain how easy they are doing it. Our losses to Collingwood and Freo in the run of three were largely injury/personnel based. Injuries in game had an enormous impact - May, Petty, Gawn, Petracca. Then the second loss to Collingwood could genuinely have gone either way, similar to our first loss to Sydney, again without May. Lack of discipline cost us more than anything on Friday night. I reckon those sides played at their best to beat us - that's not easy to do every game.

Agree with this. I'd go further to say that we won the most difficult flag of all to win. Not one single opportunity for a home final, every game at a neutral venue probably makes it the purest finals campaign of all time. Anyone who attempts to rewrite history by belittling our performance last year on the basis that it wasn't at the MCG is absolutely kidding themselves. Geelong until this year proved themselves finals chokers in all environments, the Swans got belted in GF's at the G in 2014 and 2016. No need to go into the litany of finals debacles Collingwood have had at the G. Those who supported us in Perth last year deserve our respect and gratitude.

Not buying the doom and gloom. I've seen enough sides in identical positions to us now (with even worse form coming into finals) make GF's or actually win it. Dropping the first final isn't necessarily an impediment to winning a flag. Just this century you've got Brisbane in 2003, Sydney in 2005, West Coast in 2006, Hawthorn in 2015, Richmond 2020; then teams who have made the GF after losing in week 1 include Sydney in 2016, Collingwood in 2018 and Geelong in 2020 just in the last 6 years. Add to that the Bulldogs who won a flag and made another GF (2016 and 2021) playing each week. Very historical but both flags our own coach played in were 4 week finals campaigns - in 1997 they won them all and in 1998 they lost the first one then got three in a row to claim back to back. Let's hope history repeats.

Just a touch of hyperbole there Daz. Gawn had 30 hitouts from 49 contests and 14 hitouts to advantage. To go with his three contested marks (5 in total) and a goal.Hickey won 24 hitouts from 71 contests with 7 to advantage. With one contested mark and 1 goal. I grant you the bit about Jackson - 13 hitouts from 34 contests and 1 mark and 7 disposals at 43% effectiveness. Gawn got half the centre bounce attendances for the night and beat Hickey comprehensively when he got the chance to play where the best ruck in the league should play - the ruck. I'd argue we would have been substantially better off had the best ruckman on the ground actually played in the ruck for an appropriate amount of time.

That was one of the really great finals games. And makes you realise just how unbelievably dominant our September campaign was last year. That game today was what you always hear about what finals are supposed to be like. I still think our best is good enough to take Geelong if we can get there.

If Harmes is suspended we'd win it on appeal for sure. I reckon he'll get a fine. Late bump, not high, no damage done, 50 given and play on. We'll need him if Petracca is out or reduced to a cameo forward role.

Jackson playing so much time in the ruck really hurt us. Hickey just rag dolled him. Gawn needs to be in there about 80-20. Hickey had next to no impact when opposed to Gawn. Oliver was magnificent, May was brilliant but had one or two "moments" he'd like back. We won't be making many if any changes. Perhaps Harmes the only (forced) omission. We'll beat the Lions - not easily but we'll get it done. Plenty of teams have come from the semi finals (either QF losers or EF winners) to make GF's and win flags - Both Sydney and the Bulldogs in 2016, Collingwood in 2018, GWS in 2019, Geelong and Richomond in 2020. That's just the last handful of years. The Hawks won the flag in 2015 after losing week 1 of finals. We didn't play a terrible game last night. We made too many errors, some under a lot of pressure and some under not much. Some of our star players were very down - Petracca and Brayshaw haven't played that poorly in some time. Jackson had a season worst game. And despite that we had opportunities to win and were in a good position half way through the third quarter. It's far from over but this the greatest test for this team. I think they can do it.

Lovett played more mid under Balme, Binman. Balmey often started him in the centre square. Under Northey he was an outstanding attacking half back. At the time - late 80's early 90's probably the best in the comp. Glenn Lovett was also an excellent mid albeit with dodgy hamstrings.

Other than Hawkins being named captain, it's actually a really decent side. I'd have swapped Hawkins for Lynch but otherwise it's hard to see who didn't deserve to be in there. Congratulations to Gawn who is clearly the best ruckman since Dean Cox. 6 AA's puts him in rare air. Oliver will be there soon enough, and well done to Petracca and May on their achievements.

N6 - 2 tickets. I usually sit N14 as a Trident.

Yeah! N6 - love it!

https://www.zerohanger.com/gws-appoint-richmond-assistant-adam-kingsley-as-senior-coach-126258/

And hopefully this will be shown up in September.