Engorged Onion

Thanks mate. I was being a little sardonic… but what I hadn’t heard was Goodwins presser and being clear about attributes/behaviours we value being made so public - that’s fantasic

Hmmmmm......just on that, how many goals is the minimum for him to retain his spot? ....5? 😇

This was the other scenario I had thought of, and you put it really well Rod. And if this happened, personally I think it's brilliant for Simon. Just like it was for Ash Barty (of recent sports people we know in the public sphere) and for anyone living life and then going...actually this doesn't interest me anymore...time to exit stage left. After all, it is just a game... (it wasn't in 2021!)

If we were watching a press conference after a loss, and a question was asked to opposition coach - "You looked as though you prepared really well, and you were able to really nullify their strengths" What strengths would most likely be nullified, and what strategy(ies) would be used to do so? TIA...

I never said you stated that you said Goodwin would have to be sacked....and it is not tenable that Yze will coach Melbourne in the senior role, unless Goodwin is sacked. It is very likely that Yze will be a senior coach... and not in the timeframe that lends itself to Goodwin exiting. He won't be senior coach at this football club...based on how the side is tracking. No one would begrudge him for applying for and ultimately attaining a senior role, actually all in the community would support it - it is not a reflection of or of not, being appreciated.

Just so we are clear. In your opinion, if he 'walks' ie: secures a head coach position at another club. It is because he is under-appreciated. The only way to retain him and thus show appreciation is by sacking Goodwin, to ensure there is a role for him? ps... can you bullet point explicitly what he has done for 'us'? Because I thought I had appreciated him, but perhaps there are lots of responsibilities I do not know he does, and I would like to savor and appreciate him some more,.

Daniel Chick just missed selection?

[censored] me, the thread title stating "Covid19 claims" is a bit intense...

First game in 3 years live... staying up in Melbs also for the first time in 3 years (Jolimont) on Friday and Saturday.... anyone got some good recommendations for food that isn't fish n chips or good ol australian country town chinese takeaway?

There seems to be a strong anxiety on the board about us losing a KP Defender mid match, and thus TMAC is the only way to manage such a scenario, thus he retains his spot in the side... I'd argue there a range of other options, that don't include TMAC. Including one of the rucks to drop into the hole. If we lose a defender mid match... then so be it.... it happens.

You wrote the question, I suppose you know the answer your after?

downhill skiier 😏

kinky...

It's misery-porn. and it adds nothing to the spectacle.

The Mongrel Review

.

The beauty is within the predictability… so far this year we’ve had 10,3,9,2,7 and 21 more scoring shots in each round, not only that, it’s where the opposition have their shots from typically. there’s more to write but I’m off for a pcr

Spelt 'Hawthorn"... it's such a vulgar name.

It'd be great to be at the match review, to understand what the emotional experience was like for each player on the ground, when we were scoring points, and how that interacted with each players, intensity, belief and just the urge to continue, whilst experiencing (presumably) disappointment? Did they feel deflated? Did it feel like it would 'turn' at some stage? More importantly, now that we've experienced a match like this, what was learned from it emotionally about that sort of situation? And what would happen if it was in a Final?

The match against the Tigers reinforced to me that Goodwin and Co has a plan B (yes I am being cheeky here). But really that Plan B, is an extension of Plan A. The way I see it, if we assume teams will 'back their system' against ours, it plays into our hands of our (Plan A)...things such as Our rolling defensive system cuts down opportunities to kick on the 45 to switch play across the centre and spread us (creating gaps for free players) Due to this, we force long kicks down the line, to wherever Gawn, Jackson, Brown, May Lever is on slow plays On fast plays exiting our F50, opposing teams get dump kicks, typically mopped up by our defensive pressure by our forwards and mids, and repeat entries into F50 occur...typically towards the pockets if it is defensively packed. If a team gets it out moving towards our D50, due to our strength of the back 6 - we can then typically rebound quickly and find space to accurately deliver a ball to a forward Our strength inside AND then outside on the spread (post contested ball) allows us deep entries that either gives us another opportunity to keep the ball in (set up when a point occurs) or it's out of bound and we set up for dump kicks and also the expectation that we're likely to win the clearance. All this works in our favour if a team chooses to try to negate all that (which moves them away from backing their system presumably)..and you get what we saw last night. 3 times the amount of scoring shots due to an inability for the team to get the ball regularly beyond centre square with any 'real intent', due to all players parked between our goal square and center square - with May or Petty acting as sweeper The challenge then becomes for the team to switch, and with Jordon, Brayshaw, Spargo, ANB, Langdon all valuing defense, typically slowing down, and then we are back to a slow play where by it falls to Plan A again (for us) - forcing long kicks down the line. Alternatively trying to go up the center, but risking interceptions and the quick rebound into our F50 Anyway, that's why I think our system is pretty amazing.... because our one woods of Plan A are are better than any other teams, and if teams go to trying to do something alternate, it still plays into our strengths, quite inadvertently. It'll take either injury, masses of individual brilliance, or umpires, or inaccurate kicking to stop us. Feel free to add any other thoughts on how the system works please.

The ride home would be great for some genuine post match downtime by himself...

unsure about one player....who may be omitted due to 'mouth-knack'?

Most Scoring Shots (31) vs Least Scoring Shots (14) of the year... so far.

I hope I am being... went for a spoil, collected the head slightly I think...

Weeks for Brown there on the MRP...