Most Likely never play a game?
Like Troy Simmonds, Simon Godfrey, Shane Woewodin or Brent Moloney?
Not to mention rookie listed players, like Aaron Davey, Russell Robertson, James McDonald, Matthew Bishop, Peter Walsh, Daniel Ward, Mark Jamar or Troy Broadbridge?
Now these aren't great players, but I'd take any of them at the start of their careers over a questionable guy who may play 2 years at best