45HG

Fev kicked most of his goals when Frawley wasn't on him, and when he did kick goals on him they were outlandish flukes. Riewoldt is also, arguably, the best player in the comp and the Dees as a whole weren't exactly after the win after half time - when Nick kicked most of his goals.

I'd have laughed at myself a month ago if I heard myself say this but I too am well over this circus.

Completely disagree. Jurrah has KPP written all over him in my view, I also think this argument has come up before. If jurrah is our third key forward in upcoming years may God watch over and keep those whom we play, because it will be ugly.

I'm loving watching Johnson bowl lately, "tippity" rules seem to come into play. 3 overs for 34 whilst the VICTORIANATOR has 2 overs one maiden for 6 runs.

Judging by those photos it looks like the game will be played mainly down the corridor

I note that you chose a decidedly smaller font size. I assume it is to match the size of your....wit. And yes, you got me

OOOOOhhhh

Jurrah almost reminds me of the way Watts goes about his footy at Casey, and IMO in time will in AFL - quiet confidence that they know they are good they just need to work and work to make it show in the big time.

We did a presentation last week using powerpoint and I swear there was one blind open in the room and you couldn't see what was being shown on the projector. Maybe that's what happened with us, Judd and co. were just too polite to tell us they couldn't see any of it.

Haha, maybe he was telling them that that was a bad thing of Judd to do, or that he doesn't think the Blues boys should kick each other at training.

Certainly seems a more mature, level-headed person than Farmer, but seems to be a player that reminds me of him. When on, can simply do anything he wants. I was thinking carefully not to racially steretype, I hate that, but the other ones I could think were players like Modra but I was probably too young to make a meaningful comparison. I think the things he can do when considering how tall he is, is where my excitement for him comes in.

Hence the title of the thread.

I didn't think you were being serious. You don't think he can be compared to anyone? Personal characteristics probably not - no one has come from where he has to play AFL before. I suppose it's a tough question as he seems to play in a pretty unique way - but he is hardly the first player I've seen who can take a one handed mark, pack mark or big speccie. Certainly he's not the only player to have played with confidence and composure. And seriously, you want me to compare his fingers to other players? Perhaps a KP Jeff Farmer?

We've been kissed on the dick alrady, but there is no chance there will be another Jurrah at PSD 1

Perhaps people vote in polls without thinking

It'd be a fair effort to make an arse of yourself in the eyes of Carlton players.

According to some? For those who have expressed their opinion with words it's 23 no, 17 yes. Seems odd

Don't get me started again on Keane. Bentley had a 'mare...or is just no good...

It's always good when we can talk these things over. I think he's another who's on the way. A very creative player, but yes, as has been stated "star" is a subjective and purely opinion-based label. So one cannot be right or wrong for claiming either side. Personally I equate star with A grader.

No

[censored].

Completely agree with Smith, said much better than how I did around ANZAC time this year.

Grimes, struggle to get a game at Collingwood? That has literally made my weekend. Thanks Xav, you're always good for a laugh. Shouldn't you be whinging about the fixture?

In what way?

I thought so to, but being 22 I'm always told I'm supposed to be a headstrong, arrogant little so and so. So why not play the part. 14-18 Interesting though, 14-18 versus 60-24