Bay Riffin

Why do people rate Mahoney ? Lost the lever deal badly and we just got screwed. Massively. Ridiculous. You alway pay overs to extract a player. Except from the dees. Terrible. Terrible. Terrible waste. So Neale gets more for Freo ?

Sorry but I will spew with that deal. We paid more for hogan as a 17 year old.

This deal can’t be last minute. If they stall till tonight I say we screw them. We want to get May and perhaps another runner. Can’t do all that with little time.

I agree with some of what you wrote but assuming he wouldnt make a great key back is based on nothing. Roos mentioned last week he thought Jesse would be just that. He was all Australian CHB in the under 18s. When hes gone back in periods he has looked natural to me and willing to defend. I think he Could be better than may as he has twice the ability. And a bigger tank. How would you rate jack reiwoldt at 23 ? I thought he was the biggest drama queen and gave up when it all got too hard. He found a way with experience but probably moreso with personal maturity and now he does what’s best for the team.

Nope. Unlikely.

Is it just me or do you get the feeling Mahoney is a bit soft on trades. I get the feeling he doesn’t see us like the power clubs. Even with vandenburg he states this shows we are a destination club like we need to prove it like a little brother proving themselves. This trade was another cross. No tick from me.

Freo watering down their draft picks the cunning rats.

anything less cannot be an option. they are rightfully asking for more than pick 5 for Neale and Hogan is worth more again.

yep really hope we can keep him. His value is highest staying with us. great team player and came back magnificently really after such a long lay off for a big unit.

Mahoney got bent over for the Lever trade. I don’t trust him yet.

if we get May it will be a case of where will Oscar and Frost fit.

well it can set an impossible benchmark to expect never to cop a bad loss. I thought pies looked an ordinary football side one week ago against GWS and could have a flag on Saturday.

where are demonlanders congregating ?

For gods sake will this pillaging ever end. Hope he stays.

Based on Sundays game Im not sure how useful McGovern is as a forward. lacks some skill and class for mine.

his opponent had zero stats. that's the real story.

Hogan is light years ahead of Weideman. not sure how you conclude that.

yes his kicking is reliable and decision making very good. He is a natural. I wish he had more toe but hey you can't have everything.

Was exceptional tonight. Very good all round game. Kicked the clutch goal at the end.

yes but that's about it maybe elite vision as well.

its a good sign to see the 2nd and 3rd categories so well stacked. I generally agree and maybe Lewis and Vince will drop off a bit in their autumn years now. I think the extra we will gain from Salem and Brayshaw will be more about getting them consistently on the park and performing. They already have both shown plenty. same goes for Hogan. I also think Oliver can improve quite a bit in metres gained. so often he doesn't go forward almost by auto pilot. he could break games open more and become even better.

not to mention Lever is young as well.

game on. now Adelaide are saying Lever wanting Melbourne is 'all good and well' but we are negotiating with 10 Victoria clubs. I think they need reminding of the Scott Thompson deal for a late first rounder.

and our opponents will tag him out of the game like the grand final.

and lose two years first rounders ? no thanks