dazzledavey36

Completely different scenario Mgdee. Roos didn't rule out coaching all year and actually chatted to us and showed intrest.. Adams Wants nothing to do with us at all. There are 5 clubs that are his preferred destination before Melbourne so highly doubt he will get through to 5 clubs before coming to us. Get this through your head if he doesn't want to even speak to us DONT bother with him then..

Why are people still bringing up Adams when he has CLEARLY said Melbourne is not in his destinations list. We were never going to get him and never will.

The Giants are a big fan of Sharenberg and see him as a rebounding defender something they lack. They will use pick 1 on Boyd but pick2 would nab them Sharenberg.

Absolutely we should trade pick 2 for Shiels. This bloke considered a top 3 pick before he was initially pre picked for the Giants. Killed us the first time this year with his gut running and speed. Highly regarded for his leadership too.

Does anyone remember when CS came on here and told us he was glad none of us are in charge of the club? Hypocrite of the highest order.

Wow don't know about that.. Graham couldn't even get a gig for the crows. Spud of the highest order. Hampson has atleast shown talent with his marking and ruckwork. Fresh start will do him well for the tiges

Think you will find he is a pretty happy Freo supporter now they are up and going..

Spot on ^

Awsome. Massive fan for some reason.. killer speed and x factor to go with. Would love him on a wing running up and down providing dash and creativity.

Whens the next game Rollo??

Anything much nicer?

Got no time for this [censored]. Tried to get his head into the football side of things then got some home truths of Stynes to never do it again but didnt listern. Players absolutely hated him for the politics he was bringing to the team and caused a big fraction. Got no time for him and never will. Every function he spruiked on about the Melbournes history when he should have stuck to his job and talked about the business side of things.

Ralph the guy is as skinny as what Morton was when he was a under 18 player. Trust me as a qualified personal trainer even with him being in the AFL system his genetics and metabolism he is not going to just stack on 20 kg over his career and become a big powerful midfielder like Jobe Watson who your comparing to. Its way off the mark and no where near What Watson was as a kid. Watson wasnt so much skinny but had alot of puppy fat he had to turn into muscle hence why he looks fairly cut now. With Aish shoulder history aswell he will not straight away just hit the weight and try and stack on weight. It will do more damage to shoulders especially when he is quite young. I see Aish in the same catergory as Morton, Cam Hunter, Kade Simpon, Matty Lappin and even Dustin Fletcher. Will put bulk on but like these guys will always be slender and lean.

Thank you.

Leeroy is my brother Rollo. Doesnt surprise me he did well. Could have been very good footballer if he had the mindset. Injuries did get him early on his career which was a shame.

Very highly doubt Aish will get to Watsons build.. Watson is a solid 96kg with powerful legs. Aish will be lucky to clock 82 kg. If anyone he will most likely have the build of a Kade Simpson or Dyson Heppell.

If you had been watching this year we had MJones, Trengove, Toumpas, Evans, Bail, Blease, Nicholson and even Howe all basically playing outside Roles. We also have Dom Barry who is developing nicely and should play 6-10 games.We then had Viney, Jones, Sylvia and sometimes Rodan as our inside Mids. Two are now gone and Mckenzie just isnt up to it. We got pushed off the ball way too easily and and were continue to get flogged in the center bounce. Yet people like you are still led to believe that Jones and Viney dont need help and someone to ease the pressure. Look at teams like Hawthorn with Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis, Puopolo, Sewell, Shiels. All contested tough mongrel beasts. Sydney have Kennedy, Jack, Mitchell, O' Keefe, Hannerbery, Parker, Goodes as their in and under Ball magnets. We have Jones, Viney....Magner? Mckenzie..? Where is our Mongrel compared to them? You know the blokes that are hard and aggressive at the ball and the man and love to Scrap and dish out a big hit for the team?? Viney and Jones are our only two Mongrel bastards.. We needs blokes that when we dish out the big bumps the opposition come off second best. Kelly is not that type and never will. He will be a good outside player in the mould of Farren Ray or Andrew Gaff but he does not fit our NEEDS. cannot not make that any clear..

By inside i seriously mean a bloke that will cop the hard knocks and burrow in and under against seasoned players. Kelly is so far off that it shouldnt be mentioned in the same sentance as kelly.. Mission can do all the work he can but he is an outside endurance runner that will struggle in his career to put on bulk. Whatever weight he puts on he will burn it off straight away come the season. Kelly is a pure outside. Like Morton, like Gaff and like Scully..Kelly will be a gokd player but he doesnt fit our needs of a inside ball winner to take the pressure of Jones and Viney. He will suit a club like the saints or dogs who need outside run. Glenn Bartlett said we need mongrel in our team. Kelly does NOT fit that bill.

Norwood now out to a 3 goal lead at the 8 minute mark..

I will be very disappointed if we pick Kelly at 2.. We need inside ball winners to Help Jonesy and Viney. Cant keep picking skinny outside midfielders and expect this two to cop all the brunt. We have enough outside midfielders enough as it is. Freeman, Dumont, Crouch and Dunstan are players we should be talking about, and seriously consider. Kelly is that skinny that I don't expect him to make a real impact till another 3 to 4 years. And lets be realistic he isn't gonna put much bulk on either even when he does get into the AFL system. Will be another Cale Morton or Cameron Hunter that just cant put on the weight. Blokes like Crouch and Dunstan will slot in and make an impact Like Wines and Vlaustuin did this year. Even Freeman aswell. Melbourne Football Club should be saying thanks but no thanks.

Dumont who is considerd a first rounder is dominating. He is the game leading disposal getter at the 17 minute mark with 13 disposals, 6 marks, 0 tackles, 2 inside 50s and 51 dreamteam points

Its the 13:45 minute mark and James Aish has 7 disposals 2 marks 0 tackles 2 clangers and 2 inside 50s

Nathan Freeman for pick 2

nah its coming good now. Boy he looks a great prospect. Big Motor, evasive, great leg speed. Reminds me of Stephen Hill the way he breaks the line and pin points his kicks.

keeps stopping and starting for me which is very frustrating...