WERRIDEE

I don't think Bugg is in our best 25. I may put J.Smith ahead of Jetta or Kent depending what happens against West Coast.

B: MELKSHAM, T.MCDONALD, VINCE HB: HIBBERD, O.MCDONALD, HUNT C: SALEM, JONES, LEWIS HF: PETRACCA, HOGAN, BRAYSHAW F: GARLETT, WEIDEMAN, GAWN FOLL: SPENCER, VINEY, OLIVER IC: STRETCH, TYSON, JETTA, KENT EMERG: VANDENBERG, J.SMITH, HARMES

Love the reports. Did Jetta play?

B: JETTA, T.MCDONALD, O.MCDONALD HB: HUNT, FROST, VINCE C: MELKSHAM, LEWIS, BRAYSHAW HF: PETRACCA, HOGAN, WATTS F: GARLETT, WEIDEMAN, PEDERSEN FOLL: GAWN, VINEY, JONES IC: TYSON, HIBBERD, SALEM, OLIVER EMERG: STRETCH, VANDENBERG, HARMES INJ: KENT

What a pathetic effort. We have no skills and give up far too easily. The last 2 weeks have destroyed our progress this year, we never know what Melbourne will turn up. How do we drop Oliver but still give games to spuds like Bugg? Bugg is the new Terlich he should have no future at this club.

I am happy with the McDonaldd's actually. Your comments are over the top with them like they are with Trengove. Why do you want to delist him? Would pick 60 or 80 be better than him? I doubt it. Dawes, Grimes, Terlich and Newton should be delisted happy for the rest of the senior list to stay. Can't delist everybody because you will end up with a heap of picks over the 60's and most of them are no good.

Pretty poor comments even by your standards. He was always going to get another year to prove himself due to being injured for 2 years with a foot injury. If he plays at Casey all year so what! He would not be on a lot of money anyway. Hopefully he can prove you wrong like the McDonald's have. FAR TOO HARSH ON A BLOKE THAT HAS HAD NO LUCK PULL YOUR HEAD IN!

Just a straight swap with the 2nd round pick should definitely be enough. I don't know why anyone would want to trade Salem he's all class. Can't trade Grimes because he is a free agent, Dunn seems a more logical trade.

Harmes has been treading water for a while, it was only a matter of time before he got dropped. His kicking has cost him just like it cost M.Jones a few weeks ago, we are weeding out the poor kicks from the side so I'm not surprised that ANB and Michie are now ahead of him. We need to get games in to the Weid so I'm content to see him get a game ahead of Pedo. I don't understand the replacement for Garlett surely Kennedy was the perfect replacement. I don't know what he's done or not done to be offside with Roos. I don't know what to expect from this game, are we going to be the clanger king Demons (Essendon game) or world beating Demons (Hawthorn game). We must smash them no excuses.

Harry must retire, we can't have 2 more years of this. He was worth a punt but has ended up being a massive bust for us, he's not in our best 22. Melksham, Hunt and Vince and hopefully Hibberd will play off half back next year so their is really no room for Harry, time to cut our losses and hopefully that will give us more cap space to eventually fit in Hogan. Does anybody know why he was put on the LTI list with only 2 games to go? Michie and Wagner have been upgraded due to Melksham and King does this mean White will take H's spot?

Pretty sure I read somewhere that he had a knee injury.

Where's Dawes and the number 1 draft pick?

Not even Roos can save Brisbane.

IN: HOGAN OUT: GARLETT Garlett's too one dimensional if he's not kicking goals he does nothing, he needs to show some form in the VFL. Pedersen should stay but I'm worried we may be too tall having Watts, Hogan, Weideman and Pedersen in the same forward line.

I agree. GREAT WIN DEES! Midfield was awesome today, we are a far better side with Oliver in it. What are Gawn's odd's for the brownlow? What a sensational year he is having.

Really hard to see him getting a game considering Roos has to fit Dawes back into the team.

B: JETTA, FROST, O.MCDONALD HB: MELKSHAM, T.MCDONALD, HIBBERD C: HUNT, N.JONES, VINCE HF: BRAYSHAW, HOGAN, PETRACCA F: WATTS, WEIDEMAN, KENT FOLL: GAWN, TYSON, VINEY IC: OLIVER, STRETCH, SALEM, VANDENBERG

He should be getting a game ahead of Vanders. Don't understand why Vanders seems undropable.

No 15 is Keilty. Your thoughts on Kennedy?

Maybe Essendon as part of the Hibberd deal? Harmes and Vanders surely need big games tomorrow with Kennedy and Oliver in brilliant form in the VFL. Grimes,Michie and Newton are finished at Melbourne, Kennedy and Oliver need to be in the seniors ASAP.

Bugg far too high and Petracca is too low. Brayshaw, Oliver, O.Mc and M.Jones would be in my best 22. GOOD JOB ON THE LIST.

HOW ON EARTH DID WE LOSE THIS GAME? Only Melbourne can dominate a game and still lose. Watts and Vince posters were really costly. The deliberate out of bounds decisions were a disgrace, Foote should never umpire a game again. Gawn has to be All Australian ruckman he was brilliant again and been brilliant all year. Good to see Tyson starting to find some form since I called him the Toump. Not sold on Harmes and ANB Oliver should definitely be game a game ahead of them. Not sold on Wagner either I think he's just warming up Melksham's spot for next year. Dawes kicked 2 goals but he is still a spud. 1 Joe the goose and he also out marked a midget. What was he thinking when he kicked the ball out on the full, a man has to know his limitations. I've seen enough of Hulett to think he should be ahead of Dawes and the sooner Weideman develops the better. A heart breaking loss but a heap more positives than negatives to come out of the game and I'm looking forward to see how we go for the next 5 weeks and especially next year. WE ARE ON THE UP.

His calf's are shot, he can't run constantly that's why he can't play in the ruck. Remember his chasing effort against Kreuzer last year? Dawes is in simply because Roos loves him hopefully Goodwin doesn't feel the same way.

I thought Roos picked players in form? Then why is Dawes in the team? Woeful footballer he should have played his last game against Adelaide, he needs to be delisted. The love affair Roos has with Dawes is amazing. The should have thrown Spencer in the ruck (like everyone he is in better form than Dawes) and play Gawn up predominantly up forward.

I wouldn't worry too much about Oli Picket he'll be right. His tank has been a problem all year, would prefer to see him run out some games in the VFL before he gets back in. Would prefer to see Harmes and M.Jones get a run before Grimes and Michie and I doubt that Garlett has done enough to get back in the side. Popular with clientele hey! Does this involve night shifts?