WERRIDEE

Another one that doesn't do his research. The Richmond thing has already done. No one in their right mind would say he was successful at the Bulldogs because it's just not true. I will take into account that you are a Sydney theatre goer.

Melbourne can go for anyone they like at pick 3 except Lever. He's done his knee and there is a high risk he could do it again. He would have to be as talented as Schwarz for us to even contemplate such a risky decision. He sounds like Grimes not a lot going for him except he is a fantastic leader. We have been given a gift at pick 3 we shouldn't [censored] on it.

Blease did look good when he played in the championships but Zaharakis looked better we should of taken him. Laverde can take a grab so he has a few more tricks than Blease.

I'll be laughing at the haters that doubt me not the club.

You still have said how many games you have watched McCartin play. You can have a go at McCartin but I can't have a go at McCartney pot\kettle I say.

I didn't think I had to make a suggestion I just don't think he is the great get that everyone suggests he is and I typed the reasons why I don't think he is. I would prefer someone with a Sydney background.

That's a hard one, preferably someone not recycled. Somebody that could be moulded into a Roos proto type. I think it would be hard for anyone who has coached for 16 years to change his philosophies and follow Roos's strict game plan. The Bulldogs, Geelong and Essendon don't play anything like Melbourne.

Who did Craig develop? Walsh was always injured and Spangher is a handy premiership player. Crameri got paid over twice the amount he was getting at Essendon to play for the Bulldogs. Both Mooney and Scarlett don't strike me as coaches and it looks like they both made the wrong decision. We'll see how the young Bulldogs go next year.

Prove that Hird said it. Anyone could of turned those players into stars, Selwood was a star in his 1st game. You make it sound like McCartney was the senior coach and Thompson was the assistant. Keep on coming haters I love it.

1998-99. Who's the half wit? Who doesn't do their research? Look it up yourself. BP's not the only one I got right I got Sylvia, Cook, Bailey and Mark Williams just to name a few. My user name was LITTLE STINGA, bjgc could of been my username for my Bailey comments.

Because I don't blindly fall in love with every appointment Melbourne make? I rate his possible appointment up there with the 2 year deal to Barry and the 1 year deal to Terlich. He will give us what Craig gave us NOTHING. If we are fortunate maybe he will bring over a spud like Sellar. He done nothing at Richmond, Essendon and the Bulldogs but got lucky at Geelong. To all the other haters I remember getting abused by Demonland for my views on Prendergast when he was at the club, funnily enough no one is defending him now. So keep the hate up as I will have the last laugh when he fails.

How many games have you seen McCartin play? Even if he's a spud we will have greatest development coach in the universe in the great McCartney and he will singlehandedly turn him into a superstar like every player he is going to develop.

And your record is great is it? Keep up the love affair with hacks it makes me laugh.

I put it down to Thompson a proven coach. McCartney was at the right place at the right time like Neeld was at Collingwood.

I thought he was the most outstanding player in the SA V VIC METRO game. He singlehandedly kept them in the game, he seems to have it all, he can take a mark, he's quick, good at run and carry and has a real x factor about him that I didn't see in Petracca or Brayshaw. Didn't see much inside work from him which must be his only downside. Sounds like he could go to Collingwood at pick 5.

What about Neeld? Premiership coach at Collingwood, we must of failed Neeld.

Nah he's a gun coach with a winning % of 30 he will go down as one of the great coaches of the modern era. The discontent at the Bulldogs all year was just a myth. Undoubtedly the greatest coach we have had since Norm Smith.

We already know. Play Viney on him. McCartney was a failure at the Bulldogs, hated by all. How is this a good get? Just sounds like another reject at Melbourne, we would be just as well off going for Neeld as a development coach.

Dawes is suspended for rnd 1.

Howe was supposed to be a smokey and people thought he would go late in the draft with a pick in the 50's. It was a midfielders draft and we went with all talls, I still don't understand the logic behind that decision. I don't know if we got the Howe decision right when Parker was still available (I know who I would rather have), if we got him at pick 50 instead of Davis then we would have won.

Your being a bit dramatic aren't you? Our recruiting had been dreadful, no use hiding from it.The article is clearly flawed anyway. As if Wines and Motlop can't get ahead of Goldsack and Scott Selwood in the starting 18. We only got Bail and McDonald right, something Prendergast can hang his hat on. What a recruiter he was? How bad was the 2012 draft? No one's made us pay for recruiting Jones and Terlich. They are also being very nice to Taylor, we could of got Dunstan instead of Salem and we could of got Ben Brown ahead of Kennedy-Harris.

I don't think it would be a factor at all. He could go to any other Victorian club and still spend time with Bernie if he wanted to.

I don't see why they wouldn't give him every chance to prove himself in the pre season and if he doesn't prove his worth then he doesn't play RND1 like any recruit, he doesn't have much competition TBH.

Even if Roos is anti talls it doesn't mean he can't be persuaded or even overruled on picking a tall. I remember Danny Frawley saying he was overruled by the recruiters when he wanted Pavlich and they went for Fiora, so it can happen.

There is no chance in hell that Walker will land at Melbourne. No proven gun will go to a bottom club like Melbourne, it just doesn't make sense. The only thing we can do is what the Bulldogs did and throw money at an unproven kid.