WERRIDEE

The worst thing Jason Taylor done was recruit him ahead of Ben Brown. I doubt that we would lost a game if we had him in the side.

IN: ANB and Melksham out: jkh and bugg

He's playing down back in the VFL isn't he?

Kent was named our second best player behind Wagner. Did you see it differently or are we really that bad?

His form was good this year.

Give me a break

How did King go?

Is there any tall forward\ruckman in this year's draft? Sam Reid for a 2nd round draft pick. I still think when fit our 2 Gawn and Spencer can play in the same team.

Interested in how King went.

I doubt Tyson will get dropped. Bugg's spot is up for grabs if he doesn't perform.

Is Weideman playing? Trenners the only Melbourne listed player over 20 possessions is disappointing.

We could get away with Gawn being injured but to lose Spencer as well is a massive blow. We only have kids left in King and Filipovic who you wouldn't think would get thrown to the wolves. Pedersen and Watts are second stringers.

We won't win a game without a ruckman. The last quarters against Richmond and Geelong show how bad we are without one. To have to rely on Watts and Pedersen means trouble. Looks like we will be talking about draft picks again, I thought we were past this. [censored] injuries have killed us this year.

IN: LEWIS, O.MCDONALD, PEDERSEN OUT: SMITH, SPENCER, JKH

The Riewoldts, Hawkins and McCarthy have killed us this year. This year McDonald has been far too loose, we probably need another tall back to give him a chop out.

Weideman obviously didn't play?

If he has another poor game I think he'll make way for Lewis.

Smith should have been ahead of Weid last week. Hogan and Hibberd are no brainers. JKH is a surprise but it sounds like Kent had an ordinary game in the VFL so it looks like it was the right decision. Does anybody know how many tackles JKH got last week in the VFL? Bugg is unlucky but we can't fit them all in.

IN: BRAYSHAW, FROST, SPENCER OUT: HARMES, O.MCDONALD, GAWN Weide gets one more chance, he and Smith can fight it out for who stays in the team when Hogan comes back.

To be fair on Viney Danger kills everyone.

Did Brayshaw play?

Has anyone mentioned Kent's goal kicking, it never seems to improve every 5 shots from him I'm expecting 1 goal 4 or 2 goals 3. We can't afford to have a forward who wastes as many shots as he does. The sooner Frost replaces Oscar the better I've lost faith in him.

What is Oliver's odds for the brownlow? A star in the making.

B: MELKSHAM, T.MCDONALD, GARLAND HB: HUNT, O.MCDONALD, VINCE C: SALEM, JONES, LEWIS HF: PETRACCA, WATTS, BRAYSHAW F: GARLETT, HOGAN, SPENCER FOLL: GAWN, VINEY, OLIVER IC: TYSON, HIBBERD, STRETCH, BUGG EMERG: WEIDEMAN, HARMES, NEAL-BULLEN

Giants dogs saints dees swans eagles hawks cats blues the spoon sheil the brownlow Cameron the coleman