WERRIDEE

He's a better field kick than you give him credit for and he's a better kick now than he was as a CHB.

Are you talking about Marty Hore? Too small.

Interesting that he lead the pressure acts and tackles. Hard to see him up forward HF: MELKSHAM, JACKSON, PICKETT F: T.MCDONALD, WEIDEMAN, FRITSCH Looks too top heavy. I wonder if they will consider him at CHB. Dropping Tomlinson he was once a great CHB beating the best CHF's around before he was our number 1 forward.

To me he's keeping Bennell out of the team and that's a pretty good achievement.

Add very few injuries too. Compare that to Misson it's chalk and cheese. Recruit of the century if you ask me.

Sorry Jas. Funnily enough when we lose I think you can't recruit when we win suddenly your a genius. This year's recruiting spree has been amazing. Jackson, Kossie and Rivers all look amazing. Last year's not so but Sparrow is starting to look the goods. Weid's finally showing something, Clarry has been amazing and Petracca and Brayshaw have showed why they are top recruits, Salem has also been good. Overall it's been a lot better than Prenergast. Win us a Premiership and your our recruiter for life and I will never doubt you again.

Tommy couldn't possibly play we would be too tall with him in the side which is stiff because he did play well against North. I don't think you could drop both Vanders and Chunk one needs to be there for their hardness. I'm starting to head towards Vanders being dropped due to the free kicks he's given away. Lockhart could only come in for Harmes due to the 7 backman rule but I would keep Harmes to tag Sidebottom along with Sparrow and rotate through the backline when Sparrow is tagging Sidebottom so I would leave Lockhart out for another week.

Zac Williams would be a great get. Plays more half back but I'm sure he could play on the wing.

I can't think of any. He's been great a big reason why we have moved up the ladder.

Vanders could be in trouble his form hasn't been great so it's either him or Jones. Harmes is another who could be in trouble if they want to play Lockhart. Tomlinson stays at CHB I think he has been alright in that position.

How can you drop Hannan? He was great especially early. Lockhart will have to bide his time. Harmes is playing a different role need to give him more time. We are no good with 3 talls stick with Gawn, Dogga and Weid.

Pretty good you would think was one of our best.

IN: GAWN, VINEY OUT: JONES, TOMMY

6 PETRACCA 5 OLIVER 4 BRAYSHW 3 JACKSON 2 PICKETT 1 LEVER Langdon unlucky not to get in the votes

Well done Dees we belted the 2 bottom teams and that is what we had to do now for the test against the Pies. Petracca BOG again. Oliver continuing his great form Brayshaw played great replacing Viney. The young guns are the story of the night Kossie electrifying, great game from Dogga to beat the 3rd best ruckman in the league in Goldstein. Sparrow and Rivers deserve a mention as well. A special mention to Spargo I thought he was cooked but he deserves another game after that effort well done son

Dogga, Kossie, Weid and especially Trac are killing it. Spargo a surprise. Keep it up Dees bury them.

Weid and Petracca are killing them. Umpiring still shocking though.

Sorry Spargo

Umpiring [censored] awful. Goodwin has [censored] this game up by playing Gawn against Adelaide. We have a fight on our hands.

You shouldn't be a mod you don't allow opinions.

It's only one week. Jackson needs to ruck wether we like it or not. Tommy can't ruck.

I think the Weid will second ruck. Tommy permanent forward. Key backs don't ruck Tomlinson won't ruck. Jackson to ruck back and midfield like Gawn. Weid to ruck forward and a little bit in the middle when Jackson needs a break.

He was carried in 2018 he showed his worth for the last year and half. I think the reason why he is in is because they dropped\managed Bennell and they want another forward and Spargo is the only forward left.

I want the best 22 in the side not the worst 22. Spargo is in the worst 22 he makes our team worse I can't stand that.

B: SALEM, MAY, LEVER HB: HARMES, TOMLINSON, HIBBERD C : LANGDON, PETRACCA, VANDENBERG HF: MELKSHAM, T.MCDONALD, HANNAN F: FRITSCH, WEIDEMAN, PICKETT FOLL: JACKSON, OLIVER, BRAYSHAW IC: JONES, SPARROW, SPARGO, RIVERS We have 7 defenders so I think Harmes will definitely be back. Jones and Sparrow in the midfield. Spargo forward but I think he could spend time in the middle, it's worth a shot he's not a forward. Rivers as the 7th defender.