SPC

His reading the ball in flight against Collingwood was terrible. His great strength last year has become his weakness.

He wasn’t, it was actually Salem for not taking possession and knocking the ball on.. thought May was good and Lever worked his way into it

Not sure he is VFL standard either. Lockhart is a jet, would be a straight swap if Goodwin wasn’t the selector!!

Lockhart and Bedford played well. Both will be in the AFL side regularly over the next 2 years. Lockhart is that far ahead of Spargo it is obvious

Love Baker and Fritsch on the wings

Who cares.. all I know is she is as hard as a cats head.. is that where the link is?? ?

If.. the.. price.. is... right!!!

Never brought into the hype when he was drafted.. didn’t get excited when he was talked up in the VFL.. have since watched his first 3 games at AFL level and I’m sold!!

Is Oscar still here?

Do you count a 1% when you stuff up and then try to recover the ball, by knocking it to a team mate? Cause he is valuable then.

I would keep Hannan and get rid of Spargo. Otherwise this looks good.

Agree. I like him and Smith together, they work better than he and McDonald.

What I’m amazed by- is how he has actually become weaker in the contest. He gets pushed off it by small and talls alike. He has gone backwards. He never marks it in the contest and often mistimes his fist back into a dangerous spot. Love to know what is happening.

Gee the ‘After the siren’ videos are cringeworthy. It’s like me apologising to my wife for saying she is unreasonably when she has her period.. completely token!

[censored] body on body - so I’d suggest not

Ryan Ferguson no 2

I’m annoyed, we were outworked in the last quarter. Reality is, our backline contains 2 half forwards and a midfielder. It was the difference tonight. Once they got entries, they scored! Oscar continues his poor form

Weid was ok. Just needed to kick the winner..

Gee Oscar is a spud..

Did the AFL not bring in a rule about paying a fifty if a player disposes of the ball and is wrestled- preventing them getting to the next contest..? the game is rife with pining blokes, holding, grappling, elbows to the chest of blokes on the ground.. Get a grip AFL.. game is a joke!

Not sure it is a real quick brain. Has a bit of Harry O madness about him.

Salem only one who ticks both boxes.. YZE 2.0

Over the last few weeks he has been.. Terrible kick and runs around in circles.. He is the worst player i have seen in a Melbourne jumper over the last 20 years. Big shout out to Shane Valenti.

Sorry for the question if it has been answered before- but was he playing any good before he was injured?