ManDee

I watched the replays of the Collingwood and GWS games on the weekend. Jeremy Howe took some great marks, gave away frees, 50m penalties and hardly hit a target. I think we will be a better side without him. (How sad-watching replays at this time of year I hear you say. My son has returned from os after 2 years away, we had some footy to share. Big dees fan!)

Get your priorities right leuco, that PhD can wait.

My first mistake? The comment was he was too big, are Ollie Wines or P Dangerfield too big at 92kg (quoted) or Dane Swan 93kg or Jab Watson at 94kg. He certainly wasn't too tall. PS. I don't believe quoted height or weights, but they are a guide.

I thought it should be mentioned here due to dear Andrews calls to the EFC. Perhaps he has form. Happy to remove if you think it duplicates info.

And around in circles we go.

Lucky we wren't talking about Jayden Hunt.

James Magner Personal information Full name James Magner Date of birth 12 August 1987 (age 28) Original team(s) Dandenong Stingrays (TAC Cup) Draft No. 42, 2011 AFL Draft, Melbourne Height/Weight 178 cm / 82 kg Position(s) Midfielder Club information Current club Port Melbourne Way too big? Gary Jnr Ablett #9 Gold Coast Suns Age: 31yr 7mth Games: 274 Born: May 14, 1984 Height: 182cm Weight: 85kg Position: Midfield Nathan Fyfe #7 Fremantle Dockers Age: 24yr 2mth Games: 112 Born: September 18, 1991 Height: 190cm Weight: 88kg Position: Midfield or the same as Jack Viney, way too big. Jack Viney #7 Melbourne Demons Age: 21yr 8mth Games: 49 Born: April 13, 1994 Height: 178cm Weight: 82kg Position: Midfield

If Magner was that good where is he playing now?

Consistantly fickle.

If you had a choice of a new player at MFC next year and the choice was $cully or VanDenBerg who would you pick? For me I would rather VDB which does not say much about $cully

When you think of the experiments they performed on young men it is probably appropriate.

Lingchi We can only hope.

If it was a team failing why have the team not been punished?

Is it near the any key?

If we are found guilty of cheating don't penalise us. So what if we gained an unfair advantage by cheating, don't take away poor Jabs brownlow. Our team of discredited drug cheats worked tirelessly to enable Jab to win that brownlow. He deserves it for all the hard cheating we did, whatever it takes.. Don't you know the old saying , cheats never prosper except Essendrug. Edit: F you Essendrug

Don't hold back Beeb, what do you really think? Thinking about it, fair call.

You want me to stand behind these guys? And I'm not wearing a silly hat, you can photoshop it!

A surprise for me would be Petracca not being fit.

You are all being 4rseholes now.

Most would know that I regularly disagree with stuie, his manner and tone are often way off and I have said so here both publicly and privately. In this case he is right. Give credit where credit is due. I have no doubt that in the future I will be siding with you against him if you are right IMO. Life can be like that.

No, I have not received any pm today. Can you resend?

Often when I hit the "Reply to this topic" my previous reply appears in the box and cannot be fully deleted. I have had to post then delete. Then start agin, the next time is ok.

From John Silvester crime reporter The Age "He reacted extremely angrily, very very agitated, began swearing at me, standing over me physically, it was extremely intimidating," the Sydney woman, identified as "Tracey", told Channel Seven. This means he will, belatedly, be investigated for threats to kill, assault and assault with a weapon. Under the law, it doesn't matter if someone intends to carry out a threat to kill, it is still an offence if the victim fears he or she will. "If a police officer was on the scene you would have expected Martin to have been arrested on the spot. But this is a relatively simple investigation with a simple outcome. If there is sufficient evidence Martin will be charged, if not, he won't. The AFL and police have tried to lead in the area of violence against women but they have stuffed this up. One of the key priorities in such cases is the welfare of the victim. While the police and the AFL were handing out press releases did anyone bother to tell this woman the case was now a criminal investigation. The answer is no. She learned about it on Twitter and feels betrayed by the very people she needs to trust. What a disgrace." Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/about-bloody-time-why-did-police-take-so-long-to-launch-dustin-martin-probe-20151210-gll17x.html#ixzz3tyqkhnpG