1. Neitz to be in a forward pocket

2. Robertson and Neitz to lead from goal square, Tony Lockett style 30m out shots at goal.

3. More penetrating kicks into 50 not on the 50.

4. Replace Davey with Valenti

5. Moloney into Mid field.

6. No long Kicks to one on ones. We dont have anyone strong enough to take a strong grab 1-1 unless going to Neitz in goalsquare.

7. Send Miller back to Sandringham,

8. Bring back Whelan, Rivers.

Anyone else have any thoughts?

1. Neitz to be in a forward pocket

2. Robertson and Neitz to lead from goal square, Tony Lockett style 30m out shots at goal.

3. More penetrating kicks into 50 not on the 50.

4. Replace Davey with Valenti

5. Moloney into Mid field.

6. No long Kicks to one on ones. We dont have anyone strong enough to take a strong grab 1-1 unless going to Neitz in goalsquare.

7. Send Miller back to Sandringham,

8. Bring back Whelan, Rivers.

Anyone else have any thoughts?

7. Send Miller back to Sandringham,

Far too considerate! I think there is a Sandringham in the UK. He would struggle there too!

drop weetra, buckley, bode, garland...not ready for AFL footy yet...

as much as i agree with the droppings of bode garland and weetra i reckon we axe the older players first. they are just getting into the swing of things (without much leadership i might add) - the older guys don't have that excuse.

Out - BRUCE - absolutely no two ways about it, must be the first one gone, Miller, McLean, White, Robertson, Garland, Wheatley, Weetra, Green, Bode, Davey (inj)

In - Rivers, Whelan, Petterd, Maric, Holland, Meesen, Bate, Frawley, Moloney, Newton, Martin

B - Whelan Carroll Frawley

HB - Bell Holland Rivers

C - Jones Moloney Morton

HF - Dunn Neitz Bate

F - Maric Sylvia Newton

R - P.Johnson McDonald Bartram

I/C - Martin Meesen Buckley Petterd

I think you are both hard on Miller - he should be playing CHF.

Agree on Neitz and Robbo.

Garland, Weetra, Bode to be dropped - Davey out injured.

Frawley, Rivers, Moloney, Whelan (if fit) to come in.

Green to play HF

Bruce on ball

B: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Rivers Frawley Wheatley

C: Dunn McLean Morton

HF: Green Miller Sylvia

F: Robertson Neitz Bruce

Foll White McDonald Jones

Res: Johnson, Buckley, Moloney Bartram

Bate is injured?

It's a football; kick it;

Wattching Morton is one of the few things that please me, at the moment. He is no champion yet, but, he just might be!

Here is what annoys me the most. Seems to happen with whoever we play.

When we rebound from our D50... We're slow, indecisive and can only ever seem to find stationary 1on1s or leads where their opponent is still able to spoil.

When other team rebounds, they go through the middle, their leads seem to be 5 meters in front of our player or there is string of unmanned players across the entire field. :angry:

Out - BRUCE - absolutely no two ways about it, must be the first one gone, Miller, McLean, White, Robertson, Garland, Wheatley, Weetra, Green, Bode, Davey (inj)

Are you kidding me. I thought he played a descant game on B.Johnson today. in the first half he kept he pretty quiet.

drop weetra, buckley, bode, garland...not ready for AFL footy yet...

That's right, lets drop our future now so we can have less pain next week. But we can have an extended envelope of pain over the next few years by bringing on the kids via the drip feed.

That's right, lets drop our future now so we can have less pain next week. But we can have an extended envelope of pain over the next few years by bringing on the kids via the drip feed.

Sorry, but Weetra, Bode and especially Garland are not part of the future.

Here is what annoys me the most. Seems to happen with whoever we play.

When we rebound from our D50... We're slow, indecisive and can only ever seem to find stationary 1on1s or leads where their opponent is still able to spoil.

When other team rebounds, they go through the middle, their leads seem to be 5 meters in front of our player or there is string of unmanned players across the entire field. :angry:

Spot on. And had enough of players streaming from the backline only to stop and handpass to a stationary target, stuff the handpass and turn it over for an opposition goal. Surely it can't be instinctual to stop and handpass when you're clear and running out of defence.

Are you kidding me. I thought he played a descant game on B.Johnson today. in the first half he kept he pretty quiet.

Yes 'Addam Magic" Bruce kept the dangerous Johnson very quiet and yet Yze Magic with his intense hatred for Cam wants him to be the first to go! THANK GOD HE IS NOT A SELECTOR! He would have to be the greatest knocker of our Melbourne team.

Out - BRUCE - absolutely no two ways about it, must be the first one gone, Miller, McLean, White, Robertson, Garland, Wheatley, Weetra, Green, Bode, Davey (inj)

In - Rivers, Whelan, Petterd, Maric, Holland, Meesen, Bate, Frawley, Moloney, Newton, Martin

B - Whelan Carroll Frawley

HB - Bell Holland Rivers

C - Jones Moloney Morton

HF - Dunn Neitz Bate

F - Maric Sylvia Newton

R - P.Johnson McDonald Bartram

I/C - Martin Meesen Buckley Petterd

What absolute [censored] about Bruce. Did you go to the game? You are paranoid mate. GO and barrack for someone else. You have NO LOYALTY at all. King KNOCKER!

Bruce did well on Brad Johnson, but it has got to the stage where I don't want him getting the ball. He coughs is up far too regularly for a senior player.

There is a spot for him in the side in a defensive role.

Bate is injured?

Yes.

Sorry, but Weetra, Bode and especially Garland are not part of the future.

More CAC blunders.

More CAC blunders.

Weetra - Pick 62 in 2006. Massive failure!

Bode - Off the rookie list. What was CAC thinking at that time!

Garland - He's only played four games in sides that have been comprehensively flogged.

CAC deserves to fairly analysed and assessed. But FFS do it on the picks that count with a fair consideration of the facts.

7. Send Miller back to Sandringham,

Far too considerate! I think there is a Sandringham in the UK. He would struggle there too!

Miller was far from our worst last week - I thought he had a dip which could not be said for the majority who took the field - Junoir deserved much more..

By playing Cameron Bruce so deep, you lose a good player.... although was not sure he was fully fit!!

weetra must be put back to sandy - he looks like he is lost out there.. lindsay gilbee was the most effective player in the first half and weetra touched it once i think... also looked to be a little slow

garland - two efforts on the outer wing were terrible.. not attacking the footy and not marking it in front of the eyes.. once might be understandable but twice in a minute, well... really struggled.......

the problem is that the leadership group and senior players are also playing so poorly and really is there anything to be gained in dropping the youngsters....

would dropping a robbo have a bigger impact...

on saturday he was getting me so infuriated with his selfishness!! i am at a loss of words to describe his footy at the moment.. going for the spectacular when even the easy is made to look hard.. i would be much be happier if he chased, presented harder, shephered and acted like a leader of the team..

we do not do the unselfish things good clubs do.... on saturday the number of times we switched the ball but then we had no-one to kick to.. no-one was prepared to run hard to make space and to make a lead....