Colin Sylvia wont even finish in the Top 10, come on be realistic!

Not sure of top 5 but yeah, shoe in for top 10..!

1. Jones

2. Jmac

3. White

A very close battle between 1 & 2

I hope Jonsey wins it as there has been no one else that deserves it...

He has been our most consistent player all year...

White, JMac Robbo have also had reasonable seasons but the baldey deserves it.....

Its evident we dont have any real stars by the fact our all australians a few and far between and we havent had a dual B & F winner since that big Irishman.....

i reckon nath jones should win, he has put in all the hardwork and effort this season and has stood up for the team. it is only his second year, and there isn't much else you could expect from him

1. Jones

2. McDonald

Jones

McDonald

Green

Bell

White

...and after that it gets very hard. That's pretty much all of our list that has played more than 18 games this year.

'Shame on you' to everyone who excluded Bell.

The Keith 'Bluey' Truscott medal is awarded to the best & fairest Melbourne player of the season.

The award was named in honor of the late Keith 'Bluey' Truscott, a former dual premiership player and World War II fighter ace killed in 1943.

As you can see, I big selection of extremely honorable players.

Thank-you.

What else would you expect?

I'd like to say Jones will win it, but i think Jmac will just pip him at the post. Jones' development this year has been one of few highlights, so if he can top it off with a B&F it would be fantastic. White will come third, but i don't he's a great year. Played all the games, but for a ruckman he's been serviceable this year.

It should be given to the members that showed up. :angry:

Macca wasnt good enough this year. his disposal just let him down.

Jones is getting there but his decision making let him down.

and they were the best...

1. NATHAN JONES

2. Brad Green

3. James McDonald

4. Daniel Bell

5. Colin Sylvia

6. Jeff White

I will be ecstatic if Daniel Bell gets top 5.

The more I think about it the more it looks like:

1. Nathan Jones

2. James McDonald

3. Brad Green

4. Jeff White

5. Brown/someone else

Nathen Jones stood out to me whenever we played, and got 3rd in the Nab rising star which backs up that he had a good season.

Very consistant, and that is all it will take to win it this year.

Colin Sylvia wont even finish in the Top 10, come on be realistic!

For mine: 1)Jones 2) Junior 3)White 4)Green 5)Brown

Brown Dog to take out best clubman one more time

Newton to get Most Improved

Petterd to get Best First Year Player

To quote myself, I at least got Most Improved and Best First Year Player right.

And YM I should've had that bet with you.

Bate and Davey the big surprise packets out of this years count for mine...

Well done to Junior on back-to-back Blueys...

JMAC by a country mile look at his tackle stats compared to everyone else

I couldn't have predicted a more accurate outcome

It should be given to the members that showed up. :angry:

Macca wasnt good enough this year. his disposal just let him down.

Jones is getting there but his decision making let him down.

and they were the best...

Best-and-fairest votes

256 James McDonald

190 Nathan Jones

179 Matthew Bate

170 Brad Green

168 Aaron Davey

167 Cameron Bruce

157 Jeff White

131 Brock McLean

130 Nathan Brown, Russell Robertson

1 - Jmac

2 - Jones

3 - White

Not bad if i do say so myself, cept for whitey of course

Well done Jnr, Jones and Bates.

Bates form fell off the second half of the season; I am looking forward to a bigger year next year.