Guess I'll kick this off again

6 - Zanker

5 - McNamara

4 - Hore

3 - Pearce

2 - Harris

1 - Fitzsimon

Pisano gets a special mention. Easily her best game. Hopefully she can build on that and become the dangerous small forward we need.

6 - Zanker

5 - McNamara

4 - Pearce

3 - Hore

2 - Fitzsimon

1 - Harris

Shout outs to Gillard and Goldrick for their returns.

6 McNamara

5 Zanker

4 Hore

3 Hanks

2 Chaplin

1 Harris

6 McNamara. She has to be happy with her 50th game. Was good all game

5 Zanker. 5 goals, bullied har opponents

4 Chaplin. Consistently 2nd cleanest with the ball after Hanks. Love the move of putting her in the middle. Need two of her so one can play down back as well. 2nd most metres gained today after

3 Harris. So much more versatile these days. Most metres gained, 2 goals, 4 marks and second most hit outs. Popped up all over the ground. Love it

2 Taylor (Saraid). I assume we all saw the break two tackles, handball, hand ball receive, kick to leading forward play. As BDA said she is our most improved player

1 Hanks. Because I’ll never not vote for her

Apologies to Pearce, Hore, Fitzsimmons and Heath

Congrats to Gillard and Goldie on their first game back. Both did better than I thought that would. Probably congrats to the rehab team there too.

Best game from Pisano

Zanker could be the Plugger of the league

She is a unit

She should dominate for years and with Harris and Banno. no one can stop that. We just need more kids and backs

6 votes to all the vote givers...I'm terrible at it so refrain but they all look around the mark to me.

Zanker

McNamara

Chaplin

Harris

Taylor

Wotherspoon

Really good game from Pisano.

6. Eden Zanker

5. Elizabeth McNamara

4. Tyla Hanks

3. Kate Hore

2. Tayla Harris

1. Megan Fitzsimon

Progressive voting after 6 rounds

82. Tyla Hanks

73. Kate Hore 

41. Maeve Chaplin 

40. Elizabeth McNamara 

36. Tayla Harris

24. Eden Zanker 

20. Megan Fitzsimon

15. Shelley Heath Olivia Purcell

14. Paxy Paxman

4. Lauren Pearce Saraid Taylor

2. Maggie Mahony Ryleigh Wotherspoon

1. Alyssa Bannan Gabrielle Colvin Laela Ebert Molly O’Hehir

COACHES VOTES

Melbourne v West Coast

10 Eden Zanker MELB
6 Eliza McNamara MELB
6 Tyla Hanks MELB
3 Charlotte Thomas WCE
3 Kate Hore MELB
1 Tayla Harris MELB
1 Ella Roberts WCE

On 22/09/2025 at 00:33, rjay said:

6 votes to all the vote givers...I'm terrible at it so refrain but they all look around the mark to me.

You can't be terrible at it.

Everyone values individual performances differently.

Your opinion might be different, but no less valid.