57 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Is there a rule saying we have to kick it to our captain at all costs??

No just putting what I was told by interested parties, any comment on the second bit or is it fact getting in the way of hyperbole again?

Edited August 16, 20187 yr by Satyriconhome

7 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

No just putting what I was told by interested parties, any comment on the second bit or is it fact getting in the way of hyperbole again?

He wasn’t in my top 3 for votes Saty. If you want to only look at stats that support your argument, JKH gained 128m with those 14 disposals which barely rated as average (9m per disposal). You would hope he’d be effective moving the ball 9m forward.

0 1% acts in 4 quarters of footy.

My preference would be Kent over JKH, that’s all.

20 minutes ago, small but forward said:

He wasn’t in my top 3 for votes Saty. If you want to only look at stats that support your argument, JKH gained 128m with those 14 disposals which barely rated as average (9m per disposal). You would hope he’d be effective moving the ball 9m forward.

0 1% acts in 4 quarters of footy.

My preference would be Kent over JKH, that’s all.

He is ineffective. Has no presence, the footy is always a hot potato. Tackles weell, but doesn't like contact. Lacks composure. Shouldn't be in the side.

Just now, samcantstandya said:

He is ineffective. Has no presence, the footy is always a hot potato. Tackles weell, but doesn't like contact. Lacks composure. Shouldn't be in the side.

I was talking about Kennedy- Harris

1 hour ago, samcantstandya said:

I was talking about Kennedy- Harris

Glad you cleared that up. I thought you were talking about Saty.

2 hours ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Glad you cleared that up. I thought you were talking about Saty.

I am more than effective, don't pander to the group think malaise that infects this board

6 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

I am more than effective, don't pander to the group think malaise that infects this board

Just the company line...

12 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

No just putting what I was told by interested parties, any comment on the second bit or is it fact getting in the way of hyperbole again?

Do you ever have your own thoughts?  Or are they dictated by others?  You don't like group think, yet you go with the group think at the club all the time.  Interesting.

And for the record, JKH shouldn't be kicking it to the captain if he's under pressure.  He should be doing the team thing and taking the best option presented to him.  Jones wasn't the best option, captain or not.

In : Hibberd , Melk, Weiderman, Kent

Out: Hunt ,Hogan, Pedo ,GARLETT

We have to play the extra tall because WC play two rucks.

 

50 minutes ago, shorty said:

In : Hibberd , Melk, Weiderman, Kent

Out: Hunt ,Hogan, Pedo ,GARLETT

We have to play the extra tall because WC play two rucks.

 

What extra tall? You have taken out 2 - Hogan & Pedo and put in one - Weid

55 minutes ago, ManDee said:

What extra tall? You have taken out 2 - Hogan & Pedo and put in one - Weid

Yeah you're right, I meant Spargo and typed Pedo

2 minutes ago, shorty said:

Yeah you're right, I meant Spargo and typed Pedo

OK, take out one put one in, no extra talls.

4 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

Do you ever have your own thoughts?  Or are they dictated by others?  You don't like group think, yet you go with the group think at the club all the time.  Interesting.

And for the record, JKH shouldn't be kicking it to the captain if he's under pressure.  He should be doing the team thing and taking the best option presented to him.  Jones wasn't the best option, captain or not.

The interested parties were the players involved

I have my own thought all the time, post them on here,  of course to be called a liar sometimes, isn't that right my Keyboard hero, never got an answer to my question last time

 

23 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

The interested parties were the players involved

I have my own thought all the time, post them on here,  of course to be called a liar sometimes, isn't that right my Keyboard hero, never got an answer to my question last time

 

Your own thoughts? You just post what the players or coaches supposedly tell you. That's not your own thought, that's just regurgitating info from someone else. 

7 hours ago, shorty said:

In : Hibberd , Melk, Weiderman, Kent

Out: Hunt ,Hogan, Pedo ,GARLETT

We have to play the extra tall because WC play two rucks.

 

U left out JKH for Hannah otherwise u called it right.