2018 Contracts and List Details

[Lucifers Hero 39,832]

Updates for Delistings, Reitrees, Trades and 'B' Rookies.

We now have 7 senior + 1 'A' Rookie vacancy. 

My guess is we will use pick #104 and maybe #86 to upgrade Keilty and/or T Smith as both have been rumoured to have contracts in the offering.  Nothing to lose using those very late picks for them.

That would leave 4 live draft picks with at least 5 senior list and 3 'A' Rookie list vacanies. 

Vand rumoured to have a contract soon to be announced.  This leaves JKH and Dion.  Given the changes already there is a very good chance they will have new contracts.  JKH has done enough to warrant one and Dion has done a fair bit of work in defence with Jetta so their might be role there going forward.  Worth a one year contract to find out.

After that are no more 2018 OOC to be decided.  That leaves contracted player' futures: namely, Tyson, Garlett, Hogan. 

Still lots of water to go under this bridge!!

Edited September 26, 2018 by Lucifer's Hero

[Dee-licious 1,951]

Thanks @Lucifer's Hero - love your work.  

To put this all in perspective: 

2019 - 7 changes (thus far, not including Kent)
2018 - 8 changes 
2017 - 8 changes 
2016 - 9 changes 
2015 - 11 changes
2014 - 11 changes

It seems like a lot of changes considering that we made a prelim (Collingwood had 8 changes this year). We could legitimately be looking at 10 changes to our list which if you told me that at the start of the year (or 8 weeks ago) I would have laughed. 

[Lucifers Hero 39,832]

2 hours ago, Dee-licious said:

Thanks @Lucifer's Hero - love your work.  

To put this all in perspective: 

2019 - 7 changes (thus far, not including Kent)
2018 - 8 changes 
2017 - 8 changes 
2016 - 9 changes 
2015 - 11 changes
2014 - 11 changes

It seems like a lot of changes considering that we made a prelim (Collingwood had 8 changes this year). We could legitimately be looking at 10 changes to our list which if you told me that at the start of the year (or 8 weeks ago) I would have laughed. 

Thank you.

Yep, it has taken 5 years to remove all players who for whatever reason didn't make the grade in the Roos/Goodwin era, some of whom were mature age players that came to fill list gaps and have since gone.  5 years - not very long really with a lot of hard-ache decisions along the way.

The only players pre 2014 are Jones, Jetta, McDonald, Viney and Hogan (??).  An unbelievable turnaround.

The fab thing is, of the senior players OOC in 2019 everyone of them would be a starting 22 at an AFL club if not with mfc.  That means we will have few to delist next year and more than likely will be trades (this year or next). 

So not only have we totally rebuilt our list we have also positioned ourselves to get good value draft picks in for the players we lose.

Edited September 26, 2018 by Lucifer's Hero

[Dee-licious 1,951]

11 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

The fab thing is, of the senior players OOC in 2019 everyone of them would be a starting 22 at an AFL club if not with mfc.  That means we will have few to delist next year and more than likely will be trades (this year or next). 

So not only have we totally rebuilt our list we have also positioned ourselves to get good value draft picks in for the players we lose.

This has made me feel a lot better than where I was when I was posting. I was lamenting the fact that we are again loosing players from our list. You are right that the 2019 OOC are really best 22 either at the MFC or other top 8 clubs. Baker, Wagner, Maynard are the only ones there that I'd question might not break Geelong's starting 22, but I'm looking forward to seeing what Baker can do. My worry is experienced depth, which is why I dont want to loose guys like Tyson and JKH. They are good players who will offer more next year than pick 45. 

Building on this, last year we lost Garland and Watts who were in our best 22. The others were Hulett (0 games), Kennedy (bust trade), Lumumba (well Clark didnt do anything either), Spencer (great back up), Trengove (sad but glad he got a go with Port), and White (didn't loose anything here as he came to Casey anyway). 

This year we have lost Vince to retirement which is odd for us as we haven't had many who have lasted to retirement lately, Balic which was sad for the boy but we never had him in MFC colours and most thought depth anyway. King and Flip were basically out due to their in and out from Casey by mid way through this year and our preference not to play them in the ruck. McKenna was a speculative pick that none of us really put hope in, Bugg was good for us during transition and I hope he gets a gig somewhere else, but no one had him best 22 at the start of the year, and Pederson has again been a great servant during transition but he would just be back up again next year. 

Now it comes down to players we don't really want to loose. I know things happen during the year, but I dont know where I am de-listing three from next year's OOC. 

[red and blue forever 1,031]

10 minutes ago, Dee-licious said:

This has made me feel a lot better than where I was when I was posting. I was lamenting the fact that we are again loosing players from our list. You are right that the 2019 OOC are really best 22 either at the MFC or other top 8 clubs. Baker, Wagner, Maynard are the only ones there that I'd question might not break Geelong's starting 22, but I'm looking forward to seeing what Baker can do. My worry is experienced depth, which is why I dont want to loose guys like Tyson and JKH. They are good players who will offer more next year than pick 45. 

Building on this, last year we lost Garland and Watts who were in our best 22. The others were Hulett (0 games), Kennedy (bust trade), Lumumba (well Clark didnt do anything either), Spencer (great back up), Trengove (sad but glad he got a go with Port), and White (didn't loose anything here as he came to Casey anyway). 

This year we have lost Vince to retirement which is odd for us as we haven't had many who have lasted to retirement lately, Balic which was sad for the boy but we never had him in MFC colours and most thought depth anyway. King and Flip were basically out due to their in and out from Casey by mid way through this year and our preference not to play them in the ruck. McKenna was a speculative pick that none of us really put hope in, Bugg was good for us during transition and I hope he gets a gig somewhere else, but no one had him best 22 at the start of the year, and Pederson has again been a great servant during transition but he would just be back up again next year. 

Now it comes down to players we don't really want to loose. I know things happen during the year, but I dont know where I am de-listing three from next year's OOC. 

it is getting harder, a great thing indeed, but there are still some who would be surplus to requirements,

 

Wagner for One is obvious to cull ,

I would think stretch would close to that too

Last year of Lewis...  and that is three players.

 

If D.Johnstone  and JKH ges contract extensions they will porbably be only one year, and will need to show something good to get another...

 

[red and blue forever 1,031]

It is a good sign out delistings are getting stronger and the selection table are having more headaches

 

Out 2018	Out 2017	Out 2016	Out 2015	OUT 2014	Out 2013	OUT. 2012
H.Balic	J.Spencer	J.Grimes	D.Cross	S.Blease	T.Couch	J.Gysberts. - North
B.Vince	J.Trengove	D.Terlich	M.Jamar	M.Clisby	A.Davey	S.Martin. - Lions
C.Pederson	M.White	M.Jones	R.Bail	J.Strauss	T.Davis	B.Moloney. - Lions
T.Bugg	L.Hulett	L.Dunn - Pies	J.Howe - Pies	J.Frawley - Hawks	T.Gilles	C.Morton. - Eagles
L.Filipovic	B.Kennedy	V.Michie (r)	J.Mckenzie	M.Clarke - cats	J.Macdonald	J.Rivers. - Geelong
M.King	J.Watts	M.Dawes	J.Fitzpatrick - Hawks	D.Nicholson	J.Magner	R.Petterd. - Tigers
P.McKenna	C.Garland	B.Newton	J.Toumpas - Port	S.Byrnes	D.Rodan	J.Bennell. - Eagles
D.Kent??		Max King (r)	A.Riley	A.Georgiou®	J.Sellar	M.Bate
		H.Lumumbia		D.Barry	C.Sylvia - Freo	L.Cook
				M.Evans	T.Taggert	B.Green
				L.Tapscot	J.Tynan	L.Jurrah
						K.Lawrence
						J.Sheahan
						L.Williams

[Mr Steve 3,820]

19 minutes ago, red and blue forever said:

it is getting harder, a great thing indeed, but there are still some who would be surplus to requirements,

 

Wagner for One is obvious to cull ,

I would think stretch would close to that too

Last year of Lewis...  and that is three players.

 

If D.Johnstone  and JKH ges contract extensions they will porbably be only one year, and will need to show something good to get another...

 

Stretch!!! You have too be kidding. Billy if fit will be every game next year. 

[Dee-licious 1,951]

There is an interesting article on AFL.com.au that talks about WCE and Collingwood list builds for the GF. 

I wanted to see how our 22 on the past weekend matches up. In terms of top end talent, they are actually very similar. All 3 clubs have drafted 5-7 top end and then added a heap of top end through trades. This is going to be something moving forward that I'm interested in where we go. You can add Lever and Hogan to the list of first rounders and Stretch to the second rounders on top of 3 guys in Lewis, Melksham, and Tyson who are top 10 picks in their own right. There is a lot of top end talent in here moving forward, even though we like to talk about our steals with Gawn, McDonalds, Vanders etc.

First Round Picks (WCE 7; Coll 5; Melb 6) 
Petracca (Pick 2)
Brayshaw (3)
Oliver (4)
Salem (9)
Weideman (9)
Jones (12)

Second Round Picks (WCE 3; Coll 2; Melb 3)
Viney (26 but first round bid)
Spago (29)
Neal-Bullen (40)

Third Round Picks (WCE 5; Coll 0; Melb 4)
Gawn (34)
Hannan (46)
T. McDonald (53)
O. McDonald (53)

Fourth Round / rookie (WCE 1; Coll 6; Melb 4)
Jetta (51)
Harmes (2 in rookie draft)
Vandenberg (2 in rookie draft)
Smith (Category B)

Trade / Free Agency (WCE 6; Coll 9; Melb 5)
Tyson (originally pick 3)
Lewis (originally pick 7)
Melksham (originally pick 10)
Frost (53)
Hibberd (pick 4 rookie draft)

[Turner 1,514]

imo the list changes remaining this year is just the Kent trade and if anyone wants JKH he goes for a third rounder or even earlier than our 4th.

then next year seems to be pretty obvious too with Garlett appearing to lose his passion for it especially in the VFLGF looked very absent, Lewis raps up potentially losing his spot mid year to a Stretch/Maynard/Hunt off the flank/through the middle with Jones shifted back and Wagner +/- Keilty, Johnstone if they dont come on and JKH if he's still around getting the chop too. Baker's outside pace makes him necessary to keep trying for at least an extra year on what he's got now

[WERRIDEE 5,479]

On ‎9‎/‎26‎/‎2018 at 1:46 PM, red and blue forever said:

It is a good sign out delistings are getting stronger and the selection table are having more headaches

 

 

Out 2018	Out 2017	Out 2016	Out 2015	OUT 2014	Out 2013	OUT. 2012
H.Balic	J.Spencer	J.Grimes	D.Cross	S.Blease	T.Couch	J.Gysberts. - North
B.Vince	J.Trengove	D.Terlich	M.Jamar	M.Clisby	A.Davey	S.Martin. - Lions
C.Pederson	M.White	M.Jones	R.Bail	J.Strauss	T.Davis	B.Moloney. - Lions
T.Bugg	L.Hulett	L.Dunn - Pies	J.Howe - Pies	J.Frawley - Hawks	T.Gilles	C.Morton. - Eagles
L.Filipovic	B.Kennedy	V.Michie (r)	J.Mckenzie	M.Clarke - cats	J.Macdonald	J.Rivers. - Geelong
M.King	J.Watts	M.Dawes	J.Fitzpatrick - Hawks	D.Nicholson	J.Magner	R.Petterd. - Tigers
P.McKenna	C.Garland	B.Newton	J.Toumpas - Port	S.Byrnes	D.Rodan	J.Bennell. - Eagles
D.Kent??		Max King (r)	A.Riley	A.Georgiou®	J.Sellar	M.Bate
		H.Lumumbia		D.Barry	C.Sylvia - Freo	L.Cook
				M.Evans	T.Taggert	B.Green
				L.Tapscot	J.Tynan	L.Jurrah
						K.Lawrence
						J.Sheahan
						L.Williams

You might as well add Vanders and Hoges to that list

[Turner 1,514]

AVB to 2021

[red and blue forever 1,031]

So, as far as I can see, Kent remains unsigned as well as the 2 rookies T.Smith and D.Kelity?? 

 

[djr 1,515]

Has the club re-signed Kennedy Harris?

[red and blue forever 1,031]

2 hours ago, djr said:

Has the club re-signed Kennedy Harris?

Yes, 1 year extension

 

Only Kelity remains unsigned as far as I know

[Delusional Dee 13]

6 spots left? 4 for the draft, 1 on a delisted free agent, 1 for T Smith and Keilty to stay a rookie.

[Red and Blue Flame 187]

I make it 7 spots left on primary list - may and KK brought it to 33. You're allowed 40 + 4 rookies.

picks 23,28,54,62,91 is 5....so 2 extra spots? one rookie position with maynard, smith and keilty currently rookies.

 

 

[Lucifers Hero 39,832]

State of play post trades.

 

May is on a 5 year contract and I have 3 year contracts for Preuss and Kolodjashnij but not sure if the latter are correct.  Advice to confirm contract length would be appreciated.

Given our first pick before the draft (post comp picks) was #36 to now have #23 and #28 and rebalance our team is a terrific result.

Overall List:

Current list size = 33.  Minimum list size =  38.  Maximum list size:  40 (plus Rookies)

To reach the minimum of 38 we need to add at least 5 players.  Hard to see us using picks #91 or #105 so would have to assume that either/both Keilty and T. Smith get promoted to senior list or we recruit a delisted player or two.

Also, Mahoney mentioned that while happy with our draft holding it may change before the draft.  Watch this space!

Edited October 21, 2022 by Lucifers Hero

[xarronn 380]

The AFL website is reporting that Melbourne have no unsigned players left and "rookie-listed Declan Keilty the last to sign on".

Doesn't say whether Smith and Keilty re-signed as Rookies or on the main list.

[Big Kev 369]

On 10/19/2018 at 6:17 AM, Lucifer's Hero said:

State of play post trades.

May is on a 5 year contract and I have 3 year contracts for Preuss and Kolodjashnij but not sure if the latter are correct.  Advice to confirm contract length would be appreciated.

Given our first pick before the draft (post comp picks) was #36 to now have #23 and #28 and rebalance our team is a terrific result.

Overall List:

Current list size = 33.  Minimum list size =  38.  Maximum list size:  40 (plus Rookies)

To reach the minimum of 38 we need to add at least 5 players.  Hard to see us using picks #91 or #105 so would have to assume that either/both Keilty and T. Smith get promoted to senior list or we recruit a delisted player or two.

Also, Mahoney mentioned that while happy with our draft holding it may change before the draft.  Watch this space!

Not sure about Kade, but Preuss signed on for 3 years -

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2018-10-12/preuss-joins-melbourne-in-trade-deal

MELBOURNE has secured ruckman Braydon Preuss in a trade that will see the departure of midfielder Dom Tyson to North Melbourne.

Agreeing to terms on Friday morning, Preuss will wear the red and blue until at least the end of 2021, while the Demons also receive pick No.62 of the NAB AFL Draft in the deal.

[yelworcs 4]

Lucifer’s Hero - just wanted to say thanks for this thread - it was driving me nuts trying to work out the list details. With your help I can sleep at last ?!

[deanox 9,927]

With Hogan being traded out,  I'd like to see us get an extension on Weid early,  preferably over summer. 

He may wish to hold out, as good form next year will really pump his market value.

[Turner 1,514]

@Lucifer's Hero you have got the draft picks wrong in your most recent contracts table we dont have 36 we have a pick 54

[Lucifers Hero 39,832]

 

Thank your to posters for feedback and corrections.   

Changes were fix draft pick error - we have #54 but not #36. 

Also updated for T.Smith and Keilty being re-contracted as 'A' Rookies for 2019.

So we need to fill a minimum of 5 (maximum of 7) list spots and with 4 effective draft picks we would be looking at one to three Restricted Free Agents.

Edited October 21, 2022 by Lucifers Hero

[deanox 9,927]

It still wouldn't surprise me to see some late pick trading, giving up picks next year in for this year.

Only 3-6 potential delistings or retirements next year:

Lewis, Baker, Garlett, Wagner, Stretch, Jones.

So we might not be planning to use as many picks in 2019. Our 2019 first pick for  WCE 2018 pick 20 and pick 61 would give us six picks in the first 62 this year. 

[Turner 1,514]

3 hours ago, deanox said:

It still wouldn't surprise me to see some late pick trading, giving up picks next year in for this year.

Only 3-6 potential delistings or retirements next year:

Lewis, Baker, Garlett, Wagner, Stretch, Jones.

So we might not be planning to use as many picks in 2019. Our 2019 first pick for  WCE 2018 pick 20 and pick 61 would give us six picks in the first 62 this year. 

Jones, Baker Stretch safe but add Maynard and JKH to the list imo