6. Salem

5. Garlett

4. Jetta

3. Jones

2. Oliver

1. TMac

 

Progressive voting has Clarrie in front -

34. Clayton Oliver
23. Nathan Jones
16. Christian Salem
11. Max Gawn
8. Jeff Garlett 
6. Jordan Lewis Dom Tyson Bernie Vince
4. Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta Tom McDonald 
2. Christian Petracca Jack Watts

6: Oliver

5: Salem

4: Garlett

3: Jones

2: Gawn

1: Watts

19 hours ago, Dee-licious said:

6: Salem (I dont know what it looked like on TV but wow he had an outstanding game. Imagine him and Kelly on a wing together). 

5: Oliver (Just dominated the first quarter and came back strongly in the last - also put a cheeky $2 on him for the brownlow) 

4: Jeffy (that tackle!) 

3: Jetta (so underrated. I wonder if he will at least be in the AA conversation)  

2: T-Mac (If Hurley, Rance, and McGoven dont take the possie, he will) 

1: Jones (when we needed our captain he came running. 

 

Homsar - live Weid looks really good. Right areas, competes well. Will be something. 

I was there live, and I agree he can look good. I was probably a bit harsh in my assessment. When he gets space to run and jump he is a good mark. Lovely kick too. Old style full forward. With a few years to build a tank and muscle, will be a serious player.

6 - Salem

5 - Oliver

4 - Jetta

3 - Garlett

2 - Jones

1 - T Mac

22 hours ago, jane02 said:

6. Garlett

5. Salem

4. Jetta

3. Oliver

2. Jones

1. Tyson

Perfect Jane02 in My HO.

I am glad you left JW out. 

The amount of dropped chest marks apart from the first that Garlett gave him, was appalling.

1 hour ago, homsar said:

I was there live, and I agree he can look good. I was probably a bit harsh in my assessment. When he gets space to run and jump he is a good mark. Lovely kick too. Old style full forward. With a few years to build a tank and muscle, will be a serious player.

I find it really interesting because of Hogan, Weiderman isnt really talked about by the outside world. While we might all think he is going to develop well, the outsiders talk about Danniher, McCartin, Schace, McKay for Carlton, etc but no love for Weid. If he tracks the way he is going (no improvement, just stagnate) for the rest of the year, he ends up with 33 goals and must be seriously competing for the Rising Star with that amount of goals. Might have the sort of development we wish Watts had - off the bright lights of Broadway and can develop in his own time with great players around him. 

6 - Salem

5 - Clarry

4 - Jeff

3 - Nev 

2 - Jones

1 -T Mac

 

Salem    6

Oliver     5

Jones     4

Watts      3

Lewis      2

Hogan    1

On 03/04/2017 at 4:56 PM, Barney Rubble said:

Perfect Jane02 in My HO.

I am glad you left JW out. 

The amount of dropped chest marks apart from the first that Garlett gave him, was appalling.

Have a look at the last quarter, JW was excellent: certainly worth a vote IMHO.

On 4/3/2017 at 4:56 PM, Barney Rubble said:

Perfect Jane02 in My HO.

I am glad you left JW out. 

The amount of dropped chest marks apart from the first that Garlett gave him, was appalling.

2 - he dropped 2. ( but there were 8 other marks he did take). I have no problem with him being left out of the votes purely based on there being better players on the day but he was very influential in the last quarter when the game had to be won.

I thought Hogan provided a contest all day but he also dropped a lot of marks that he got clean hands to.