Our tall back stocks are pretty good for once

Frawley

Sellar

Mcdonald

Gillies

Davis

Pederson

Garland

Watts

Except that four of the above-named either haven't played a game or are not regulars in the starting 22.

James Sellar was good down back last year and has been good there this year. In fact he's looked very much at home there whenever he has been. Tom McDonald on the other hand looks more like a natural forward. At his best last year he was instinctive and sought the ball out. He played there as a junior, and was drafted on what he showed as a forward. I don't understand why he hasn't been tried up front, unless its part of a longer term career plan, a la David Neitz.

Except that four of the above-named either haven't played a game or are not regulars in the starting 22.

Better to have them and not need them then need them and not have them. although i think Aaron davey would even be a better player than Gillies based on what i have seen.

Sellar tries hard but his hands are shocking. Definitely not a forward. As Django said, he's a pretty handy depth player.

Better to have them and not need them then need them and not have them. although i think Aaron davey would even be a better player than Gillies based on what i have seen.

I agree with that point (I assume you mean Davis, not Davey).

Good depth player only.

Is there a matchup for him this week? I didn't watch the Freo game, so I am not sure who they played forward. But they seem to get a lot of goals through Mayne/Ballantyne/Walters. Frawley may get Mayne, or though he works pretty hard up the gorund. Then Garland may get Ballantyne, and Nicho on Walters.

Nicho on Walters ? We are finished

Nicho on Walters ? We are finished

Rest easy Walters is out injured.

Looks better down back, but do freo have a matchup for him?

In my opinion is one of the worst players to ever get a game for Melbourne.

Rivals Michael Newton

Totally agree with you, one of the worst players I have seen play for the Melbourne Football Club.