I love Magner but yet to see a weapon other than hunger. I hope it works for him but need to see what he can offer once other teams respect him

I assume by the comment above you must face the wrong way when watching the footy not to 'see'....apart from the great job he did on Scarlett in the 2nd half on Saurday

And Jetta NO way.....have you an explanation as to why

wait til you see what a disappointment jack viney turns out to be !

I presume that you are speaking tongue in cheek, or are you Bluey from Demonology in disguise?

There will be 8-10 players in our 2015 best team that aren't listed in the OP's offering. At least half of them aren't yet on our list.

Agree with Ben Hur, No way Jetta, Bennell or Batram are in our best 22 in 2015. If they are we must be playing in the VFL

Who should be there: Frawley, Trengove, Clark, Grimes, Garland, Howe.

Who could be there: Viney

The rest is up in the air IMO

I presume that you are speaking tongue in cheek, or are you Bluey from Demonology in disguise?

He almost will be a dissapointment given some of the pumping up he gets on this site. Seriously I am not interested in any players until they hit 20, that is when you know what you really have.

There will be 8-10 players in our 2015 best team that aren't listed in the OP's offering. At least half of them aren't yet on our list.

There will be 8-10 players in our 2015 best team that aren't listed in the OP's offering. At least half of them aren't yet on our list.

You just cant say that, 2015 is only 3 years away and there is no way that we will gain 8 - 10 players in that time that will put us where we want to be

I presume that you are speaking tongue in cheek, or are you Bluey from Demonology in disguise?

was just jokes.. my username should indicate that i'm a viney fan from way back - i even liked jay

That is assuming all of those players come on, and given the history of this club in success with draft picks and development perhaps our list in 2015 might look very different.

A lot of your 2015 side relies on draft picks coming on. Which we hope can happen as a midfield of Viney, Blease and Gysberts might prove good value providing the latter two come on. Gysberts was highly rated and showed a lot early before injury. Blease looks a little Cale for mine, but time will tell.

I wonder if the players realise they are playing for their future AFL careers. No side will touch them based on current performance and effort. I wouldnt be joking around myself.

Edited May 13, 201213 yr by Norm Smith's Curse

Or maybe it will take FIVE Jacks to break Norm Smith's curse??

Edited May 13, 201213 yr by Norm Smith's Curse

You just cant say that, 2015 is only 3 years away and there is no way that we will gain 8 - 10 players in that time that will put us where we want to be

Yeah we will, if we don't then we are going nowhere fast (we are now). I would expect us to have between 3 -5 players debut next season if we go with strong mids in the draft and I would also expect Taggert to debut at sometime this year and really step up in the next couple. With trades for Silvia and compensation for Moloney we could look for a Kennedy type around the 23 - 24yo so at the bottom end that's 5 not on the list and not including Viney.