Tom Scully

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Cameron effectively said we are financially able to, and have room under the cap to match the offer, but it doesn't allow the club to reward the other players as they progress through the ranks.

He wasn't keen to talk about compensation should we lose him but said there was a system in place and he was part of the team that put it together.

He also said that Tom Scully is a great kid and doesn't like all the things that are gong on and being said.

[angrydee 842]

and it's infectious.

[Kento80 83]

The Carbon tax and the T Scully sagas, sick of it all!!Certainly I would like him to stay, but if several mill are on offer to him, good luck to him I say.I do think that the hype over him has become overwhelming and personally speaking I doubt he will be as good as they say he will.His myth has taken on Messiah like status, I certainly don't want Melbourne to bust the bank over him at the expense of our other LOYAL young players I believe him to be an early developer with dodgy knees!!We don't want to be in another debt demolition, while filling his pockets.For what its worth GWS have taken over from my long time hatred of the Bombers to be my number one object of loathing!!He will suffer there with his millions and he won't get his fulfilment on the footy field playing in front of a small crowd who has hasn't a clue whats going on and don't really care!!

I agree with you here Scullitor, but there is nothing that has happened so far to suspect that Tom is not loyal, so I don't understand why people keep mentioning other "loyal" players. Tom has had all of this thrust upon him. He didn't ask for it, but is doing his best to deal with it. Question his loyalty IF he decides to go, but until then, he is just as loyal as any other player at the club. Would we be questioning the loyalty of Trenners if he was in the same position Tom is in??

Thanks guys. I didn't see the other thread. Long day, I'm afraid.

Enjoy that website Rojik, I love it. And if you have an iPhone, you can even get it as an app and listen from your phone.

[demonique 314]

I agree with you here Scullitor, but there is nothing that has happened so far to suspect that Tom is not loyal, so I don't understand why people keep mentioning other "loyal" players. Tom has had all of this thrust upon him. He didn't ask for it, but is doing his best to deal with it. Question his loyalty IF he decides to go, but until then, he is just as loyal as any other player at the club. Would we be questioning the loyalty of Trenners if he was in the same position Tom is in??

Enjoy that website Rojik, I love it. And if you have an iPhone, you can even get it as an app and listen from your phone.

Yes point taken Kento the LOYAL thing was just a bit of frustration creeping in I'm afraid. : ( I am 50/ 50 about the whole sorry saga and that I really don't know what to believe! with all the dis -information flying about!

[Kento80 83]

Fair enough I guess. Just believe the kid, it really does make me feel much more at ease. And the article today is the only one with real quotes from real people, which makes the whole sorry saga even easier again. The other thing that helped me firm in my positive views of Tom has been Wolfmothers comments in this thread, as he seems to be the only person on here who actually knows Tom and talks to him about it.

[Adzman 2,154]

I would play footy in a pink dress and a pair of stilettos for 1 million a year.........Tom just has to show up.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

I would play footy in a pink dress and a pair of stilettos for 1 million a year.........Tom just has to show up.

No no no..you mis understood your contract. They were paying you a million a year NOT to wear a pink dress and stilettos. I repeat NOT.

[Tony Tea 2,806]

Any chance the media will stop referring to the GWS "multi million dollar" offer, while completely ignoring Melbourne's own multi million dollar offer.

[Tony Tea 2,806]

If you are optimistic about Tom staying, you better not read this tweet stream.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

If you are optimistic about Tom staying, you better not read this tweet stream.

Oh FFS.

OK it's official, some guy heard from his mate that Lynch nodded his head. It's all over.

[QueenC 74]

Any chance the media will stop referring to the GWS "multi million dollar" offer, while completely ignoring Melbourne's own multi million dollar offer.

Nope......

[Kento80 83]

If you are optimistic about Tom staying, you better not read this tweet stream.

I'm not going to change my views based on Darrens twitter stream, but I know Darren and I don't think for a second that he would say all of that unless he was as certain as he could be that his source was on the money. He is a massive Dees fan, and a positive one at that, and I really can't see him wanting to fan the flames unless he had accepted that it is the case. This is not a good turn of events at all, but I am still gonna "believe in Tom" (sorry rpfc, wasn't trying to steal it)

[wonnabeeri 275]

I'm confident he will stay. Im just going to wait the 2 months or so until we get a proper announcement.

[Samsara 65]

Those tweet streams are ridiculous. Scully to leave Melbourne for GWS because Melbourne aren't professional enough - seriously? Every club has drinking problems among the ranks, and a new franchise full of 18 year olds on ridiculous money is going to be the worst of the lot.

Edited July 12, 2011 by Samsara

[wonnabeeri 275]

OK it's official, some guy heard from his mate that Lynch nodded his head. It's all over.

And the fact that this exchange occurred to people IN THE MEDIA means its probably a load of horseshite. As if sheahan or one of the other wouldnt have this on the back page of the little paper if this had actually happened.

[QueenC 74]

Those tweet streams are ridiculous. Scully to leave Melbourne for GWS because Melbourne aren't professional enough - seriously? Every club has drinking problems among the ranks, and a new franchise full of 18 year olds on ridiculous money is going to be the worst of the lot.

Especially with The Mean Fiddler just around the corner !!!

[Jaded No More 68,867]

And the fact that this exchange occurred to people IN THE MEDIA means its probably a load of horseshite. As if sheahan or one of the other wouldnt have this on the back page of the little paper if this had actually happened.

Exactly.

They report sh!t that never happens, let alone stuff that does happen.

I'm sure Lynch said he went too far with his comments, because it put a serious dent in GWS' move, but FFS why would he then turn around off air and declare that he's going, when at the time no offers were made, nothing was signed and nothing was even decided (and it still hasn't).

Besides, just because Lynch/Schwartz/Sheehan believe that Scully should go, doesn't mean he will. I think he'll make a life changing decision based on his opinion and the opinion of his family, and not take life advice from his accountant, media commentators or indeed his manager who works on commission. Laughable.

Can we at least give this kid some credit? He isn't some homeless bozo we picked up off the streets.

[Mac7 309]

Those tweet streams are ridiculous. Scully to leave Melbourne for GWS because Melbourne aren't professional enough - seriously?

Agree.

Jimmy not professional? Cam not professional? Todd not professional? Leadership group not professional? AAMI Park not professional? MCC not professional? Yep sure.

[Guest The Tweed Pig]

If you are optimistic about Tom staying, you better not read this tweet stream.

I read the tweets and it doesn't make sense. Firstly, Lynch is too professional to tell anyone, even off camera and secondly, why didn't Gerard then probe him following this shake of the head? Ever heard of Chinese whispers? It's amazing how a shrug can turn into a shake of the head. Especially when the watcher may already have their own preconceived ideas.

It's a widely held belief in media circles that Scully is gone, so it's not surprising that Darren's mate has heard the same stuff. When everyone is saying the same thing it becomes more compelling - even if it isn't true.

I have absolutely no reason to believe that Scully is a liar and that this isn't one big charade that's thriving on its own momentum.

EDIT: Lynch would have said he went "too far" because he shouldn't have given any sense of where things are at. Do you know why? He doesn't know. So making any assertion one way or another, no matter how slight, wasn't professional.

Edited July 12, 2011 by The Tweed Pig

[Captain Jack Jordan 32]

tweet streams are the new news .

I work for Murdoch so I'll just get you a transcript of a tapped conversation between TS and Alistair Lynch.

AL So can you sign up in August Tom?

TS Maybe after September

AL Sheeds wants...

TS F#@$ Sheeds. I dont work for Sheeds!

AL We worked hard on this deal Tommy

TS Don't call Me Tommy ,Dont call me at all .

AL I told you I'm a demon for life mate .Talk to Sheeds and tell him to call me in 5 years .When he'll be in a lunatic asylum .

Care of FOX media .

[Clanger King 9]

Sounds like his management team is unprofessional.... If they are going round saying crap like that off camera... Dont believe it.

[heartbeatstrue 57]

I would play footy in a pink dress and a pair of stilettos for 1 million a year.........Tom just has to show up.

I would play footy in the centre for Melbourne every week for absolutely free, if I was good enough and they wanted me there. Any payment would be an amazing bonus. The thought of doing it every week for GWS just makes me feel all the pain and effort. They would have to pay me a mill to even consider. But then I'm not Tom and he's not me

[Mac7 309]

I would play footy in a pink dress and a pair of stilettos for 1 million a year.........Tom just has to show up.

Last time I saw Tom play footy in Pink he got 40 possessions....

[Guest 36DD]

Agree.

Jimmy not professional? Cam not professional? Todd not professional? Leadership group not professional? AAMI Park not professional? MCC not professional? Yep sure.

ummm

[Pata 16]

So many people and things pointing to the fact that he is going isn't a coincidence.

It's all very similar to the Ablett situation last year.

I am a big Dees fan but those who keep pushing things to the side and not believing them are either in denial or off their heads.

He is a midfielder who can be replaced. There will plenty of room in the cap for a free agent. I say target Buddy!