Carlton dilemma over Brock McLean's spot against Melbourne

[old dee 23,256]

I can back the McLean was dispensible argument with, well, reality.

Davey was very good last year.

Moloney is an elite clearance player.

Jones is having a very good season.

These are all facts.

Very good rpfc

I have a horrible feeling that this time next year your post will read the same but

Davey was very good in 2010

[QueenC 74]

get over maclean threads - left ages ago

I feel a little the same W04.....

He left the club, we did well out of the deal, and if he plays, he plays B) !!!

[Nasher 33,246]

Well said Striker. IMO he will prove to be a favoured son by the end of his career. That is unless those in the halls of power at MFC are equally as blind to a players qualities as some on here.

I just wish he'd lay a few more tackles. He laid 5 tackles a match for the first two (good numbers), since then he's averaged just a bit over 1 per match. This suggests to me that since the first couple of rounds he is not applying a sufficient level of pressure, despite having played pretty well otherwise. Compare this to Moloney who should be a similar style of player - laid close to 5 per match for the year. Even in the Hawthorn game where he was utterly garbage, Moloney managed 2 tackles (his minimum for the year); Jones couldn't manage a single one against West Coast and only got 1 for the Adelaide smashing.

For a guy who is (and always has been) built like a brick outhouse, this is a very poor output in terms of applying pressure on the opposition.

[Jaded No More 60,181]

I just wish he'd lay a few more tackles. He laid 5 tackles a match for the first two (good numbers), since then he's averaged just a bit over 1 per match. This suggests to me that since the first couple of rounds he is not applying a sufficient level of pressure, despite having played pretty well otherwise. Compare this to Moloney who should be a similar style of player - laid close to 5 per match for the year. Even in the Hawthorn game where he was utterly garbage, Moloney managed 2 tackles (his minimum for the year); Jones couldn't manage a single one against West Coast and only got 1 for the Adelaide smashing.

For a guy who is (and always has been) built like a brick outhouse, this is a very poor output in terms of applying pressure on the opposition.

You can probably work on getting more tackles, but ZERO clearances last week?! That's pretty bad.

[Nasher 33,246]

You can probably work on getting more tackles, but ZERO clearances last week?! That's pretty bad.

The two are probably closely linked considering the nature of a tackle and the nature of a clearance; both require a degree of "hard stuff".

Either way it suggests to me that we're not getting close to maximum value from Jones even though at face value he's playing pretty well, which may explain why opinions on him are polarised at the moment.

[Striker475 696]

I just wish he'd lay a few more tackles. He laid 5 tackles a match for the first two (good numbers), since then he's averaged just a bit over 1 per match. This suggests to me that since the first couple of rounds he is not applying a sufficient level of pressure, despite having played pretty well otherwise. Compare this to Moloney who should be a similar style of player - laid close to 5 per match for the year. Even in the Hawthorn game where he was utterly garbage, Moloney managed 2 tackles (his minimum for the year); Jones couldn't manage a single one against West Coast and only got 1 for the Adelaide smashing.

For a guy who is (and always has been) built like a brick outhouse, this is a very poor output in terms of applying pressure on the opposition.

He does has flaws in his game, but I love watching him blow through a pack. He's still improving, has improved every year, and is steadily becoming a genuinely good player.

[DemonWA 3,658]

I hate watching him try to "blow through a pack" and getting pinged holding the ball!! haha

Jones is spending more time on the wing which would probably be the reason for his reduced tackle and clearance count?

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Looks like it's been settled - Brock is IN.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/carlton-midfielder-brock-mclean-set-to-take-on-demons/story-e6frf9jf-1226063278792

[Deestroy All 14,262]

..and, back out.

Chuckle.

[diesel 420]

..and, back out.

Chuckle.

Could never accuse Brock of bruise free footy. Bit of severe ego bruising there I think.

[rhaz 342]

Our trade just keeps looking better and better. Serious possibility of getting delisted by Carlton at years end. Surely GWS would take a chance on him if he was delisted, but yeah... i heart Gysberts.

Edited June 2, 2011 by rhaz