Cause they are big and useless. He can't get a game ahead of Leigh Brown. NEXT

Filthy Collingwood piggies trying to offload their crap on us..

10 games in 3 seasons, with only 1 of them worth talking about.

Of Jurrahs 9 games in 1 season to date - at about the same age as Dawes - nearly all 9 were worth talking about.. Dawes doesnt even get close.

He was Taken at Pick 26 - Id hesitate to offer pick 34 for him

Keep pick 18 for Daw or Jetta

EDIT: No Nasher, he is not a pup - he's 100KGS and an adult

Edited October 2, 200916 yr by DemonDan...

This is a hard one. I have such little respect for Demonland posters re MFC players that it's a little difficult to respect their opinion on opposition players.

This is a hard one. I have such little respect for Demonland posters re MFC players that it's a little difficult to respect their opinion on opposition players.

I'm waiting for Freak to weigh in...

if we take majak daw at pic 18 ill throw punches lol

if we take majak daw at pic 18 ill throw punches lol

I thought you were a Daw fan?

Can't see it happening though.

I'm waiting for Freak to weigh in...

As always.

Is this what you do in the "real" world? Your first dates must be bloody boring!

With Dawes at FF, Watts at CHF and Jurrah roaming as the dangerous 3rd tall id be very very very happy to get Dawes.

Would rather pick 34 goes to them but I can handle pick 18 cause I rate him pretty highly.

So, let me get this straight.

Dawes; a late 2nd round pick who hasn't done anything in the 3 years he's been at Collingwood gets traded (in your eyes) to Melbourne (who are trying to cease mediocre football) for a solid pick, of 18 in the draft?

Pfft, please.

What do you base your "rating him pretty highly" on?

I've seen nothing & let's be honest people, it's not like the Collingwood FC has the most potent forward line.

If Rocca gets a game before him - WE DON'T NEED OR WANT HIM!

Surely it's a no brainer.

This is a hard one. I have such little respect for Demonland posters re MFC players that it's a little difficult to respect their opinion on opposition players.

No reason to lump everyone else in with me.

This is a hard one. I have such little respect for Demonland posters re MFC players that it's a little difficult to respect their opinion on opposition players.

You seriously have massive tickets on yourself. Why is your opion so dame important? and why do you think you have the right to pot every person on this sight? I have noticed that all you do is promote yourself and disrespect others. Who do you think you are? im guessing your a no body with a half desent vocabulary and nice computer. If you have nothing constructive to add then don't.

im guessing your a no body with a half desent vocabulary and nice computer.

Got it in one, [censored].

My opinion is about as worthwhile as everyone else's.

If Collingwood are desperate to get Fev, they will almost certainly need one of our picks to do so. Thus we have all the cards. Why not Anthony for pick 18? With Fev at Collingwood, Anthony becomes very expendable. Do demonlanders rate Anthony for pick 18? If not what collingwood player do you want (be realistic) for pick 18? We are in a strong position to drive a hard price.

I would prefer to keep pick 11 rather than trade pick 11, but we could use this pick for a young A grade player instead. Anyone we want from the scum?

Edited October 2, 200916 yr by Grand New Flag

So Collingwood think Jolly is only worth pick 14 but Dawes is worth pick 18.

I'd give pick 34 for him but definately not 18.

As always.

Is this what you do in the "real" world? Your first dates must be bloody boring!

Hey, I go to Freak for guidance...

Not sure about this. I rated him after he played his first few games up forward but Malthouse has played him down back and even on the flanks at times which doesn't suit a guy of his size.

I reckon he'd be worth a shot but would give up our 3rd rounder, not 2nd.

No thanks! Dawes is overrated!