Changes for Richmond Game

[Demons 32 235]

We are that bereft of a marking, goalkicking full forward that we should take the punt and play him if he's fit to play anyway. The Swans didn't mess around with Nic Malceski when he came back from his knee reco and he doesn't play in a fixed position at one end of the ground.

Agreed, watching the game I thought we could really use him.

Was speaking to a few mates from work this morning and the general feeling from these guys is that we need Newton.

[w00dy 146]

We are that bereft of a marking, goalkicking full forward that we should take the punt and play him if he's fit to play anyway. The Swans didn't mess around with Nic Malceski when he came back from his knee reco and he doesn't play in a fixed position at one end of the ground.

we are lacking a big body up forward as you say, but our forward line looked dangerous on the weekend, quite unpredictable... so do we need to rush him straight back in?

dunn presented well there in the last quarter and I think we should throw him back down forward for the entire game next week to give us another marking target... so no need to rush juice in for mine...

Valenti for Moloney

Frawley for Rivers

Johnson for Bell

Davey for Bode

I forgot about Chip Frawley. So I'd bring him in ahead of Carroll/Martin as I said in the first post. Which would give me the same changes as you with the addition of:

Whelan for Bartram

[The Cold Hard Truth 0]

Out:

B Moloney (inj.), J Rivers (inj.), C Bartram, D Bell, J Bode, L Dunn

In:

S Buckley, N Carroll, A Davey, J Frawley, C Johnson, M Whelan

B....Carroll.........Warnock......Whelan

HB..C Johnson....Garland........Buckley

C....Wheatley......Jones...........Bruce

HF...Bate............Miller............Davey

F.....Wonamarri...Sylvia..........Green

R.....White..........McLean.........McDonald

Int: P Johnson, Frawley, Morton, Yze

Emg: Bell, Valenti, Bartram

Possibly too many changes, but changes like Bell and Bartram are overdue.

Bartram was very tough and courageous against the Filth and Bell's strength is very important when he can enforce it, but both are hurting us too much with their disposal and decision making and need to get back to Sandy and work on it.

Bode and Dunn don't offer enough and C Johnson and Buckley deserve their chances.

Yze gets another chance only because with Green and Sylvia he can be a good medium foward capable of kicking 2-3 goals but he'll have to play some very good footy to not be an automatic ommission once Newton is ready.

Frawley is lucky, but has shown enough to be a great defender and needs patience and persistance for him to grow and develop into what he can become and the best way to do that is to keep giving him big tasks ala Garland.

[Rogue 585]

Whelan for Bell, Valenti for Moloney as straight swaps.

Having managed to raise is hand at the post match function means Aaron comes back into the side, at whose expense? Maybe Jace Bode - who had quite a few 1% yesterday so well done.

The replacement for Riv is a harder one, Carroll V Martin...experience V youth & versatility [you can also throw Martin forward and into the ruck].

Who makes way if CJ returns? A toss up between Bartam and Dunn perhaps...with overall team structure probably determining the outcome.

I agree with most of this, but to me it'd be Carroll v Frawley (rather than Martin).

[praha 11,236]

Johnson has been in the best at Sandy many times, but fails at AFL level. He is a top-tier VFL player and that's all. De-listed at years end.

[w00dy 146]

Johnson has been in the best at Sandy many times, but fails at AFL level. He is a top-tier VFL player and that's all. De-listed at years end.

But he's never had form like his form over the last month. And I think his game is much more suited to Dean Bailey's game plan. I believe once he gets his spot in the side, he won't look back, and will give us some much needed class on the half back line in amongst the likes of Bartram and Bell.

[brey9186 102]

Brad Green will not play as a permanent forward... people need to realise this!! This worked in 2000, but it isnt his game style any more, he might float forward for some goals, but is a wingman now, cleaning up the HB line

[DemonDave 1,089]

Tigers Team has been published. Jake King is a big out for them. A second family-matchup of the year also awaits Cale Morton as his brother Mitch is recalled....

RICHMOND v MELBOURNE

Richmond

B: Chris Newman, Luke McGuane, Graham Polak

HB: Jordan McMahon, Kelvin Moore, Daniel Jackson

C: Matthew Richardson, Shane Tuck, Matt White

HF: Mitch Morton, Jack Riewoldt, Richard Tambling

F: Adam Pattison, Nathan Brown, Trent Cotchin

Foll: Troy Simmonds, Brett Deledio, Nathan Foley

I/C (from): Dean Polo, Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls, Chris Hyde, Joel Bowden, Alex Rance, Jay Schulz,Shane Edwards

In: Riewoldt, Rance, Oakley-Nicholls, Hyde, Jackson, Polo, Morton

Out: Will Thursfield (hamstring), Jake King (hamstring), Greg Tivendale, Kayne Pettifer

[bjgc 0]

B: WHELAN, WARNOCK, BELL

HB: BARTRAM, GARLAND, WHEATLEY

C: DAVEY, MCLEAN, BRUCE

HF: BATE, MILLER, GREEN

F: SYLVIA, HOLLAND, WONEAMERI

FOLL: WHITE, JONES, MCDONALD

IC: YZE, MORTON, DUNN, P.JOHNSON

EMERG: C.JOHNSON, BODE, MARTIN

I don't want to see Carroll or Frawley they are hopeless.

Martin to CHB and Garland to FF if Holland is not fit.

[sylvinator 96]

I don't want to see Carroll or Frawley they are hopeless.

Frawley has been named and rightly so...this yr is about development and Frawley will only improve by playing senior football.

[barpen 0]

Melbourne

B: James McDonald, Colin Garland, Matthew Warnock

HB: Brad Green, Paul Wheatley, Cameron Bruce

C: Colin Sylvia, Brock McLean, Lynden Dunn

HF: Jace Bode, James Frawley, Clint Bartram

F: Paul Johnson, Brad Miller, Austin Wonaeamirri

Foll: Jeff White, Chris Johnson, Nathan Jones

I/C (from): Aaron Davey, Mark Jamar, Matthew Bate, Cale Morton, Matthew Whelan, Adem Yze, Nathan Carroll

In: Davey, Frawley, Jamar, C Johnson, Carroll, Whelan

Out: Jared Rivers (groin), Brent Moloney (shoulder), Daniel Bell

[Adzman 2,154]

Frawley in to play on RICHO!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

Who will Garland get this week? Nathan Brown? Very similar palyer to Didak, and very important to the Tigers.

Also, i wouldn't mind seeing Dunn play a negating role on Newman, where he can also stay in our F50, and maybe bag a couple of goals.

[titan_uranus 24,974]

Tigers Team has been published. Jake King is a big out for them. A second family-matchup of the year also awaits Cale Morton as his brother Mitch is recalled....

RICHMOND v MELBOURNE

Richmond

B: Chris Newman, Luke McGuane, Graham Polak

HB: Jordan McMahon, Kelvin Moore, Daniel Jackson

C: Matthew Richardson, Shane Tuck, Matt White

HF: Mitch Morton, Jack Riewoldt, Richard Tambling

F: Adam Pattison, Nathan Brown, Trent Cotchin

Foll: Troy Simmonds, Brett Deledio, Nathan Foley

I/C (from): Dean Polo, Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls, Chris Hyde, Joel Bowden, Alex Rance, Jay Schulz,Shane Edwards

In: Riewoldt, Rance, Oakley-Nicholls, Hyde, Jackson, Polo, Morton

Out: Will Thursfield (hamstring), Jake King (hamstring), Greg Tivendale, Kayne Pettifer

Good outs for us, they lose their full-back and some of their run. Rance was a first rounder last year, wasn't he? Is it his first game?

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Frawley in to play on RICHO!!!!!!!!!!!!

HA!

Warnock on Richo, or Garland on Richo if he pushes up the ground?

Garland on Brown is interesting, but I think if Whelan plays he'll get first crack.

[deestroy08 0]

HA!

Warnock on Richo, or Garland on Richo if he pushes up the ground?

Garland on Brown is interesting, but I think if Whelan plays he'll get first crack.

Whelan.. Brown.. crack.. not a good thought. I still have not recovered from seeing that incident.