Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
Thanks @adonski We have room for many more Picketts in our team 🤣🤣🤣
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
@whatwhat say what any prediction on McAdam. I think if we are truly serious and ruthless, then he’s definitely cut. But Tim Lamb got him the 3-year deal (one of many mistakes) so might stay . He’s contracted but it’s a charity deal that should at least be classified as a tax write off for 2024 and 2025. Will be 31yo at virtually the start of 2026 year with injuries ruining the past two years.
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
@whatwhat say what given you want to keep Fullarton, what’s your proposed changes? To free up the 6 or 7 list vacancies as needed?
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
Yes agree that we need to also look at trade offers I’m perhaps in the minority but I’m wanting to keep Oliver and Petracca. Oliver has shown so many signs of his return to near his very best and with a full preseason, our Clarry could be set for a huge 2026. Trac needs a coach and psych to get him to remember his elite play and not the reluctant player who is scared to kick goals and too easily brushed aside in tackles. He had a nearly year and I can see being close to getting back. Six months of someone teaching him how to kick again will be surely enough. Mcvee? Really want to keep him but if he desperately wants to go, then we must get the best deal in picks of players Salem? Lever? Who would want these guys and give us any true value … unlikely imv Sparrow? Adem Yze’s lovechild when Yze was at the Dees. He might fit into the Tigers rebuild plans.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Agree. They see the stats and go wow !!! He was okay but pies best were Degoey and the Daicos-j. Brownlow should be 3 Degoey 2- Gawn 1- Langford It’s a joke if N.Daicos gets votes for that game. A joke !!! Might ask Mrs Dillon who will win the Brownlow
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
Pending … buffering… on standby … to be considered … early thoughts MFC list first review before trades/delisting key tall defenders: May, Tmcd, Adams *ADD DERKSEN …add him and have one more year for May and one more year for Tmcd tall defenders: Lever, D.Turner, Hore❌. *One more year for Lever. Hore delisted med/sml/running defenders: Rivers, Bowey, Salem, Mcvee, Howes, AMW, KBrown , Sestan *KBrown one more year perhaps … Salem hangs in but might get a good desl elsewhere … Sestan one more year inside Mids: Petracca, Oliver, Viney, Sparrow, Laurie⭕️ Tholstrup, Langford *I think Laurie goes. Sadly never given a go and he needs to get a chance elsewhere. Tom Sparrow is a great young bloke but he’s giving us little and if Yze wanted him at tiger land, I’d do a deal outside Mids: Langdon, Windsor, Lindsay, Woey jnr💔, Culley , Billings ❌ *???Woey jnr …will watch the Casey finals series closely to see what he shows . Billings having a great year for Casey but I think will be delisted key forwards: JVR, Petty, Fullerton ❌, Jefferson , Johnson, Kentfield * Fullerton goes … Jeffo stays for one more year med-tall forwards: Fritsch, Melksham McAdam❌ *perhaps one more year for Melksham, though I’m not as sure as other posters that he can go on. I’ve never been a fan of the McAdam trade and a ruthless club would cut him small forwards: Pickett, Chandler, Spargo⭕️, Sharp, Mentha, Henderson❌ *Charlie needs to go. 8 possessions and zero scoreboard impact is not good enough. Likely trade for Derksen or get compo as a FA . Henderson is a good VFL player and that’s it imv 7 off the list - Spargo, Fullerton, Hore,McAdam , Billings, Woey jnr, Laurie (Henderson was top up SSP) Add Derksen + add another mature player Add Culley as upgrade to rookie Add White and Sinnema Add 2 youngsters in the draft
-
Welcome to Demonland: Harvey Langford
Langford v Pies ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 74% time on ground 26 possessions 1 goal (from right on 50 with one step and bang!!) 92% disposal efficiency 7 marks 7 score involvements 665 metres gained Dees best first year player 2025 ⭐️ Hope he gets some Brownlow votes for last night and high up in this weeks coaches votes He is our rising star
-
POSTGAME: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Thank you Oliie fan. @beelzebub Chaplin was poor again. May on Elliott. It was a poor decision. I’m glad he’s not in the running as senior coach. Also when he put Gawn forward , needed then to tell the other forwards to [censored] CLEAR OUT and leave GAWN & Kozzzy in the 50arc. !!
-
Losing it ourselves
“We've got to learn how to win again." Max Gawn reflects on Melbourne's season. Well said Max. Won 7 Lost 16 Lost 5 Beaten well and truly (NM, Suns, Hawks2, Cats, bombers) Lost 5 we were in the game & could have got into a winnable position. (Crows, Power, Bombers, Hawks 1, Saints1) Lost 6 where we LOST IT after being in front in the late stages (Giants, Pies KB, Saints2, Blues, Dogs, Pies2) … win 4 of these AS WE AT LEAST SHOULD HAVE and its a 11-12 season. If …
-
2025 AFL National Draft prospects: The next batch
Just caught up on action from last weeks games Stingrays v Rebels Noah Hibbins Hargreaves. 5 goals. 29 possessions. 21 kicks. 8 marks. Standout player. He was clearly best on ground. Tarion Ah-mu Two goals 16 kicks 10 marks He is AFL quality as a big forward. Can mark , lead and kick straight. I really wish the Dees had the balls to push for his NGA inclusion How many Pacific Islander players in the AFL Maybe one!!!! It’s ridiculous the preference for other teams and inclusions Sam Lewis Very impressive in midfield. He was able to win the footy in contest and either connect by hand or spread and clear himself. One grab type which is what impressed me. His kicking is penetrating and covers distance. Rank him ahead of Callum Smith. Memo to JT… he is a worthy late pick in my view
-
VOTES: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
6 OLIVER Clarry we love ya Return of the king 87% disposal efficiency. Please stay for 2026 5 GAWN the King Definite All Australian Smashed the pretense of Cameron If only our players could kick it to him when resting forward 4 LANGFORD wow he’s going to be the real deal Composed beyond his years Only 74% game time Great goal Our MFC RISING STAR 3 FRITSCH He did his job Good goals with smart play Very reliable kick once again 2 RIVERS Run and run A few errors but his determination are what’s needed 1 LANGDON Just a great first half on 35filth Seemed to get moved to a half forward role after 1/2 time apologies to Salem, Trac, Bowsa. Trac had another yet another NEARLY game
-
Losing it ourselves
Collingwood were 0-5 for wins when trailing at 3/4 time. Dont worry. It’s the Dees that will choke. Melbourne had some small chance for revenge. For the finals knock out For Maynard ruining Gus’ career For the Kings Birthdsy 1 point For stopping us from making the finals in 2017 For the May line … “ we are better than them” For the Ed Langdon … no duck line For stopping Daicos win the Brownlow For the whole of the AFL General population. But no , Dees break your heart Seriously 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
-
Losing it ourselves
4th Trac goal 👏 [censored] win it win it have to win it 7-15 pies 11-5 Dees Trac runs into 45m and skews it 🤬kick the goal mate McVee 🤬dumb Kozzzzy 🤬lil funky dinky kick … turnover Pies goal Trac miss 🤬 Salem kick it up and up and you are ****ttttt!!🤬Gawn was there Rivers miss 🤬from 45 metrs … kozzzzy free Rebound down the centre and Pies goal Sparrow 12 metres out and mark .. no !!! 🤬 JVR miss 🤬 May 🤬🤬🤬🤬under zero pressure. Turnover Pies goal … in front !!! Dees are so dumb Bowey turnover 🤬 dumb footy Pies goal Trac miss 🤬🤬☠️ Langdon miss 🤬 Sharp too dumb to tap to Langdon for a certain goal 🤬 Game over Pies 11.16 4 goals 1 behind in last 16 minutes Versus dees 5 behinds !!! As bad as loss and as embarrassing as the Saints loss We try hard really hard but are so dumb and we lost it ourselves Glory to Collingwood … get fuc&)&)d
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
4th Trac goal 👏 [censored] win it win it Trac 🤬kick the goal McVee 🤬 Kozzzzy 🤬 Pies goal Trac miss 🤬 Salem kick it up and up and you are ****ttttt!!🤬 Rivers miss 🤬 Pies goal JVR miss 🤬 May 🤬🤬🤬🤬under zero pressure. Turnover Pies goal in front of!!! Bowey turnover 🤬 Pies goal Trac miss 🤬🤬☠️ Langdon miss 🤬 217 to play
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
3rd Melksham miss - snap 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬 Bowey is losing it 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬hit a target mate Viney. Trac. Sparrow skills are [censored]. “BLOW A CERTAIN GOAL”🤡🤡🤡🤡 Kozzzz$$&&y goal Langford ❤️💙❤️💙 Fritsch goal Fritsch goal Dees 59-48 Then … 💔Trac doesn’t jump 💔Bowey !! Kick it 💔💔💔💔pies goal to crisp Then Oliver to Fritsch to Melksham ❤️💙 26 seconds left … yes suck that you ****nnn magpie filthy [censored] [censored]
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Sparrow is tagging … himself. Had such a poor year. Call Yze and ask if Tigers will take him for a 2nd round pick
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
We can still win this … page 17
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Bomb it to a pack Anyone interested in “Leading to the footy”
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
1/2 time Pies 46-33 Dees Langdon tag on that filthy35 👏 Gawn is a star 👏 Clarry getting back to Clarry 👏 Viney tackles 👏 Langford is very good and bright future 👏 @binman ☠️killed at centre clearances 4-8 ☠️tackles in fwd50 Zero Other deeesasters ☠️Riv handball to no one ☠️Trac skill level ☠️Dees still kick up and under and high and high to fwd50 ☠️kozzzy disinterested… hardly chasing ☠️umps … where’s 50 for Oliver… where is free to petty for Frampton punch … why 35fikth is flop and free ☠️Dees handballing is mostly wasted ☠️May has lost it … farewell Tmcd … Melksham looked cooked with a lazy left foot snap
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Issue 6. Petracca skill Is ****ttttt
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Issue 5. Centre clearances FARRRRK
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
Melksham!!!
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
FREE KICK COLLINGWOOD HANDBSLL HANDBALL HANDBALL MADNESS
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
1, move Howes forward 2,hit a target 3,tackle Salem use your possessions
-
2025 MFC Injury List
Out injured this week Dees 💔Windsor Lever Lindsay Pies ❌Hill