Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
Bailey Williams
Agree. I rate Ely Smith as top 20. Others had him in 20s/30s but he is the modern ready to play type. Strong. Quick. Clearance king. Great handball. Kicking is satisfactory but not elite. He gets it and distributed by hand. Not unlike Oliver and they would be two absolute bulls.
-
Bailey Williams
Twomey is joking. Bailey Williams is definitely top 30. Top 20 for me given size, athleticism, combo as ruck or key forward, and skills. Leap can get him over taller opponents. Definitely be gone by 30. I think we’d have to seriously consider.
-
Daniel Menzel
It’s a No from me. Good offensive player but chase and tackle is nil. But I trust Goodwin to structure his team. If Goody thinks he’d be a plus, then I’d support him.
-
Phantom Drafts - 2018
33- swans used points match Keiran Briggs - Giants 34-Bombers Damon Greaves 35- Lions Fraser Turner 36-Saints Tom Berry 37-Tigers. Conor Idun 38- Swans James Rowbottom 39- Swans Mitch Riordan 40- Swans Jacob Kennerley 41- Pies used points 42- Kangas used points 43- Freo Dillon Oreilly 44-Pies Jacob Koschitzke 45-Bulldogs Campbell Hustwaite 46-Saints Jack Bytel 47-Kangas Will Golds 48-Kangas Sam Fletcher 49- Kangas Chris Jansen 50- Cats Luke Foley 51- Pies Thomas Jok 52-Giants used points 53-Hawks Angus Hanrahan 54- Demons Joe Ayton-Delaney
-
Phantom Drafts - 2018
26- swans used points 27- bulldogs used points 28- Demons. Xavier Duursma 29- Suns. Chayce Jones 30- Lions. Connor Mcfayden 31- Freo. Sydney Stack 32- Bulldogs. Luke English
-
Phantom Drafts - 2018
Sorry Swans and Bulldogs will have to lose these picks #26 and #27 to use the points to get Blakey and West
-
Welcome to Demonland Toby Bedford
It worked with Bailey Fritsch last year. He was undisciplined, crazed and injury prone. Bargain selection at 31.
-
Welcome to Demonland Toby Bedford
I think Bedford has some injury concerns and discipline issues. Very risk pick for any club to nominate except for the Dees
-
Bailey Williams
Yes Bailey Williams has had an up and down year. I rate him very highly. Hard to judge his value in the draft as a high potential ruck/fwd type. I think he could be a very very good player and I think he is rated between 10-20 and should likely go to Crows, Tigers or Bulldogs. He would be a good pickup at 23 or 28 if available.
-
2019 best 22 and depth chart
Tall backs May Frost Omcd Petty Keilty (R) Mid/tall. Lever. Jsmith. Wagner. mid backs Hibberd Salem Lewis small backs. Jetta 12 mid inside Oliver Viney Brayshaw Harmes Jones Maynard (R) mid outside. Kolodjashnij Hunt. Stretch. Baker. 10 Tall fwd. Tmcd. Weideman TSmith (R) mid fwd. Melksham Petracca. Fritsch. ANB. VDHberg. Hannan sml fwds. Spargo. Garlett jkh. 12 ruck. Gawn. Preuss 2 there are many other variations with Petracca ANB able to go into midfield or Brayshaw to go outside mid as required. Salem can go into the midfield. Kolo Baker Hunt can go back as running half backs. We have 8 spots to fill. The key areas for me are 1- more midfield class. You can never have enough (see Pies and Eagles) draft options - Xavier O’Halloran or Tom Mckenzie or Xavier Duursma (at 23 or 28 or both) 2- crumbing forward. (Garlett can step up but we need more goal kickers) draft options - Toby Bedford (pick 54 or 62 likely) Zac Foot or Nick Hind (pick 91, rookie option) 3- tall forwards. Yes we need to build up in case tmcd/Weid have injury or form issues. draft options - Hudson Garoni, Haydn McLean (either at pick 91 or rookie) 4- young ruck. I see a spot for a youngster here to develop at Casey. (Bradtke is on list as Cat B) draft options - Bailey Williams (at #28 if available) , Stephen Cumming (rookie option) 5- small back. Cover for Jetta. draft options - Jay Lockhart or Marty Hore (either at pick 62,91,rookie)
-
Delisting, Trade and FA discussion 2018
Crumbing pressure forward. Nick Hind. Excellent year for Essendon vfl team.
-
Delisting, Trade and FA discussion 2018
Depth inside mid - Mav Weller. 1 year contract. Physically ready.
-
PICKS # 26 & 31 (formerly # 23 & 28)
McHenry is a Spargo type. Like Gresham of the Saints. We have one of these already. Small midfield fwd pocket type. Disposal is 50/50. Cats might grab him as a local product. Luke Valente SA U18s skipper is a very good midfielder who will go to either Crows or Power. No relation to “Shane Valenti”. Xavier Duursma- fingers crossed. Son of Dean Duursma. Nephew of Jamie.
-
Farewell Jesse Hogan
Good luck Jesse. You are welcome back anytime. I know how important family is, especially given your last 2 years.
-
PICKS # 26 & 31 (formerly # 23 & 28)
Khamis is tied to Bulldogs who will match the pick. He is certainly worth 20-35 pick. Bailey Williams is probably either going to get picked 13 by Crows, 17 by tigers or 19 by giants. Hard to see him lasting to 23 but never know come the night.
-
Welcome to Demonland Toby Bedford
Bedford is quick. No doubt. Whilst he doesn’t get the footy 25 times a match, his danger is tackling, pressure, goalkicking and assists. Definitely worth any draft pick after 50.
-
Phantom Drafts - 2018
I’m optimistic about Duursma. I am a fan of Tom McKenzie for his pace and hope he might last to 28. He is another gun.
- Jay Lockhart
-
Phantom Drafts - 2018
Crystal ball view to pick 28 Very cloudy though !!! 1-Blues. Sam Walsh 2- Suns. Jack Lukosius 3- Suns. Conor Rozee 4- Saints. Bailey Smith 5- Power. Izak Rankine 6- Suns. Max King 7- Bulldogs Ben King 8- Crows. Jackson Hateley 9- Giants. Riley Collier-Dawkins 10- Power Luke Valente match - Nick Blakey. Swans 11- Giants. Jye Caldwell match - Tarryn Thomas. kangas 12- Cats. Ed McHenry 13- Crows Bailey Williams match - Isaac Quaynor. pies 14- Freo Ian Hill 15- Power Curtis Taylor 16- Crows Ely Smith match - Rylee West. Bulldogs 17- Tigers Sam Sturt 18- Lions Liam Stocker 19- Giants Zak Butters 20- Eagles. Jordan Clark match - Will Kelly Pies 21- Crows Jez McLennan 22- Eagles Jarrod Cameron 23- Demons Xavier O’Halloran Match - Bailey Scott Kangas 24-Suns Tom McKenzie 25- Giants Riley Bowman 26- Swans Sydney Stack match - Connor McFayden Lions 27- Bulldogs Chayce Jones 28- Demons Xavier Duursma
-
Recruiting a 3rd tall forward to find another 50 goals?
Petracca can step up with a 40+ goal season in the stars.
-
2019 best 22 and depth chart
Jones and Lewis. Hard to see them in best 22 for round 1. Though I will have Jonesy in my team for the reason he gives heart and soul. Might be needed in the long season for midfield rotations.
-
Delisting, Trade and FA discussion 2018
Delisted free agents are all pretty slim pickings. Agree Mav Weller is the only one that I’d call right now. One year deal. Physically ready. Tough. No backwards steps. Fits Harmes mould. Good depth. Protects new young draftees at Casey.
-
Welcome to Demonland Toby Bedford
Agree. We will likely use 54 or 62 on Bedford or those points. I think the earliest nominated offer for him could be Bulldogs at 45. He has the skills and pace that we need. Needs 12 months in Casey development at least.
-
PICKS # 26 & 31 (formerly # 23 & 28)
Yes I didn’t mean Bedford at 28. He’ll probably get a nomination in the 40s so we will have the use pick 54 points. Or use pick 54 if he lasts. Either way we should draft Bedford so no need to get McHenry.
-
PICKS # 26 & 31 (formerly # 23 & 28)
Possibly we could draft late or perhaps rookie Hayden McLean (19yo from Sandringham VFL). Looked promising in 2017 under 18s year and developed again in 2018 versus vfl men. Needs to get more development but handy youngster who has the agility to play key forward. Josh Jenkins type.