IRW

I had to remind myself he was playing ( a little like Jackson actually ) because there was a swarm of magpies all over the ground and he was pretty irrelevant to proceedings

I think the Pies are are a very attractive and exciting team. Not their supporters though. I would only support Doggas team to keep Collingwood out of the G/F

Of all the disasters that have befallen our suburban footy competition Gil is the worst. Has he done anything at all of value ?

That was thev " at our mythical best you all go on about" . I didn't say we weren't contenders now or even that we wernt very good last finals.I did say beating Footscray was nothing to boast about because they arnt that good. Bang Bang Bang was very very good. You can't even see that we are off the pace and we cracked under pressure on Friday ? Running old memes isn't analysis it's what commentators say because they have run out of ideas ,you numpty

Geelong couldn't play any worse but got it done?? Seriously? If this weekend is your marker then we should be worried about the Lions. The Pies would have run all over us on this week's showing. Even May and Petty wouldn't hold them up. At least Geelong didnt ship their daks and crumble onder the pressure like the Dees This almost mythical "we're the best when we are at our best " is becoming a hilarious fantasy meme. It's never happened. Last year we only beat a crook Cats team and no one should consider beating Footscrsy a triumph . That's not loyalty it's delusional

No chance

I bet he won't and will probably play Trac and Spargo and anyone else who can walk unaided. Which is why JVR and every other possible change hasnt had a run in the team to date. This bloke isn't a coaching genius despite last years success. Not by a long shot

Did you watch the Cats fumble all day today or is it just a MFC thing in your mind. Group think

A bit less bombing it high to pockets and more Fitta to space with TMac and Max going to the hot spots might help. Silly I know and its probably too late to change ,but it would give Kossi his chance to take that mark of the year he's inclined to attempt

The coaching failures over time come to fruition when there are no previous alternatives from Casey trialed from when we were 10 zip but patchy...and show up when the players are interviewed and say " we have that ferocious edge going" and the like . Shut that presumptuous crepe down until the game is over is the job of someone on the coaching staff I understood you were on the blame Melksham for anything band wagon that runs around here. My mistake apparently I can't see TMac being ready given his slow build to form in the past. Obviously he's an option...but I'd get rid of BBB myself and trust the forward line smalls to work harder But yes overall they cracked under pressure all around the ground,there's only so many times May and Petty can stop it without mistakes creeping in. So Longmire prepared his team better than Goodwin?

Happy to be mistaken. We will see

Yeah two crucial misses and half the team fell over or handpassed to Sydney all night. He was pressure and as much as they need extra big tall strong I'd almost play TMac for rag doll Brown and hope Fritta and Gawn can catch it. Max doesn't tap to our players anyway . Problem with TMac is I don't think he comes back from foot injuries with any sort of form to speak of. That's me jogging past you while you blame Melksham for bad coaching an game wide lousy decisions from the Captain down

Yeah post game frustration on my part 200cm 100 kg and competes like a rag doll ,albeit one who can kick straight. But the only alternative if TMac isn't ready is Weideman and that's just crazy

Melk out..? Maybe but were you actually there or watching on TV...two different performances

The reason we have no one coming through to cover for injuries and poor form is that the Coach regularly says he will be " ok " or flatly refuses to change a problematic line up..experiment even ,when an opportunity arises. Mind you we'd want Trac if he was 95% good to go

Yeah, but they can't drop the Captain . He was shocking all night

Who has to come in to get rid of BBB? TMac or Van Rooyen? Harmes will be suspended

Harmes likely won't play before round 2 next year.

That's a win win tip any way you spin it

Gawn endless bad decisions May carried the team Petty is a champ Kossie is not Flash ..is not Eddie is not LJ , Melk 2 vital misses Trac Dusty 80 % Jackson left for home. BBB 200cm 100kgs ragdoll Salem ok I guess Sydney organised and committed MFC can't stand pressure Viney standard setting fumbles Ollie can't fault him Harmes round one 2023

No Goodwin is a lousy match day coach

Try to grow up you'll be much happier

I am not sure and would struggle to explain it but I think it is possibly that they could advance to the flag by defeating in sequence .... Sydney then Collingwood then Geelong !!!!!!! I mean how good would that be? Respect, then no respect , then who is the best?

So will he

I am ust waiting to hear the pompous outrage on here when he gets the gig as captain