olisik

Love it how all these posters are saying 'we should get in Patton and Cameron's managers ear' however none can answer this.

This debate will go on for decades, I can see it already A million things can happen, lets say Vineys OP gets the better of him and Lachie Whitfield goes on to win a brownlow. Imagine the amount of 'Cant beleive we chose Viney over Whitfield to keep his old man happy' threads there ll be. Every possibility will be explored, its not as simple as saying 'we are taking him thats it' like what alot of posters here are saying at the moment. The club has even said themselves that they will only take him if suitable. We will find out at the bidding table in a few months time the out-come. My guess is that GWS and GC wont risk it.

Please suggest who you think would be a good fit to give GWS in return? I am still waiting for someone to suggest something that would be feasible to give GWS in return.

The success of the club is a bigger factor then the 'happiness' of a few people

Blease and mid round compo to GWS 17 yr old pick to port & handshake agreement not to bid on Viney Boak to MFC Pay for Cloke Petterd and pick 3 to GC for there pick 2 and handshake agreement We get pick 2, 4 Viney, Boak and Cloke We lose Petterd, Blease, pick 12 and some coin

I saw Garland bash and crash a pack in great style against GWS, looked like he was bowling some pins over. He isn't that big though that pack did crash when he hit it

Please suggest a good feasible player swap Undeeterred Love it how u highlight just 1 out of the 4 names i threw out there though do not have any constructive input at all into the suggestions

I know we need mids, but we will also need a J Darling player type coming through to (Better to start early why we have higher draft picks) What type of Key forwards are expected to go high in the draft this year? Anything special or is it really that mid-heavy?

Wonder if any straight player swap for boak would be feasible here? Martin - How is ports ruck stocks going? Trengove - Boak seems to be performing better, would this ruin the MFC culture? Rivers - Playing the best he has for his career, his value now would be better then ever and will diminish in next few years Blease - Young with potential, could be upset that his mate scully left?

No, i just like to throw out diff scenario ideas and suggestions and be creative rather then just critique other peoples posts then go and post similar ideas a few months later such as you do. I will ask again, can PSD picks be traded?

Love it how we are in the mix for everything (17 yr olds, cloke, boak, Viney ect) With this in the paper other teams may try make a play for our pick 4 and it could work the other way around with teams approaching us offering the above for this pick.

We dont need to use pick 4 to beat Geelong when pick 12 will beat them anyway. Only competition we may have by using pick 12 is that the Bulldogs can trump us, however are they willing to give up there first rounder?

Your forgetting Cloke!

Anyone know if once we lock Viney in with our 2nd rounder, if its possible to still swap our 2nd round pick? so another team gets an upgrade. Could be useful for trade scenario's. We could do a 2nd round swap with Collingwood, so it would be say pick 22 for pick 36 or so?

hmmm oh yeh damn, looks like i was assuming side-deals would be made but then we wouldn't be able to make it with everyteam would need to look like this then Cloke (On big coin) Martin (First 17 year old for our first rounder) Toumpas/Stringer (First compo pick) Boak (Mid-round compo pick + 3rd round pick or possible 2nd round pick upgrade? if thats possible? anyone know the rules about this? or PSD pick if possible? or a good player who wont get a game with all these players added. We can try to make some of our fringe players look good before seasons end if we play against bad teams) Viney (2nd Round Pick)

Cloke (On big coin) Martin (First 17 year old for our first rounder) Toumpas/Stringer (First compo pick) Boak (Mid-round compo pick + 2nd round pick) Viney (3rd Round Pick) Can we trade picks from PSD? I am sure a player here and there can make the above feasible

how have i not taken into account the f/s bidding? if we are already discussing things with port then whats stopping us from discussing things with GWS. And in my scenario i did mention (IF gc dont bid) meaning i understand that the bidding process is before trade week

Some people here would say the complete opposite, none being right however as X-factor is a non measurable attribute that people have different interpretations of

that with the big coin going to cloke and we are laughing

try package our 2nd rounder and mid-first rounder. then tell gws they can have our first rounder for first 17 yr old with that, we can get 17 yr older, stringer/toumpas, boak and viney (3rd round) (if GC dont bid, which is a high possibility)

i don't know why Couch was elevated, am i the only one here who thinks he is over-rated? I actually see him as being the worst player on our list, harsh but someone has to take that spot. He is the same type of player as Magner and Moloney, just not as good.

Love it how everyone brings 'X Factor' into play. it seems to get thrown around a lot on demonland, my guess is that it gets thrown around a lot because its not a measurable attribute so no-one can be proved wrong by saying someone has/has not any 'X - Factor'

we need a little live wire in our forward line desperately, hopefully Nev can get into the senior team to fill that role Also when you see LJ 2 - 4 weeks, it may as well say LJ - Season Last time it was 2 - 4 weeks for his wrist it ended up being 10 months

So you have said, whats your point or saying this time and time again?

What is the point of this thread? To praise an opposition player with no realistic suggestions on what feasibly would get him to the club?