Winners at last

Or infections ...

It was a ridiculous decision. The commentators virtually never call out shocking decisions, although Richo did say "Bruce was a bit stiff".

Mr Floppy. I hate the way the commentators don't call out the fact that the decision was disgraceful.

I think it's better for PA to win rather than Dogs. Realistically Port are certain to finish top 4, so it's better that other teams vying for fourth sport lose.

Agree with all these comments. My son was a friend of his daughter. Went to his house/met him. Jealous.

Umpires loving the Saints.

It's better for us if the Saints lose tonight ....

Is it just me, but does anyone else here hate the filth?

For some reason the words 'excruciating' and 'execrable' spring to mind. Can't believe that people actually find that dross entertaining ... Dunstall comes across as a nasty piece of work and Gaze seems like a pleasant enough bloke but not much upstairs.

Interesting discussion about Tommo. He's obviously not a great player, but I think he should stay at least until Petty comes back. I agree with the comments made by others that with him in the side, it frees up Lever to do his best work. Lever shouldn't play on Mihocek or Cox (when forward). He can play on a small. I think that Hibbert should line up on Elliott. So, it's Oliver/Hibbert in. And Bowey out. So, the second out? Either Chandler/ANB/Spargo. The FD won't drop ANB ... my thought is Spargo ... he seems to be doing odd things ... running round in circles. I wouldn't drop Kozzy, although his form has been poor he is a potential match winner. I'd give him the occasional run on the ball to get him into the match. I'm a bit concerned about Gus' form. His disposal has been quite a bit off.

I'm an MCC member, and always sit there. FWIW I'm also a MFC member! I can't believe that the MCC allows filth people in as members. Surely there should be proper vetting procedure. I can say that there are plenty of MCC members who aren't doctors/lawyers etc. Anyone can join (subject of course to paying entry fee/annual fees) ... So, to that extent it isn't elitist. One of the worst experiences I recently had was at the finals last year. It was a filth match. Sitting behind me was an elegant woman (a radio/tv personality) with her husband (filth supporter) and their daughter, who looked about 12 y.o. The husband spent the entire match yelling (aggressive) abuse at the umpires, and telling her daughter that there was a conspiracy against Collingwood. What a shocking example to his daughter? To answer the obvious question, I would have moved if I could, but the area was full. I hate the filth.

Thanks Kev. I presume that there will be a training seesion at Gosch's Paddock this week? If so, what day?

Despite the standard of the match I had a fantastic time. I went with my 2 beautiful daughters ... their first match this year, elder being a new mother, and the younger down from Sydney for a few days. Dinner at the ground and beaut seats. Sitting near my incredibly annoying Blues supporter mate, and listening to him whining about umpiring. And sitting behind another Blues supporter who was making absolutely hilarious comments during the match. (Seriously!) Sadly he disappeared after half time. And after the match, meeting up with another Demons' mate in the Blazer Bar for a celebratory drink. We don't sit together at the match, but if the Demons win, we always meet up there post match. (Don't bother if we lose.) Excuse my ramblings, but it really was a great night ... particularly the being with my daughters' part.

He's a very good exponent of the set shot. He has a very uncomplicated kicking routine.

I've been to every MFC home match this season. Please excuse me for not going on KB. Quite simply the filth people do my head in with their constant booing, yelling "ball" every few seconds and the ridicuous "USA, USA" chant. I hate the filth (to quote my ex wife)"with every fibre of my being". Although she said it in a different context. I promise to go to every other MFC home match this season ... and even matches at Marvel !! Am I forgiven?

I'll be at the match with my 2 beautiful daughters (younger one down from Sydney) ... and before the match at a function at the G. They are both Demons, of course. Hopefully the team does the right thing to make it a truly memorable night. But sadly I haven't been vaccinated for MFCSS.

Re McKay's kicking for goal .... For some reason I'm reminded of Travis Cloke kicking 7.0 against us years ago.

Big stakes ... playing for the Vin Catoggio Cup.

We need to bring in another tall, possibly Tomlinson. (Why do peeps call him Thommo? There's no 'h' in his name, and it can't even be justified on a phonetic* basis!! Sorry.) If not him, then I guess it's Schache or Smith. No way Lever should play on McKay or Curnow. *Isn't it ironic that the word 'phonetic' is not spelt phonetically? It should be spelt 'fonetic' ?

I was at the 1987 PF too. Yes, it was so, so bad. I woke up the next morning hoping it had been a bad dream. Having said that, it didn't cost us a flag. We would have been thumped in the GF the following week by (coincidentally) Carlton.

There should be a separate thread about Cerra/MRO decisions. Rather than hijack the pregame thread.

Cerra ... lol. Is anyone seriously surprised? Cripps will play.

HH ... it's a yes from me too.

An additional tall defender must come in. I guess it has to be one of Tomlinson (most likely) or Smith or Schache. I'm not a huge fan of any of those gents, but Lever can't play on McKay or Curnow. As has been said repeatedly, he's not a particularly good one on one defender. He needs to be the third man up/inteceptor.